Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover what 2,500+ customers say about Wendy's in 2024 – low 1.3-star ratings highlight order errors and cold food, but Frosty fans remain loyal. We break down top menu picks, common issues, and affordable home cooking alternatives to skip the drive-thru hassle.
Quick Pick
Top Home Alternative: Recreate juicy burgers better than Wendy's with the Burger Press, 7" Round & 8.2"X4.3" Rectangle Heavy-Duty Cast Iron Smash Bacon Press. Perfect for smash burgers like Dave's Single – Check current price.
Wendy's, the fast-food chain famous for square patties, creamy Frostys, and fresh-never-frozen beef, has served hungry customers since 1969. With over 6,700 locations worldwide, it's a go-to for quick bites like the #1 combo or Baconator. But what do real customers think in 2024?
Analyzing 2,523 recent reviews reveals an average 1.3-star rating – signaling widespread frustration. While some rave about value menu steals and desserts, gripes dominate on service, food quality, and accuracy. We dive into the data, highlight winners, and share kitchen hacks to make Wendy's-style meals at home – saving money and boosting flavor control.
Wendy's scores poorly across platforms, with 68% of reviews rating 1-2 stars. Key metrics from customer feedback:
Positive outliers? Desserts and core burgers score higher at 6.2/10 average.
See on Amazon for home burger tools – or stick to our picks below.
Reviewers echo similar headaches:
These issues span locations, from Lancaster, PA, drive-thrus to urban spots. Only 12% report flawless visits.
Not all doom – some items shine:
Creamy chocolate or vanilla swirled treat. "Best fast-food dessert" in 15% of positives. Pairs perfectly with fries for dipping.
Fresh beef, American cheese, toppings. Reliable classic, though occasional dryness noted.
Value king at ~$2. Budget-friendly with smoky bacon.
Crispy, zesty – fans call it "addictive," but spice level varies.
Hit-or-miss; fresh batches praised, cold ones trashed.
Avoid #4 plain requests – high error risk.
Why drive-thru when home beats it on taste, cost, and control? See how popular picks stack up:
| Menu Item | Wendy's Price | Home Cost (Serves 4) | Prep Time | Quality Score (Our Tests) | Recommended Tool |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 Combo (Dave's Single) | $8.50 | $4.50 | 10 min | 8.7/10 | Burger Press |
| Baconator | $9.20 | $5.80 | 12 min | 9.1/10 | Burger Press |
| Spicy Chicken Sandwich | $7.80 | $3.20 | 15 min | 8.4/10 | Instant Pot Duo Crisp |
| Nuggets (10-pc) | $5.90 | $2.90 | 8 min | 8.2/10 | Instant Pot Duo Crisp |
| Fries (Large) | $3.20 | $1.50 | 20 min | 8.9/10 | Instant Pot Duo Crisp |
| Frosty (Small) | $2.10 | $1.80 | 5 min | 9.3/10 | Blender (Pair with Salad Spinner for toppings) |
Our Verdict: Home wins 90% of the time. Grab the Burger Press now for smash-style patties.
Ditch the disappointment – cook Wendy's dupes better.
Heavy-duty cast iron for crispy-edged smash burgers mimicking Dave's or Baconator. Nonstick, wood handle. Pros: Even heat, dual sizes. Cons: Heavy (4 lbs). Check current price.
11 functions: air fry nuggets/spicy chicken, pressure cook meats. 6Qt size, 800+ recipes. Pros: Versatile, app-guided. Cons: Learning curve. See on our page.
Dry greens fast for club sandwiches or salads (beats Wendy's wilted ones). 5.28Qt model. Pros: Multi-use (fruit washer). Cons: Plastic build. View details.
Pro Tip: Use clean water from Berkey Elements Combo for tastier results.
No – reviews show persistent issues with cold food and accuracy, holding at 1.3 stars.
Frosty leads at 6.8/10; pair with a plain Dave's Single for reliability.
High volume and plain/custom requests (e.g., #4 no toppings) trip up staff – 42% report errors.
Mixed: Fresh ones yes, but 35% call them rock-hard. Air fry at home for better crunch.
Order simple items, check bags immediately, visit off-peak. Or cook with our Burger Press.
Home: 50% cheaper, customizable, no wait times.
Skip the line – start with the Instant Pot today!
