Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Empire BlueCross BlueShield of New York earns a low 1.3/5 rating from 1,269 reviews. We break down PPO, EPO, HMO, Medicare plans, customer complaints on claims and service, plus plan comparisons and alternatives for smarter coverage choices.
Quick Pick
Top Recommendation: PPO Plans for Flexibility – Empire's PPO offers the largest network without referrals, ideal despite service issues. For reliable alternatives, see our BlueCross Blue Shield Illinois Reviews: Pros, Cons & Alternatives 2024.
Empire BlueCross BlueShield of New York, commonly called Empire BCBS NY, serves individuals, families, and businesses across the state with a range of health insurance options. From individual PPO, EPO, and HMO plans to Medicare Advantage, supplements, and short-term coverage, plus dental and vision add-ons, Empire aims to meet diverse needs. However, with an overall customer rating of just 1.3 out of 5 stars based on 1,269 reviews, many users report frustrations with claims processing, customer service, and billing.
In this in-depth Review Atlas analysis, we examine plan details, real customer feedback themes, pros/cons, and data-driven comparisons to help you decide if Empire fits your needs—or if alternatives make more sense. We'll cover network access, costs, and coverage gaps with specific metrics for clarity.
Quickly compare core plan types below. Data draws from Empire's offerings: PPO for broad access, EPO for balanced costs, HMO for affordability.
| Feature | PPO Plans | EPO Plans | HMO Plans | Medicare Advantage (Part C) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Network Size | Large (100,000+ providers) | Medium (70,000+ providers) | Small (50,000+ providers) | Varies by county |
| Out-of-Network Coverage | Yes (50-70% higher cost) | Emergencies only | None | Limited/none |
| Referral for Specialists | No | No | Yes (PCP required) | Varies |
| Avg. Monthly Premium (Individual, Age 40) | $550-$750 | $450-$650 | $400-$550 | $0-$100 (plus Part B) |
| Deductible Range | $1,500-$3,000 | $1,000-$2,500 | $500-$1,500 | $0-$500 |
| Best For | Frequent travelers | In-network focus | Budget-conscious | Seniors bundling benefits |
Notes: Premiums estimated for 2024 NY market (pre-subsidy); actuals vary by age/location. Medicare data from Empire's Part C options.
Empire PPO plans stand out for their expansive network—over 100,000 doctors and hospitals statewide, including major NYC facilities like Mount Sinai and NYU Langone. No PCP referral needed for specialists, and out-of-network care covered at 60-80% after deductible (vs. 100% in-network).
Pros:
Cons:
Recommendation: Ideal if you value choice. Pair with Best Auto Insurance for full family protection.
EPOs shrink the network to ~70,000 providers but slash premiums by 15-20%. No referrals, but stick in-network or pay full price outside emergencies.
Pros:
Cons:
HMOs prioritize low costs with ~50,000 providers. PCP coordinates care, referrals mandatory.
Pros:
Cons:
Empire shines in senior coverage:
Pros: Extra perks like gym memberships (SilverSneakers). Cons: Network locks; 15% denial rate on non-formulary drugs.
Short-term plans bridge gaps (up to 364 days, $100-300/mo), dental covers 80% cleanings/50% crowns, vision $10-25 exams.
Aggregated insights reveal patterns:
Positive outliers (2-3 stars, ~15%): Solid for routine care, Medicare reliability. Overall, only 12% recommend.
Data Snapshot:
Overall Pros:
Overall Cons:
If network size trumps service, PPO or Medicare Advantage could work—especially urban NYers. Rural folks or those needing quick claims? Look elsewhere. Average family premium: $1,800/mo unsubsidized.
Actionable Advice:
For broader options, explore Best Life Insurance alongside health. Pet owners, check Best Pet Insurance, Dog & Cat Foods, Flea Treatments: 2024 Guide.
1.3/5 from 1,269 reviews, driven by service and claims issues.
PPO: Largest network, out-of-network OK. EPO: No referrals, in-network only. HMO: Cheapest, PCP referrals required.
Yes for bundling (dental/vision included), but check county networks.
Common issues: Pre-authorizations and documentation errors; appeal promptly.
Empire mid-tier: $500-700 individual vs. state avg $620.
Compare via marketplaces; see BlueCross Blue Shield Illinois Reviews: Pros, Cons & Alternatives 2024 for similar insights.
Word count: 1,512 | Last updated: 2024
