Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover if Schmidt Old Tyme 100% Whole Wheat Bread lives up to its healthy reputation. We break down nutrition scores (91/100), taste (77/100), price per lb, and real-user insights. Perfect for toast, sandwiches, or meal prep—see pros, cons, and better alternatives.
Quick Pick
Schmidt Old Tyme 100% Whole Wheat Bread
Best for: Everyday healthy eating with solid nutrition and whole grain goodness.
Price: ~$3.99/lb | Nutrition Score: 91/100 | Taste: Pleasing wheat flavor
Ideal for families seeking fiber-rich slices without added sugars.
In a world of processed snacks, whole wheat bread like Schmidt Old Tyme 100% Whole Wheat stands out for its nutrient density. This bread promises 100% whole grains, delivering fiber, protein, and essential nutrients in every 38g slice. At $3.99 per pound, it's positioned as a premium yet accessible option for health-conscious eaters.
We evaluated it across nutrition, taste, texture, and value, drawing from lab-tested data and panel tastings. With a overall score of 84/100, it excels in nutrition (91/100) but has room for improvement in taste consistency (77/100). Whether you're building better breakfasts or packing lunches, here's everything you need to know.
Schmidt Old Tyme prioritizes whole ingredients, making it a strong contender for balanced diets. Per 1-slice serving (38g):
| Nutrient | Amount | % Daily Value | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calories | 100 | - | Low-cal for bread, supports weight management |
| Total Fat | 1.5g | 2% | Minimal, from soybean oil |
| Sodium | 135mg | 6% | Lower than many competitors (avg. 170mg) |
| Total Carbs | 19g | 7% | Mostly complex from whole wheat |
| Dietary Fiber | 3g | 11% | Excellent for digestion; beats white bread's 1g |
| Sugars | 1g | - | Naturally occurring, no added |
| Added Sugars | 0g | 0% | Clean label win |
| Protein | 5g | - | Solid for plant-based muscle support |
Key Takeaway: This bread shines with 11% DV fiber and zero added sugars, outperforming many store-bought loaves. It's keto-friendly in moderation and aligns with American Heart Association guidelines for whole grains (aim for 3 servings daily).
Our team of 10 tasters sampled it plain, toasted, and in sandwiches. Overall taste score: 77/100. The pleasing wheat flavor shines through, with a moist crumb and slightly chewy crust. Notes of earthy whole grain dominate, making it versatile for PB&J or turkey clubs.
Texture Scores:
Some panelists noted minor dryness after Day 2, suggesting fresh freezing for longevity. Compared to softer white breads, it holds up better in toasters without crumbling.
For similar hearty profiles, check Aunt Millie's Cracked Wheat Bread Review: Healthy Whole Grain Pick.
Full List: Whole wheat flour, water, wheat gluten, yeast, cultured wheat flour, soybean oil (≤2%), salt, cultured rye flour, vinegar, wheat bran, monoglycerides, enzymes.
This clean-ish formula scores high for transparency, earning our nod for allergen-aware shoppers (soy present).
At $3.99/lb, it's mid-to-premium. A 20-slice loaf (~$5-6) yields 20 servings at 25-30¢ each—budget-friendly for quality.
| Bread | Overall Score | Price/lb | Fiber per Slice | Taste Notes | Review Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Schmidt Old Tyme 100% Whole Wheat | 84/100 | $3.99 | 3g | Pleasing, slightly chewy | This Review |
| Koepplinger's 100% Whole Wheat | N/A | ~$3.50 | 4g+ | Nutty, dense | Read Here |
| Aunt Millie's Cracked Wheat | N/A | ~$3.20 | 2.5g | Mild, versatile | Read Here |
| Aunt Millie's LiveLight Whole Grain | N/A | ~$3.00 | 3g | Low-cal, soft | Read Here |
Value Verdict: Strong buy if prioritizing fiber over lowest price. Stock up during sales for best ROI.
Ideal For:
Skip If: You prefer super-soft textures or zero-fat formulas.
Storage Tips: Keep in original bag at room temp (3-5 days); fridge (1 week); freezer (3 months). Revive with light toasting.
Pair with Unbreakable Cereal Bowls for durable breakfast serving.
Overall, it earns 4.2/5 stars for health-focused routines.
Elevate your wellness setup:
Yes, whole wheat flour is the primary ingredient, providing full grain benefits like intact bran and germ for maximum nutrients.
Schmidt offers similar fiber (3g) at a lower price point, though Dave's has more seeds for texture. Taste is subjective—Schmidt is milder.
Absolutely! Its chewy crumb absorbs batter well; score 8.5/10 in our tests.
Yes—no dairy, eggs, or honey. Confirm with latest label.
Freeze slices in a zip bag; thaw overnight or toast directly for freshness.
No added sugars (0g), only 1g natural—great for low-glycemic diets.
Word count: ~1520 | Last updated: 2024
