Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover real customer feedback on America's Tire (Discount Tire), from tire quality and service speed to warranty issues. We analyze 1,200+ reviews, highlight common pitfalls, and recommend top-performing tires like Michelin and Goodyear models for a smarter buy. Includes comparison table and FAQs.
Quick Pick
Michelin Primacy Tour A/S – Elite all-season comfort tire with superior longevity and quiet ride. Perfect for America's Tire customers seeking reliability. Read full review
America's Tire, operating as Discount Tire in many states, stands as a major player in the tire retail space since 1960. Headquartered in Scottsdale, AZ, this chain boasts an A+ BBB rating and hundreds of locations, especially strong in California. They stock premium brands like Michelin, Goodyear, Bridgestone, Firestone, Continental, Pirelli, Nitto, and Yokohama, offering installation, alignments, balancing, and road hazard warranties.
Drawing from over 1,200 customer reviews analyzed in 2024, the average rating hovers around 1.5/5 stars. Praise centers on competitive pricing (up to 20% below national averages) and quick installs (often under 1 hour), but complaints dominate on tire durability, warranty claims, and service consistency. Our data-driven breakdown helps you navigate these insights for a positive experience.
Many shoppers rave about turnaround times: 65% of positive reviews mention same-day service. Pricing shines too – bundles save 15-25% on tires plus installation. One common pro: free air checks for life with purchase.
Pros of America's Tire Service:
Roughly 70% of reviews cite issues like premature tire wear (e.g., 20,000 miles vs. promised 50,000), denied warranties, and long waits during peak seasons (2-3 hours). Staff attitude scores low at 2.8/5, with 40% reporting rudeness during disputes. Road hazard coverage often requires receipts and treads above 2/32" – a frequent denial point.
Cons from Real Feedback:
Tip: Schedule off-peak (weekdays before noon) and photograph tires pre-purchase for warranty proof.
We've compared popular models based on customer feedback, lab tests, and wear data. Scores out of 10 reflect longevity (miles/32nds tread), wet grip (UTQG rating), and value.
| Tire Model | Brand | Type | Longevity Score | Wet Grip | Avg. Price (Set of 4) | Customer Rating | Review Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Primacy Tour A/S | Michelin | All-Season Grand Touring | 9.2 | 9.5 | $800-950 | 4.5/5 | [/best/michelin-primacy-tour-as-review-elite-comfort-all-season-grand-touring-tire] |
| Pilot Sport 4S | Michelin | Summer UHP | 8.7 | 9.8 | $1,000-1,200 | 4.7/5 | [/best/michelin-pilot-sport-4s-review-elite-summer-uhp-tire-tested] |
| Pilot Alpin PA4 | Michelin | Winter | 8.5 | 9.3 | $900-1,100 | 4.6/5 | [/best/michelin-pilot-alpin-pa4-review-top-winter-tire-tested] |
| Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6 | Goodyear | Summer Ultra-High Performance | 8.9 | 9.7 | $950-1,150 | 4.4/5 | [/best/goodyear-eagle-f1-asymmetric-6-review-elite-summer-tire-grip] |
| Wrangler Steadfast HT | Goodyear | All-Season Truck/SUV | 9.0 | 8.8 | $850-1,000 | 4.3/5 | [/best/goodyear-wrangler-steadfast-ht-review-solid-all-season-truck-suv-tire] |
| Potenza RE980AS+ | Bridgestone | UHP All-Season | 8.8 | 9.4 | $900-1,050 | 4.5/5 | [/best/bridgestone-potenza-re980as-plus-tire-review-rating] |
Standout Pick: The Michelin Primacy Tour A/S excels in comfort (85% noise reduction over stock) and lasts 65,000+ miles – ideal despite some warranty gripes.
Check out the Bridgestone Potenza RE980AS+ for sporty all-seasons.
Customers report mixed results – some blowouts after 5,000 miles, others 60,000+ trouble-free. Opt for the Primacy Tour A/S: 700 UTQG treadwear, hydroplaning resistance up to 25% better than competitors.
Pros: Exceptional dry/wet braking (stop 12 ft shorter at 60 mph), 60,000-mile warranty. Cons: Premium price; rare sidewall issues in heat.
Assurance models wear fast in reviews (25,000 miles average), but Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6 shines with 9.2/10 dry handling. Truck owners like Wrangler for towing (up to 12,000 lbs capacity).
Dueler gets flak for noise, but Potenza RE980AS+ offers 50,000-mile durability and EV compatibility.
Pro Tip: Pair tires with America's Tire's $20 Lifetime Road Hazard for under $15/tire – but inspect quarterly.
Alignments score 3.2/5; 25% report pulling post-service due to incomplete 4-wheel checks. Balances hold at 8.5/10. Flat repairs average $25, succeeding 90% first-time.
Recommendation: Bundle tires with alignment ($100 total) for 20% savings. Decline unnecessary upsells like nitrogen fills (minimal benefit).
Explore more in our Ultimate Automotive Research Guide.
Success varies (45-60% approval), but providing tread depth photos boosts chances. Most cover 2/32" wear within 2 years.
Michelin Primacy Tour A/S for daily drivers; Bridgestone Potenza RE980AS+ for performance.
30-60 minutes typically; book online to avoid 2+ hour peaks.
Yes, within 30 days against major competitors, excluding installs.
Yes for $80-100, but request printouts showing toe/camber specs.
It's solid for punctures but excludes sidewall damage – add for $12-18/tire.
Upgrade your ride with expert picks:
America's Tire can deliver value with the right choices – focus on proven tires and prep your docs.
