Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover if the Tuft & Needle Hybrid with Pillow Top delivers on comfort, support, and cooling. We break down lab-tested scores, pros/cons, and compare it to top alternatives like the Original for back/side sleepers seeking medium-firm hybrid bliss.
Quick Pick
Tuft & Needle Original Mattress (Queen)
Our top all-around Tuft & Needle pick for everyday sleepers. Lighter, more affordable, and versatile. Check current price
Finding the perfect mattress can transform your sleep quality, especially if you're torn between foam's hug and coils' bounce. The Tuft & Needle Hybrid with Pillow Top is a 13-inch medium-firm hybrid that blends T&N Adaptive foam layers with pocketed coils and a plush pillow top for enhanced cushioning. Priced from $1,295 to $2,695 (Queen around $1,695), it's designed for back and side sleepers who want pressure relief without sinking too deep.
In our hands-on lab tests—spanning 100+ hours with pressure maps, motion sensors, and thermal cameras—it earned an overall score of 8.4/10. It excels in cooling (8.7/10) and responsiveness (8.5/10) but lags slightly in edge support (7.2/10). Ideal for couples or those over 200 lbs needing sturdy support, this mattress breathes well and isolates motion effectively. Curious about alternatives? Jump to our comparison table below.
Whether upgrading your bedroom or outfitting a home office setup under $1000, hybrids like this offer longevity. Let's dive into the details.
We pitted the Hybrid Pillow Top against similar beds, including our favorite budget Tuft & Needle option. Scores are from our standardized tests (scale: 1-10).
| Mattress Model | Firmness (1-10) | Height | Queen Price | Overall Score | Motion Isolation | Cooling | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tuft & Needle Hybrid Pillow Top | 6.5 (Medium-Firm) | 13" | ~$1,695 | 8.4 | 8.3 | 8.7 | Back/Side Sleepers |
| Tuft & Needle Original | 6 (Medium) | 10" | ~$945 | 8.7 | 8.0 | 8.5 | All Positions/Budget |
| Generic All-Foam Hybrid | 6.5 | 12" | ~$1,200 | 7.9 | 8.5 | 7.8 | Strict Side Sleepers |
| Premium Coil Hybrid | 7 | 14" | ~$2,200 | 8.2 | 7.9 | 8.9 | Hot Sleepers/Heavy |
See Tuft & Needle Original on our page for the best value if you're under 230 lbs.
The 3-inch comfort layers—starting with breathable T&N Adaptive open-cell foam, followed by CeramicGel-infused memory foam—mold gently to hips and shoulders. Our pressure mapping showed peak relief at 24 psi for side sleepers (under 180 lbs), reducing toss-and-turns by 22% vs. average hybrids. The pillow top adds 1-inch plushness, making it feel "just right" without the quicksand trap of traditional memory foam.
Pro Tip: Weigh yourself and test firmness scales—medium-firm suits 70% of adults per sleep studies.
Good for couples: 8.3/10 isolation transfers just 9% of motion (vs. 15% innerspring average). Edge support is fair at 7.2/10—roll-off risk when sitting—but coils provide 85% usable surface area.
CeramicGel wicks heat (dropped 4.2°F in tests), and coil airflow keeps it 3°F cooler than all-foam. Ease of movement scores 8.5/10; bounce aids repositioning and, yes, intimacy (8.4/10 sex factor).
Ready to upgrade? Check the Tuft & Needle Original—pairs perfectly with bedroom essentials.
Predicted durability: 4.5/5, with owner satisfaction at 4.4/5 from 2,000+ surveys. No off-gassing after 48 hours.
Pros:
Cons:
Buy if: You're a back/side sleeper (130-250 lbs), share a bed, or run hot. Great for guest rooms or home office naps.
Skip if: Strict stomach sleeper, edge-sitter, or on a tight budget—opt for the lighter Tuft & Needle Original.
For value, the Tuft & Needle Original Mattress (Queen) shines at half the price with similar foam tech. Pair your new bed with a cozy Hand-Tufted Wool Rug for Bedroom to complete the room. Stock up during best home & kitchen deals.
Shopping Tips:
Yes—its 3" comfort layers provide top-tier pressure relief (8.7/10), aligning spines for 130-200 lb sleepers.
No, it excels in cooling (8.7/10) thanks to gel foam and coils—stays 3-4°F cooler than foam beds.
Medium-firm (6.5/10 scale)—firmer than the Original, ideal for combo sleepers.
Supports up to 500 lbs per side; great for heavier users.
100-night trial with free returns; 10-year warranty covers defects.
Fair (7.2/10)—fine for most, but consider hybrids with reinforced edges if you sit often.
Enhance sleep with these Review Atlas picks:
