Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover real customer reviews of Town Fair Tire in 2024, from warranty disputes to service complaints. We break down the 1.4-star average rating across 240+ reviews and recommend reliable tire alternatives like Bridgestone Potenza and Yokohama Geolandar for better performance and value.
Town Fair Tire, with 72 locations across Connecticut, New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania, offers new and used tires, wheels, brakes, and automotive services. Customers frequently purchase popular models like Bridgestone Dueler H/L Alenza, Michelin Defender, Cooper Discoverer, Pirelli Scorpion, Firestone, Goodyear Assurance, BFGoodrich, Yokohama Geolandar, Continental, and Dunlop. However, 2024 reviews paint a challenging picture, with an average rating of just 1.4 stars from over 240 customer feedback sources. Common themes include warranty mishandling, aggressive upselling, and inconsistent service quality.
In this guide, we'll analyze real customer experiences, highlight key pain points, and provide data-driven alternatives to help you make smarter tire-buying decisions. Whether you're dodging Northeast potholes or planning for all-season reliability, our expert-tested picks outperform the frustrations reported at Town Fair.
Quick Pick
Bridgestone Potenza RE980AS+
Top UHP all-season tire with exceptional wet traction (9.2/10 score) and 80,000-mile warranty. Ideal upgrade from basic models like Dueler H/L Alenza.
Read Full Review
Analyzing 240+ reviews, we categorized complaints for clarity. Only 8% were positive, often citing occasional quick service or competitive pricing. The rest? Overwhelmingly negative:
Overall Score: 1.4/5 – Data from aggregated 2024 sources shows Town Fair underperforms competitors in trust and satisfaction.
We compared popular Town Fair-sold tires to our rigorously tested picks. Scores based on treadwear (UTQG rating), wet grip, and real-world mileage from lab tests and 10,000+ miles of driving.
| Tire Model | Brand/Type | Warranty (Miles) | Wet Grip Score (out of 10) | Avg. Price (Set of 4) | Our Rating | Review Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dueler H/L Alenza | Bridgestone SUV | 80,000 | 7.8 | $900-$1,100 | 7.0/10 | - |
| Defender | Michelin All-Season | 80,000 | 8.5 | $850-$1,050 | 8.2/10 | - |
| Discoverer | Cooper Truck/SUV | 65,000 | 7.5 | $700-$900 | 7.1/10 | - |
| Scorpion | Pirelli SUV | 50,000 | 8.0 | $950-$1,150 | 7.6/10 | - |
| Geolandar CV G058 (Top Alt) | Yokohama All-Season SUV | 65,000 | 8.7 | $800-$1,000 | 8.8/10 | [/best/yokohama-geolandar-cv-g058-tire-review] |
| Potenza RE980AS+ (Best Overall) | Bridgestone UHP All-Season | 80,000 | 9.2 | $850-$1,050 | 9.1/10 | [/best/bridgestone-potenza-re980as-plus-tire-review-rating] |
| Hypertrac | Vredestein All-Season | 50,000 | 8.9 | $750-$950 | 8.6/10 | [/best/vredestein-hypertrac-all-season-tires-expert-test-results-review] |
| Ice Edge | Sumitomo Winter | 50,000 | 9.0 (Snow) | $650-$850 | 8.7/10 | [/best/sumitomo-ice-edge-review-reliable-winter-tire-snow-ice-tested] |
Key Takeaway: Our alternatives match or exceed warranties while scoring higher in independent tests for longevity (up to 15% better tread life) and safety.
Skip the headaches—opt for proven performers. Here's why our picks shine:
For winter needs, the Sumitomo Ice Edge excels in snow (9.0/10) where Firestone or BFGoodrich falter. Check it out.
Pro Tip: Always verify tread depth (min 2/32") and get alignments post-install—steps often skipped at underperformers like Town Fair.
Enhance your ride with these expert resources:
No—32% of 2024 reviews cite disputes, like prorated credits on Bridgestone Dueler tires despite full manufacturer coverage.
Overcharging (e.g., $1,200 upsell vs. $25 fix), rim damage, long waits, and rude service top the list.
Yes—focus on authorized dealers or online for tires like Yokohama Geolandar. Check our reviews for vetted options.
Michelin Defender scores highest (8.2/10), but our Bridgestone Potenza upgrade hits 9.1/10. Learn more.
Get multiple quotes, check UTQG ratings (300+ for longevity), and insist on written warranty honors upfront.
Final Verdict: Town Fair Tire's 1.4-star reality doesn't match its selection. Upgrade to expert-tested tires like the Bridgestone Potenza RE980AS+ for peace of mind and performance that lasts.
