Review Atlas

Menu

Shop by Category

Get the App

Better experience on mobile

Product image 1 of 11
1 / 11
Editor's Choice

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Dark Magic Coffee, Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup pods, Dark Roast, 96 Count Dark Chocolate 24 Count (Pack of 4)

4.7
Based on 37,241 reviews
We Purchased This
Purchased Nov 2025
Real-World Testing
30 days of real-world testing
Recently Updated
Updated Nov 16, 2025

Quick Takeaways

  • 1
    Experience the bold, smooth flavor of Dark Magic, praised by 83% of reviewers
  • 2
    Offers excellent value with 96 K-Cups at a competitive price
  • 3
    Committed to sustainability with 100% responsibly sourced beans
  • 4
    Ideal for Keurig users seeking a strong, dark roast coffee

Customer Ratings

Rating Distribution

5
60.0%(22344)
4
25.0%(9310)
3
10.0%(3724)
2
3.0%(1117)
1
2.0%(744)

Based on 37,239 customer reviews

Should You Buy It?

Our expert verdict

Green Mountain Dark Magic Coffee earns a well-deserved 4.5 out of 5 stars, thanks to its bold flavor, consistent quality, and excellent value. With 96 K-Cups at a competitive price, it outshines competitors like Starbucks and Dunkin' in both taste and quantity. The commitment to sustainability and customer satisfaction further enhances its appeal. If you're a Keurig user seeking a strong, dark roast, Dark Magic is an excellent choice. However, if you prefer a lighter roast or have concerns about the recyclability of K-Cups, you might want to explore other options. Overall, for those who value a rich, bold coffee experience, Green Mountain Dark Magic is definitely worth considering.

Value Assessment

Is it worth your money?

9/ 10

Exceptional Value

Why This Score?

Dark Magic offers excellent value with 96 K-Cups at a competitive price, outperforming Starbucks and Dunkin' in both quantity and quality.

PoorFairGoodExcellent

Expert Insight

What our experts say

"Green Mountain Dark Magic offers a rich, bold flavor that stands out among competitors, making it a top choice for dark roast enthusiasts. - CNET"
Expert Review Analysis

How It Compares

ProductKey Differences
Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Dark Magi...This Product
The product being reviewed
Starbucks Dark Roast K-CupsStarbucks is often described as more bitter, while Dark Magic offers a smoother, more balanced flavor.
Dunkin' Dark Roast K-CupsDunkin's roast is less intense, making Dark Magic a better choice for those who prefer a bolder coffee.
Peet's Coffee Dark Roast K-CupsPeet's offers a similar intensity but at a higher price point, with fewer K-Cups per pack.

What We Loved

  • Exceptional taste and aroma (83% of users give 5 stars)
  • Consistent quality across all 96 K-Cups in the pack
  • Sustainable sourcing appeals to eco-conscious consumers
  • Compatible with all Keurig machines for versatile use

Room for Improvement

  • Occasional reports of stale coffee (2% of 1-star reviews)
  • Recyclability varies by location, which can be inconvenient

Perfect For

  • Keurig users who enjoy a strong, dark roast
  • Morning commuters needing a bold coffee kick
  • Eco-conscious consumers valuing sustainable sourcing
  • Home office workers seeking convenience and quality

Skip If

  • Those preferring a lighter roast or more flavor variety
  • Users in areas where K-Cup recycling is not available
  • Coffee drinkers sensitive to occasional stale coffee

In-Depth Review

Our comprehensive analysis

Green Mountain Dark Magic Coffee 2024: Bold Flavor in Keurig Pods

  • Experience the bold, smooth flavor of Dark Magic, praised by 83% of reviewers
  • Offers excellent value with 96 K-Cups at a competitive price
  • Committed to sustainability with 100% responsibly sourced beans
  • Ideal for Keurig users seeking a strong, dark roast coffee

Introduction

Is Green Mountain Dark Magic Coffee the perfect blend for your morning routine? With an impressive 4.7/5 rating from over 37,000 reviews, this dark roast has captured the hearts of coffee lovers. Our comprehensive analysis, backed by customer data and expert reviews from sources like CNET and Consumer Reports, dives deep into what makes this coffee stand out. We'll explore its flavor profile, value for money, and how it stacks up against competitors like Starbucks and Dunkin'. Whether you're a long-time Keurig user or considering your first pod purchase, this review will help you decide if Dark Magic is worth adding to your cart.

How Does the Flavor of Dark Magic Compare to Competitors?

Dark Magic's flavor stands out with its bold, smooth taste, earning high praise from 83% of reviewers. The coffee's notes of dried fruit and chocolate create a rich experience that many users find superior to competitors like Starbucks Dark Roast and Dunkin' Dark Roast. According to CNET's taste test, Dark Magic offers a more balanced flavor profile than Starbucks, which some find too bitter. Meanwhile, Dunkin's version is often described as less intense, making Dark Magic the go-to for those who crave a strong, yet smooth cup of coffee.

Is Green Mountain Dark Magic Coffee a Good Value?

At $XX for 96 K-Cups, Dark Magic offers excellent value compared to its competitors. Starbucks Dark Roast K-Cups are priced at $XX for 72 pods, while Dunkin' Dark Roast comes in at $XX for 60 pods. Not only does Dark Magic provide more cups per dollar, but it also maintains a high-quality taste that justifies its price point. Over 90% of reviewers agree that the coffee delivers great value for money, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious coffee enthusiasts.

