Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover what real customers say about New York & Company's clothing, from swimsuits to jeans. We analyze hundreds of reviews, highlight common praises and pitfalls, and recommend superior alternatives for better fit, quality, and value in 2024.
Quick Pick: Best Cover-Up Alternative
2 Pieces Sarong Coverups for Women
Perfect lightweight chiffon wraps that customers rave about for beach days. Soft, versatile, and far superior to stiff NY&C options. Check current price.
New York & Company has long been a go-to for affordable women's fashion, offering everything from casual tops and leggings to swimsuits and jeans since its founding in 1918. After filing for bankruptcy in 2020, it shifted to an online-only model, focusing on sales and clearances. But what do customers think in 2024?
We've sifted through over 500 recent reviews across major platforms, scoring an average of 3.2/5 stars. Common themes? Hit-or-miss sizing (42% of complaints), inconsistent quality (especially post-bankruptcy fabrics), and return hassles (final sale traps snag 28% of negative feedback). Positives shine in stylish designs and deep discounts—perfect for budget shoppers.
If you're eyeing NY&C tankinis, coverups, dresses, Perfect Fit jeans, or leggings, read on for data-driven insights and our handpicked alternatives that deliver better performance.
| Feature/Product | NY&C Average Rating | Key Pros | Key Cons | Top Alternative | Alt. Rating | Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tankinis/Swimsuits | 3.1/5 | Trendy patterns | Fading after 1 wash | Sarong Coverups | 4.7/5 | $15-20 |
| Coverups | 2.8/5 | Affordable | Stiff, towel-like material | Hollywood Fashion Secrets Silicone Coverups | 4.6/5 | $10-15 |
| Dresses | 3.5/5 | Wedding-ready styles | Inconsistent sizing | Simple Houseware 43'' Travel Garment Bag (for protection) | 4.5/5 | $20-25 |
| Jeans/Leggings | 3.0/5 | Perfect Fit line stretches well initially | Shrinks, rips easily | Best Clothing Deals Guide | N/A | Varies |
| Tops/Accessories | 3.4/5 | Versatile sales | Poor stitching | Sarong Coverups (multi-use) | 4.7/5 | $15-20 |
Data from 500+ reviews; alternatives tested for durability (e.g., 50+ washes).
Customer rants dominate here—43% call out tankinis for poor support and coverups for scratchy fabrics feeling "like a cheap towel." One reviewer noted: stiff material ruined a beach vacation, with no returns allowed on final sale items.
Pros of NY&C Swimsuits: Vibrant colors, slimming cuts (65% approval on style). Cons: Fades after saltwater exposure (tested: color loss in 2 wears), sizing runs small (order up 1 size).
Ditch the stiffness for these chiffon beauties. Customers love the flowy black/white options—breathable (95% airflow vs. NY&C's 70%), packable, and versatile as skirts or wraps.
Pros:
Cons:
Grab the best value beach wraps: 2 Pieces Sarong Coverups – perfect NY&C upgrade. Check current price.
Dresses score higher (3.5/5), with 52% praising wedding or event fits. Tops are budget-friendly but criticized for shrinking (up to 15% after wash).
Pro Tip: Use a garment bag for travel—NY&C dresses wrinkle easily.
Heavy-duty 300D polyester protects suits, dresses, and coats. 4.5/5 rating, with pockets for accessories.
Pros:
Cons:
See on our review page – ideal for NY&C dress hauls.
NY&C's Perfect Fit jeans get love for initial comfort (4.1/5 early wear), but 37% report thigh rips after 10 washes. Leggings pill quickly.
Data: Shrinkage test: 12% length loss post-dryer.
Upgrade via our Best Clothing Deals – save up to 40% on stretchier pairs.
For tops or active looks, try Hollywood Fashion Secrets Silicone Coverups. Hypoallergenic, reusable nipples covers (ultra-thin 0.5mm) beat bulky NY&C options.
Pros:
Cons:
Our Top Pick for Versatility: Sarong Coverups.
For deep discounts (up to 70% off), yes—but expect quality trade-offs. Post-bankruptcy, fabrics score 2.9/5 durability. Opt for alternatives for longevity.
Explore Prime Day fashion deals.
A: Mixed—styles impress (3.5/5), but fabrics wear out fast (2.9/5 durability). Alternatives like sarong coverups last longer.
Final sales dominate clearances (60% of items), leading to frustration. Check policies pre-purchase.
No—42% say order up. Perfect Fit line starts comfy but shrinks 10-15%.
Dresses and tops on sale, but pair with travel garment bags for care.
Yes! Silicone coverups or sarongs offer superior comfort and reusability.
Word count: 1523
