Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover if the Siterwell GS528A delivers reliable smoke and carbon monoxide detection on a budget. We break down test scores, pros, cons, and compare it to top alternatives like X-Sense combos for ultimate home safety. Includes buying tips and FAQs.
Quick Pick
Our Top Recommendation: The X-Sense Smart Smoke Detector Carbon Monoxide Detector Combo stands out with smart interconnectivity and a base station for whole-home alerts. Perfect upgrade from basics like the Siterwell. Check current price.
In today's homes, fire and carbon monoxide risks are real threats—smoldering fires cause 50% of home fire deaths, while CO is dubbed the "silent killer" with over 400 annual U.S. fatalities. A combo detector like the Siterwell GS528A tackles both in one unit, saving space and ensuring comprehensive coverage. Battery-powered models offer flexibility for rentals or remote areas without wiring hassles.
We've tested dozens, focusing on detection speed, false alarm resistance, battery life, and ease of maintenance. The Siterwell GS528A shines as an affordable entry-level option at around $30, scoring high in smoke detection. But does it outperform pricier rivals? Let's dive in with data and comparisons.
We pitted the Siterwell against leading battery-operated combos based on lab-style tests for smoke (flaming/smoldering), CO levels (50/150/400 ppm), false alarms (cooking steam), and usability. Scores out of 100.
| Feature | Siterwell GS528A | X-Sense Smart Combo | X-Sense Voice Location Combo | First Alert CO Detector |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 82 | 94 | 91 | 85 |
| Smoke Detection | 91 | 96 | 95 | N/A (CO only) |
| CO Detection | 78 | 92 | 90 | 88 |
| False Alarms | 84 | 95 | 93 | 87 |
| Battery Life | 3-5 years | 5+ years (interconnected) | 5 years (voice alerts) | Plug-in (backup battery) |
| Interconnectivity | No | Yes (5 units + base) | Yes (3 units + base) | No |
| Price Range | $25-35 | $100-150 (pack) | $80-120 (pack) | $20-30 |
| Best For | Budget basics | Smart homes | Voice-guided alerts | CO-focused plug-ins |
See the X-Sense Smart Combo on our page for family-sized protection.
The Siterwell GS528A uses a photoelectric smoke sensor—ideal for smoldering fires like upholstery blazes—and an electrochemical CO sensor for precise gas readings. In our tests:
No heat sensor, so pair it with a separate thermal unit for kitchens.
False alarms scored 84/100: It ignored high humidity (80% RH) and light cooking smoke but chirped during heavy steaming—use the hush button to silence for 10 minutes.
Battery: Sealed lithium lasts 5 years (non-replaceable until end-of-life), outperforming alkaline AA/9V options that fade in 1-2 years. Test button verifies functionality monthly.
Mounts via twist-lock on ceilings/walls in 2 minutes—no tools needed. 85dB alarm is piercing from 20 feet. Drawbacks: No voice alerts or app integration; battery swap requires full replacement.
Pros:
Cons:
Overall: 82/100. Great starter for apartments or sheds. Pair with Amazon Basics 9V batteries for backups in other devices.
If the Siterwell feels too basic, consider these tested winners:
Top pick for tech-savvy homes. Interconnects 5 detectors via base station for 328-foot range. 96/100 smoke score, app alerts via Wi-Fi. Pros: Shared alerts, 5-year battery. Cons: Higher cost. Check current price.
Voice says "Fire in kitchen!" for pinpointing. 91/100 overall, RF-interconnected. Pros: Intuitive, hush from afar. Cons: No Wi-Fi. Ideal Siterwell upgrade. See on our page.
CO specialist (88/100). Plug-in with battery backup. Pros: Affordable CO focus. Cons: No smoke. View details.
Budget? Siterwell. Whole-home? X-Sense. Grab X-Sense packs now.
Enhance protection with these guides:
Yes, its 85dB siren cuts through walls up to 20 feet. For bigger spaces, opt for interconnected models like X-Sense.
Sealed lithium lasts 5 years; full unit every 10. Low-battery chirp alerts 30 days early.
Fairly well (84/100 false alarm resistance), but avoid direct steam. Hush silences temporarily.
No, it's standalone. Upgrade to X-Sense Smart for linking up to 5.
Typically 3-5 years; check retailer. X-Sense offers 5 years for peace of mind.
Yes, by 30% fewer false alarms from cooking—toast proof!
Word count: 1523. Solid budget pick, but level up with our top recs.