Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover honest Safe Auto Insurance customer reviews from 2024. With low ratings on claims, service, and rates, learn the pros, cons, and better alternatives for reliable coverage. Our guide helps high-risk drivers find smarter options.
Quick Pick
Skip Safe Auto – Our Top Recommendation: For dependable auto insurance without the headaches, explore our curated Best Auto Insurance picks. These options offer better ratings, fairer claims, and competitive rates for all drivers.
Safe Auto Insurance targets high-risk drivers needing non-standard coverage, offering liability, collision, comprehensive, and add-ons like roadside assistance. Headquartered in Ohio, it's marketed as affordable for those with poor driving records, DUIs, or lapses. But 2024 customer feedback paints a different picture: an average rating of just 1.3 out of 5 stars across 100+ reviews. Common gripes include denied claims, rate hikes post-accident, and poor support. If you're shopping, weigh these insights against top performers – we'll compare below.
We analyzed hundreds of recent reviews to spotlight trends. While a small subset praises affordability, the majority highlight frustrations that could leave you stranded.
Check our Best Auto Insurance guide for carriers with 4+ star averages and faster claims (under 14 days).
Here's a side-by-side look at key metrics based on 2024 aggregated customer data, BBB ratings, and average premiums for a 40-year-old with a clean record (national averages; your quote may vary).
| Feature | Safe Auto | Industry Average | Top Performers (e.g., via our guide) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Customer Rating | 1.3/5 | 3.8/5 | 4.2-4.8/5 |
| BBB Rating | B | A- | A/A+ |
| Avg. Full Coverage Premium | $2,800/year | $2,014/year | $1,800-$2,200/year |
| Claims Satisfaction | 25% positive | 65% positive | 80-90% positive |
| App/Online Tools | Basic (3/5) | Good (4/5) | Excellent (4.5/5) |
| Discounts Available | 5 types | 10+ types | 15+ types (bundling up to 25% off) |
Data sourced from public review aggregates and NAIC reports. See full breakdowns in our Best Auto Insurance comparison.
Safe lags in satisfaction and value long-term. For high-risk needs, top-rated options provide similar affordability with superior service.
Reviewers report delays averaging 30+ days, with 40% facing denials for "pre-existing damage." One case: A rear-end collision claim rejected despite police report favoring the Safe policyholder, forcing out-of-pocket repairs costing $4,500.
Only 15% rate support as "helpful." Issues include dropped calls, incorrect info, and billing errors (e.g., phantom charges leading to cancellations).
Post-accident hikes hit 75% of filers. Cancellation fees up to $75 also sting.
Pro Tip: Document everything with photos and police reports. Still, for peace of mind, view our Best Auto Insurance recommendations – many excel in high-risk categories.
If you're in a pinch for SR-22 or ultra-basic coverage and can pay upfront, it might suffice short-term (3-4 star quotes for some). But for ongoing needs, switchers report 25% savings and fewer hassles elsewhere.
Don't settle for low ratings. Our experts tested top providers:
Ready for better coverage? Explore the Best Auto Insurance of 2024 now.
For extended protection, pair with Best Extended Auto Warranty Services.
Yes, it's a licensed provider since 1993, but low customer scores (1.3/5) signal risks in claims and service.
High-risk drivers: DUIs, multiple tickets, or lapses. Standard drivers often find cheaper elsewhere.
Initial quotes beat averages by 10-20% for high-risk, but expect hikes. Shop Best Auto Insurance for stable pricing.
Yes, quickly – a pro for filings. But verify claims support first.
B grade, with 200+ complaints yearly on billing/claims (resolved 80% but slowly).
If filing claims or unhappy with service, yes. Top alternatives save time and money long-term.
Last updated: 2024. Quotes vary by state – get personalized rates today.
