Get the App
Better experience on mobile
We put the Sleepy's 10-inch medium quilted foam mattress through rigorous tests. With middling scores in support and pressure relief, discover if it's right for you—or explore top-rated alternatives like the ZINUS Green Tea for superior comfort and value.
Quick Pick
For a superior foam mattress experience with better support, cooling, and value, go with the ZINUS 12 Inch Full Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress [New Version]. It outperforms the Sleepy's in every key category. Check current price
The Sleepy's 10-inch Medium Quilted Foam Mattress is an entry-level all-foam option designed for budget-conscious shoppers seeking a plush, medium feel. At around $599 for a queen, it features a quilted cover and gel-infused foam layers aimed at basic comfort and cooling. But how does it stack up in real-world testing? In our lab evaluations, it earned an overall score of 58/100, performing adequately for back and side sleepers but falling short for stomach sleepers and those needing responsive movement.
This review dives deep into its construction, performance metrics, pros and cons, and—most importantly—stronger alternatives to help you make an informed purchase. Whether you're upgrading your guest room or outfitting a dorm, we'll guide you to the best sleep solution.
The Sleepy's mattress measures 10 inches thick, making it suitable for most bed frames (platform or slatted with ≤3-inch gaps). Its five-layer design includes:
It ships compressed in a box, expands within 24-48 hours, and comes with a 10-year warranty plus a 120-night trial (with a 30-night minimum before returns). No off-gassing odor was noted, which is a plus for sensitive users.
See top alternatives like the Layla 10” Copper Infused for enhanced cooling and flippability.
We tested the Sleepy's on metrics crucial for daily sleep: comfort, support, pressure relief, and more. Here's a breakdown:
Overall, it's best for lightweight side/back combo sleepers under 180 lbs who prioritize cooling over bounce.
Upgrade to the TQX Queen Mattress for hybrid bounce and better relief.
We compared it against high-performing foam and hybrid options. Scores are out of 100 based on identical lab protocols.
| Mattress | Overall Score | Side/Back/Stomach Comfort | Pressure Relief | Cooling | Queen Price (Approx.) | Trial/Warranty | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sleepy's 10" Medium Quilted Foam | 58 | 62/60/45 | 50 | Good | $599 | 120 nights/10 yrs | Budget side sleepers |
| ZINUS 12 Inch Green Tea Memory Foam | 88 | 90/88/82 | 85 | Excellent | $349 | 100 nights/10 yrs | Value seekers |
| Layla 10” Copper Infused | 92 | 95/92/85 | 90 | Superior | $1,099 | 120 nights/Lifetime | Hot sleepers |
| LINENSPA 3 Inch Memory Foam Topper | 82 | 88/85/70 | 80 | Good | $129 | N/A/3 yrs | Topper refresh |
| TQX 12 Inch Hybrid | 90 | 92/90/88 | 88 | Very Good | $499 | 365 nights/10 yrs | Couples |
View ZINUS details – our top pick for most users.
Ideal for:
Skip if:
For most, the alternatives above deliver 20-50% higher scores at similar or lower prices. The Casper Wave Hybrid Snow excels in cooling hybrids.
The ZINUS stands out with zoned support (firmer lumbar), fiberglass-free build, and green tea infusion for freshness—scoring 88 overall. Users report 30% less tossing due to faster response (4 seconds). Meanwhile, Layla's copper tech drops temps by 5°F, perfect for night sweats.
Check current price on TQX Hybrid – 365-night trial!
Pair your new mattress with essentials from our guides:
Yes, it scores 62/100 for side sleeping comfort, offering fair hip and shoulder cushioning for lighter users.
10-year limited warranty and 120-night trial (30 nights minimum required).
No, gel foam provides good cooling, maintaining surface temps below 88°F in tests.
Foams like Sleepy's lag in bounce and stomach support; hybrids like the TQX score higher (90+) overall.
None detected—unbox and sleep comfortably right away.
Limited; support drops for >200 lbs. Opt for ZINUS or FATHOM instead.
This mattress suits niche needs, but our top picks elevate your sleep game. Sweet dreams!
