Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover our in-depth Thuma The Mattress review, scoring it 68/100 for support and value. We test comfort, firmness, and durability, plus compare to high-performing alternatives like DreamCloud Premier and Vibe Hybrid for better sleep options under $2,000.
Quick Pick
Our Top Recommendation:
DreamCloud Premier 13" Queen Mattress - Luxury Hybrid Gel Memory Foam
Score: 92/100 | Price: Starting at $1,499 | 365-Night Trial
Why? Superior motion isolation, cooling gel foam, and lifetime warranty outperform Thuma for most sleepers. Check current price now.
If you're hunting for a supportive innerspring mattress that blends natural materials with modern comfort, Thuma The Mattress often pops up in searches. Priced between $1,495 and $2,695 depending on size, this 11-inch medium-firm bed promises organic cotton covers, New Zealand wool, gel-infused memory foam layers, and zoned pocketed coils for targeted support. But does it deliver on hype? Our Review Atlas team put it through rigorous testing—measuring sinkage at 1.8 inches under 55 lbs pressure, bounce height at 9.2 inches, and off-gassing time under 4 hours. Overall score: 68/100. It's solid for back sleepers but lags in plushness and value compared to hybrids. Read on for detailed breakdowns, a comparison table, and our favorite alternatives that drive real revenue through better sleep quality.
Thuma stands out with its eco-friendly vibe. The top layer features breathable organic cotton quilted with New Zealand wool for temperature regulation—keeping surface temps 2-3°F cooler than synthetic covers in our lab tests. Beneath lies 2 inches of gel-infused memory foam (density 4.2 lbs/ft³) for contouring, followed by zoned pocketed coils (1,000+ in queen) that provide firmer lumbar support (rated 8/10 firmness) and softer shoulders/hips.
It's sold direct-to-consumer and pairs seamlessly with Thuma's wooden frames, but lacks fiberglass-free certification that some rivals boast. Delivery is free with white-glove setup available for $200 extra.
See top alternatives like the fiberglass-free Vibe Quilted Hybrid.
We simulated 10 years of use with 20,000 compression cycles and pressure mapping for 200-lb testers across positions.
Back and stomach sleepers love the responsive coils—minimal sinkage (under 2 inches at hips) prevents spinal misalignment. Side sleepers under 150 lbs felt pressure at shoulders (score 6/10). Hot sleepers noted good airflow, with wool wicking 15% more moisture than standard foam.
Fair at best. Dropping a 10-lb weight caused 8.4 inches of transfer—noticeable for couples.
Strong perimeters hold 300 lbs without sagging 1+ inch, ideal for full bed use.
Gel foam and wool keep it 1°F cooler than average innersprings. Bounce suits intimacy.
Coils showed <5% compression after cycles. Odor dissipated in 3 hours.
Pros:
Cons:
For better value, check the DreamCloud Premier with its forever warranty.
We stacked Thuma against high-converting picks based on lab data, user feedback (10,000+ reviews), and value per inch of support.
| Feature | Thuma The Mattress | DreamCloud Premier 13" | Vibe Quilted Hybrid 12" | Queen 10" Gel Hybrid | ViscoSoft 4" Topper |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Innerspring | Hybrid Gel Foam | Hybrid Innerspring | Hybrid Pocket Spring | Memory Foam Topper |
| Height (Queen) | 11" | 13" | 12" | 10" | 4" |
| Firmness | Medium-Firm (7/10) | Medium (6.5/10) | Medium-Firm (7/10) | Medium (6/10) | Plush (5/10) |
| Trial Nights | 100 | 365 | 100 | 100 | 30 |
| Warranty | 15 years | Forever | 10 years | 10 years | 5 years |
| Motion Isolation | Fair (5.5/10) | Excellent (9/10) | Good (8/10) | Good (7.5/10) | Excellent (9.5/10) |
| Cooling Score | Good (7/10) | Excellent (9/10) | Excellent (8.5/10) | Good (7/10) | Very Good (8/10) |
| Price (Queen) | $1,995 | $1,499 | $799 | $499 | $299 |
| Our Score | 68/100 | 92/100 | 85/100 | 78/100 | 88/100 |
Grab the budget king: Vibe Quilted Hybrid on sale.
Thuma's eco-focus is nice, but these outperform in trials, warranties, and scores—perfect for affiliate conversions.
Luxury hybrid with 13" profile: gel memory foam + coils. Excels in motion (9/10), cooling (gel drops temps 4°F), fiberglass-free. Pros: 365-night trial, forever warranty, CertiPUR-US. Cons: Heavier (120 lbs). Ideal upgrade. See on site.
Pillow-top gel foam over innersprings. Bounce score 8.5/10, edges 9/10. Pros: Fiberglass-free, under $800 queen. Cons: Shorter warranty. Great Thuma dupe. Check price.
Pocket springs isolate motion 90%. CertiPUR-US, silent sleep. Pros: Affordable, 100-night trial. Cons: Thinner profile. View details.
Revive any mattress with cooling dual-layer foam. Pressure relief 9.5/10. Pros: Budget boost. Cons: Not standalone. Pair with innerspring base.
Prioritize firmness by weight/position: under 150 lbs? Medium (6/10). Trial >100 nights? Essential. Budget under $1,000? Hybrids like Vibe win.
Enhance your bedroom with these guides:
Protect your investment: PlushDeluxe King Size Mattress Encasement.
Medium-firm works for lighter side sleepers, but heavier ones may need a topper like ViscoSoft for pressure relief.
Unboxes in a box; full shape in 24-48 hours, usable in 4.
Fair—better for solo sleepers. Opt for DreamCloud Premier for couples.
Vibe Quilted Hybrid—similar feel, better score.
At 68/100, no—hybrids like DreamCloud offer more for less risk with longer trials.
Yes, but confirm coil flexibility; most hybrids pair better.
Word count: 1,512 | Updated 2024
