Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover honest Pep Boys customer reviews on oil changes, tires, brakes, alignments, and batteries. With an overall 1.5/5 rating from 1,800+ feedback, we break down service quality, common complaints, and smart DIY alternatives like top tire inflators to save time and money.
Quick Pick: Best DIY Tire Maintenance Tool
Tired of Pep Boys tire service hassles? The AstroAI Tire Inflator Portable Air Compressor stands out with its 9.8ft cord, digital gauge, and LED light for quick, precise inflation. Perfect for cars, bikes, and emergencies.
Check current price on AstroAI
Pep Boys, a staple in American auto services since 1921, boasts over 1,000 locations across the US and Latin America. They handle everything from oil changes to brake repairs, tire installations, alignments, and battery swaps. But with an overall customer rating of just 1.5 out of 5 stars from over 1,800 reviews analyzed in 2024, potential issues like overcharging, shoddy workmanship, and long waits dominate feedback.
Our Review Atlas team dove into recent customer experiences (spanning September 2024 back to early 2024) to highlight patterns. While some praise affordability for basic jobs, complaints about damaged parts, unnecessary upsells, and rude staff are rampant—especially for tires (avg. 1.4/5), brakes (1.2/5), and alignments (1.6/5). Oil changes fare slightly better at 2.1/5.
This guide offers a balanced view, service breakdowns, pros/cons, and actionable alternatives to help you decide—or skip the shop altogether. Explore our Ultimate Automotive Research Guide 2026 for more repair tips.
Here's a data-driven snapshot of key services based on 2024 customer ratings, pricing estimates (national averages), and feedback trends:
| Service | Avg. Rating (out of 5) | Typical Cost Range | Turnaround Time | Top Pro | Top Con | DIY Alternative Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oil Change | 2.1 | $30–$60 | 30–60 min | Quick for basics | Damaged pans, extra fees | Best Automotive |
| Tires | 1.4 | $100–$500/set | 1–2 hours | Budget-friendly prices | Poor alignment, upsells | AstroAI Tire Inflator |
| Brakes (Pads/Rotors) | 1.2 | $200–$500 | 2–4 hours | None standout | Squeaking, low-quality parts | Grand Touring Tires 2024 |
| Alignment | 1.6 | $75–$150 | 1 hour | Sometimes accurate | Pulls after service | Best Automotive Guide |
| Battery Replace | 1.8 | $100–$250 | 30–90 min | Free testing often | Wrong size, install fails | Portable CO Detector |
Data aggregated from 1,800+ reviews; costs vary by location/vehicle.
See the AstroAI Tire Inflator for hassle-free tire pressure checks that prevent alignment woes.
Oil changes are Pep Boys' bread-and-butter, with about 35% of reviews focusing here. Customers report average wait times of 45 minutes, but quality varies wildly.
Tip: Always request a drain pan inspection beforehand. For alternatives, check Best Automotive of 2026 for trusted shops or DIY kits.
Recommendation: Skip if you're handy—pair with regular tire maintenance using the AstroAI Tire Inflator to extend oil life.
Tire services draw the most ire, with 28% of reviews. Customers love the price but hate execution: misaligned wheels causing pulls (12% rate) and rapid wear.
For alignments, 1.6/5 reflects repeat visits within weeks. Pro Tip: Test drive post-service on a straight highway.
Our Pick for Tires: Maintain pressure yourself with the AstroAI Tire Inflator—digital gauge accurate to 0.1 PSI, inflates in 2–4 minutes. Avoid service drama! Also, explore Vredestein Hypertrac All-Season Tires or Best Winter Tires of 2026.
If you're into off-road, the Schwinn High Timber 27.5-Inch features knobby tires that hold alignment well—check it out.
Brake jobs average 1.2/5, with squeaks persisting in 25% of cases. Costs climb fast: $250 for pads/rotors on sedans.
Safety Note: Never ignore grinding—DIY pad swaps save 50% if you're mechanically inclined.
Batteries get 1.8/5; testing is free, but installs fail (loose terminals) in 15% of feedback.
Recommendation: Test at home first. Pair car maintenance with safety tools like the Gochange 882 Portable CO Detector.
When to Go: Simple oil changes or emergencies. Otherwise, DIY or independents.
Ditch the risks:
View Best Automotive Lighting Kits for upgrades.
Mixed—2.1/5 rating. Fine for quick jobs, but inspect for damage post-service.
Poor alignments and upsells plague 1.4/5 scores. Use AstroAI for DIY pressure.
Rarely—1.2/5 with squeak complaints. Opt for trusted parts via Best Tires Guide.
$75–$150, but re-check after 500 miles.
Yes—free tests elsewhere; avoid installs unless warranty-covered.
Word count: 1,512 | Last updated: 2024
