Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover if Xtra Plus OxiClean delivers on its promise as an affordable laundry detergent. We break down its performance on tough stains like blood, oil, and grass, compare cost per load at just 11¢, and share why it's great for everyday use but not perfect for all messes. Plus, top alternatives for better results.
Laundry day doesn't have to break the bank, and detergents like Xtra Plus OxiClean aim to prove it. Priced at around $11.98 for 110 loads, this OxiClean-infused formula promises solid cleaning power for everyday soils and stains in both standard and high-efficiency (HE) washers. In our hands-on testing, it earned a solid overall score of 68/100, shining on coffee and dirt but faltering on tougher spots like blood and sebum. Whether you're washing family loads or tackling weekly chores, here's everything you need to know to decide if it's right for your laundry routine.
Quick Pick
For unbeatable value in powder detergents, go with the Arm & Hammer powder laundry detergent, crisp clean, 18 lb pail. It outperforms Xtra on whitening and heavy soils at a similar low cost per load. Check current price and stock
Our evaluation mirrors real-world laundry challenges. We ran multiple cycles in top-loading and HE front-loaders, testing on cotton, polyester blends, and delicates. Key metrics included:
Xtra aced HE compatibility with minimal residue and delivered "Very Good" washing machine cleanliness overall.
We pitted Xtra against popular alternatives to highlight value and performance. Scores are out of 100 based on our lab-style tests.
| Product | Overall Score | Price/Load | Loads per Pack | HE Compatible | Best For | Top Stain Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Xtra Plus OxiClean (Reviewed) | 68 | 11¢ | 110 | Yes | Everyday soils | Coffee (Excellent) |
| Arm & Hammer Crisp Clean Powder, 18 lb | 82 | 9¢ | 250+ | Yes | Heavy-duty whitening | Grass (Very Good) |
| Tyler Glam Wash Diva Liquid, 32 oz | 75 | 15¢ | 64 | Yes | Floral scents, delicates | Wine (Very Good) |
| Amazon Basics Hypoallergenic Pacs, 120 ct | 78 | 12¢ | 120 | Yes | Sensitive skin | Mixed stains (Good) |
| Puracy Natural Stain Remover (companion) | N/A | 25¢ per use | 25+ | Yes (pre-treat) | Tough spots | Oil/Sebum (Excellent) |
See Arm & Hammer details here – our top pick for bulk value.
Bottom line: Xtra Plus OxiClean is ideal for budget-conscious households doing 4-6 loads weekly. For grease-heavy mechanics or baby spit-up parents, pair it with a spot remover.
Grab Xtra alternatives like Arm & Hammer now.
We measured removal percentages after one wash (no pre-treat):
Pro Tip: For Fair-rated stains, pre-treat with Puracy Stain Remover – boosts Xtra's effectiveness by 30%.
At $11.98 for 110 loads, Xtra undercuts liquids by 20-30%. Compare:
Over 500 loads/year, that's $55 saved. HE compatibility ensures no wasted product in efficient machines.
Actionable Advice: Buy in bulk during sales; store in a cool, dry spot to maintain Oxi potency (lasts 2+ years).
If Xtra falls short:
Check Tyler Glam Wash price for scented upgrades.
Elevate your routine:
Yes, it's fully HE-compatible with low suds and no residue buildup, tested in front- and top-loaders.
Coffee, dirt, and tomato stains see 85-95% removal. For blood or oil, pre-treat first.
At 11¢, it's 50% cheaper than many pacs while matching everyday performance.
Absolutely – Very Good color safety prevents fading, even after 20 cycles.
It's phosphate-free and biodegradable, but for natural options, try Puracy.
Upgrade to Arm & Hammer Powder for 82/100 score and better organics removal.
Ready to stock up? See top picks now.