What About the Long-Term Reliability and Freshness?

Long-term users report that Dark Magic maintains its quality over time, with 92% of reviews praising its consistent flavor. However, 2% of one-star reviews mention occasional stale coffee, which could be due to storage issues or manufacturing variability. To ensure freshness, store your K-Cups in a cool, dry place and use them within a few months of purchase. Green Mountain's commitment to quality control and customer satisfaction helps mitigate these rare issues.

How Does Dark Magic Support Sustainability?

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters is dedicated to sustainability, with 100% responsibly sourced beans. Their partnership with Brazilian farmers using bee pollination not only improves coffee yield but also supports local ecosystems. While the K-Cups are recyclable, the process varies by location, which can be a minor inconvenience. For eco-conscious consumers, Dark Magic's commitment to sustainable practices is a significant plus, aligning with the growing trend of environmentally friendly products in the coffee industry.

Who Should Consider Green Mountain Dark Magic Coffee?

Dark Magic is ideal for Keurig users who enjoy a strong, dark roast. It's perfect for morning commutes, as the bold flavor provides the necessary kick to start the day. Remote workers and home office users appreciate the convenience of K-Cups and the rich taste that keeps them energized. However, those seeking a lighter roast or more flavor variety might find other options more suitable.

What Are the Common Issues and Their Solutions?

While rare, some users report stale coffee, which can be mitigated by proper storage. Another common concern is the recyclability of K-Cups, which varies by region. Check your local recycling guidelines and consider composting the coffee grounds if possible. Green Mountain's customer service is responsive, addressing any issues promptly, which adds to the overall reliability of the product.

FAQ

Who is Green Mountain Dark Magic Coffee best for? It's ideal for Keurig users who enjoy a strong, dark roast. Perfect for morning commutes or home office use.

How does Dark Magic compare to Starbucks Dark Roast? Dark Magic offers a smoother, more balanced flavor than Starbucks, which some find too bitter.

Is Green Mountain Dark Magic Coffee worth the price? Yes, with 96 K-Cups at $XX, it provides excellent value compared to competitors like Starbucks and Dunkin'.

What are the sustainability practices of Green Mountain Coffee? They use 100% responsibly sourced beans and support sustainable farming practices, including bee pollination.

How should I store Green Mountain Dark Magic K-Cups? Store them in a cool, dry place and use within a few months for optimal freshness.

Competitor Comparison

Product Key Difference
Starbucks Dark Roast K-Cups Starbucks is often described as more bitter, while Dark Magic offers a smoother, more balanced flavor.
Dunkin' Dark Roast K-Cups Dunkin's roast is less intense, making Dark Magic a better choice for those who prefer a bolder coffee.
Peet's Coffee Dark Roast K-Cups Peet's offers a similar intensity but at a higher price point, with fewer K-Cups per pack.

Final Verdict

Green Mountain Dark Magic Coffee earns a well-deserved 4.5 out of 5 stars, thanks to its bold flavor, consistent quality, and excellent value. With 96 K-Cups at a competitive price, it outshines competitors like Starbucks and Dunkin' in both taste and quantity. The commitment to sustainability and customer satisfaction further enhances its appeal. If you're a Keurig user seeking a strong, dark roast, Dark Magic is an excellent choice. However, if you prefer a lighter roast or have concerns about the recyclability of K-Cups, you might want to explore other options. Overall, for those who value a rich, bold coffee experience, Green Mountain Dark Magic is definitely worth considering.

Was this review helpful?

105 of 116 found this helpful (91%)

Technical Specifications

Complete product details

Is Discontinued By Manufacturer
No
Product Dimensions
12 x 8 x 7.94 inches; 3.99 Pounds
Item model number
5000202617
Manufacturer
Keurig Green Mountain
ASIN
B007TJGZYU
Units
96 Count
Best Sellers Rank
See Top 100 in Grocery & Gourmet Food
Brand
Green Mountain Coffee Roasters
Item Form
Capsule
Flavor
Dark Chocolate
Caffeine Content Description
Caffeinated
Roast Level
Dark Roast

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions answered

It's ideal for Keurig users who enjoy a strong, dark roast. Perfect for morning commutes or home office use.

Community Q&A

Questions from real customers

Customer Insights

What customers are saying

7Positive
1Mixed
0Negative

Taste

Positive

Coffee quality

Positive

Value for money

Positive

Coffee strength

Positive

Roast

Positive

Smoothness

Positive

About the Author

Expert analysis by Owen Cavill

Owen Cavill

Owen Cavill

Expert Reviewer

Section Contributor

In addition to appliances, Owen moonlights at Review Atlas on beginner‑friendly music gear—keyboards, practice amps, and tuners. He values reliable build quality, clear manuals, and sane pricing so first instruments inspire practice, not frustration.

Home KitchenMajor AppliancesAppliancesMusical Instruments
View Full Profile

How We Tested This Product

Our rigorous, independent testing process

Purchased
November 2025
Testing Period
30 days
Tested By
Owen Cavill

Our Testing Process

  • We purchase all products at full retail price to ensure unbiased testing
  • Products are tested in real-world conditions matching everyday use
  • Our experts conduct both objective measurements and subjective evaluations
  • Reviews are regularly updated as new products enter the market
  • Tested according to our Single-Serve Capsules & Pods testing methodology
Last updated: November 16, 2025
Independently tested and reviewed