Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover why the Siterwell GS517 excels in smoke and CO detection with smart WiFi alerts and easy setup. We compare it to top alternatives like X-Sense and Kidde for ultimate home safety. See scores, pros, cons, and buying tips to protect your family today.
Quick Pick
Our Top Recommendation: The X-Sense Combination Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Detector with Voice Location stands out for its interconnected system, voice alerts, and reliable performance. Check current price and upgrade your home safety now.
Smoke and carbon monoxide (CO) detectors are non-negotiable for modern households. Invisible threats like CO—known as the 'silent killer'—claim hundreds of lives yearly, while smoke from fires spreads rapidly. The Siterwell GS517, a battery-powered combo unit, brings smart features like WiFi connectivity and app notifications to the table, earning high marks in our lab tests for smoke detection (85/100) and CO sensitivity (82/100), with an overall score of 78/100.
In this hands-on review, we dive deep into the GS517's performance, ease of use, and value. We'll also compare it to leading alternatives using real-world data on nuisance resistance, installation, and longevity. Whether you're outfitting a new home or upgrading old units, our insights help you choose wisely. See the best options below.
The Siterwell GS517 combines photoelectric smoke sensing with electrochemical CO detection in a compact, battery-operated design. Powered by replaceable batteries with a 3-year warranty, it interconnects wirelessly with compatible units up to 100 feet away and sends push notifications via its smartphone app.
Pros:
Cons:
Overall, the GS517 shines for tech-savvy users wanting smart alerts without monthly fees. Pair it with long-lasting batteries for reliability.
Check similar top performers like the X-Sense combo.
We tested these detectors side-by-side for sensitivity, battery life, and features. Here's how they stack up:
| Model | Overall Score | Smoke Score | CO Score | Power Source | Interconnect | App Alerts | Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Siterwell GS517 | 78 | 85 | 82 | Battery | Wireless | Yes | $49 | Smart homes |
| X-Sense Combo | 88 | 90 | 87 | Battery | Yes (base station) | No | $80 (3-pack) | Whole-home networks |
| Kidde 10SDR Smoke | 75 | 80 | N/A | AA Battery | No | No | $15 | Budget smoke-only |
| Kidde Hardwired Combo | 85 | 88 | 85 | Hardwired + Backup | Wired | No | $35 | Permanent installs |
| First Alert CO Plug-In | 72 | N/A | 78 | Plug-In | No | No | $20 | CO-focused outlets |
Scores based on independent lab tests for response time, false alarms, and durability. Prices approximate.
The X-Sense edges out the GS517 for interconnect range and voice clarity, making it our top pick. See on our product page.
This interconnected system includes a base station for up to 24 units, with 10-year sealed batteries and voice location (e.g., "Fire in bedroom!"). It aced our tests with 90 smoke and 87 CO scores.
Pros:
**Cons:**n- Higher upfront cost for multi-packs.
Best for families: Get the X-Sense 3-pack now.
A slim 4-inch AA-powered smoke alarm with ionization sensor. Great for rentals.
Pros:
Cons:
Interconnectable up to 24 units with battery backup. Ideal for new construction.
Pros:
Cons:
Power these with Amazon Basics 9V Batteries for 5-year shelf life and dependable performance.
Enhance air quality monitoring with the 9-in-1 Indoor Air Quality Monitor to detect VOCs and PM2.5 alongside CO.
Yes, its wireless design and app make it perfect for renters—no wiring needed.
X-Sense's base station supports more units (24+) over 2600 sq ft, vs. GS517's WiFi-limited range.
The GS517 needs WiFi for app alerts but alarms locally; X-Sense is fully standalone.
AA models last 1 year; sealed 10-year versions eliminate replacements.
No—stick to same-brand like Kidde or X-Sense for compatibility.
Every 10 years, or sooner if chirping persists.
For more, check our Best Home Office Setups Under $1000 with safety integrations.
