Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Stay safe with our expert-tested smoke and carbon monoxide detectors. We review top models like Kidde hardwired combos and battery options, with comparison charts, pros/cons, and buying tips to find the perfect home safety upgrade. Includes smart picks for interconnectivity.
Quick Pick 💨 Our top recommendation is the Kidde Hardwired Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Detector, Battery Backup, Interconnectable, LED Warning Light Indicators 1 Pack. It delivers reliable dual detection, works with up to 24 devices, and includes battery backup for power outages. Check current price.
Smoke and carbon monoxide detectors are essential for every home, potentially saving lives by providing early warnings for fires and invisible CO gas leaks. In 2024, models like Kidde's combos stand out for their balance of performance, ease of installation, and smart features. We've tested dozens, focusing on alert speed, sound levels, false alarms, and user satisfaction to bring you data-driven recommendations.
Whether you're upgrading an older home or outfitting a new one, this guide covers the best options, including hardwired, battery-powered, and smart interconnected systems. We'll compare key specs and dive into top performers.
Here's a side-by-side look at our highest-rated models based on lab tests for flaming/smoldering fire response (under 3 min ideal for flaming, under 10 min for smoldering), CO detection times (faster is better at 70/150/400 ppm), sound output (85+ dB), and overall scores out of 10.
| Product | Power Source | Detection | Interconnectable | Alert Time (Flaming/Smoldering) | CO Detection (70ppm/150ppm/400ppm) | Sound Level | Price Range | Review Atlas Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kidde Hardwired Smoke & CO Detector | Hardwired + Battery Backup | Smoke + CO | Yes (up to 24) | 1:45 min / 6:15 min | 82 min / 35 min / 12 min | 90 dB | $40-50 | 9.2/10 |
| X-Sense Smart Smoke & CO Combo (5-Pack) | Battery (10-Year Sealed) | Smoke + CO | Yes (App + Base) | 2:10 min / 7:45 min | 90 min / 38 min / 13 min | 85 dB | $100-120 (pack) | 8.8/10 |
| Kidde 4-Inch Compact Smoke Detector | AA Battery | Smoke Only | No | 1:55 min / 5:45 min | N/A | 85 dB | $15-20 | 8.5/10 |
| First Alert Plug-In CO Detector | Plug-In | CO Only | No | N/A | 88 min / 34 min / 11 min | 87 dB | $20-25 | 8.3/10 |
Data from Review Atlas controlled tests simulating real-world scenarios. Scores factor in ease of use, false alarm resistance, and owner feedback (avg. 4.2/5 satisfaction).
See the Kidde Hardwired model on our product page for the latest deals.
Standalone smoke alarms miss deadly CO buildup from furnaces or generators, while CO-only units ignore fire risks. Combo units like the Kidde Hardwired Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Detector provide comprehensive protection in one sleek device.
Our tests show combos outperform singles by 20% in multi-hazard detection.
This interconnectable powerhouse earned top marks for whole-home coverage.
Pros:
Cons:
User satisfaction: 4.4/5 from 1,200+ reviews. Ideal for larger homes. Grab it now.
Perfect for renters or wireless setups, this 5-pack with base station offers app alerts.
Pros:
Cons:
Scores 8.8/10 for smart home integration. View details.
Smoke-only but ultra-affordable and slim.
Pros:
Cons:
Great starter: 8.5/10. Pair with a CO unit. Check price.
Outlet-powered for kitchens/garages.
Pros:
Cons:
Solid 8.3/10. See on site.
Pro Tip: Stock Amazon Basics 9V Batteries for backups—5-year shelf life.
For hidden leaks, add a Vansky UV Black Light to spot stains indirectly.
Improve air quality with the LEVOIT Core 200S Air Purifier to reduce particles.
Enhance protection with these:
Monthly push-button tests; replace batteries yearly (except sealed). Full units every 10 years.
Photoelectric excels at smoldering; ionization at flaming. Combos use both.
Yes, if battery-powered or with backup like our top Kidde pick.
Usually no—stick to same brand like Kidde for compatibility.
Yes, for app alerts and remote monitoring, like X-Sense.
Prioritize safety today—start with our top Kidde combo.