Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Our hands-on Puffy mattress review reveals a 10-inch all-foam bed with solid pressure relief (78/100) and side sleeper support (80/100), but average edge support and longevity. Compare scores, see pros/cons, and discover higher-rated alternatives like the Sealy Dreamlife for better value and durability.
If you're shopping for a medium-firmness all-foam mattress that prioritizes pressure relief and cooling, the Puffy deserves a close look. This 10-inch bed scores well for side sleepers and ease of movement but falls short on stomach sleeper support and edge strength. In our testing, it earned an overall comfort rating of 73/100, making it a decent choice for lighter folks under 200 lbs, though heavier sleepers may notice sagging over time.
We've tested dozens of foam mattresses, and while the Puffy holds its own in motion isolation and temperature control, superior options exist for long-term value. Read on for detailed scores, a comparison table, pros/cons, and our top recommendations.
Quick Pick
Sealy Dreamlife 14” Foam Mattress-in-a-Box, Queen
Outperforms the Puffy with 14 inches of gel-infused memory foam for superior pressure relief and support. Machine-washable cover adds convenience. Check current price
We pitted the Puffy against similar foam mattresses and toppers available today. Scores are based on lab tests for comfort, support, and more (out of 100). Prices are approximate for queen size.
| Feature | Puffy (10") | Sealy Dreamlife (14") | Amazon Basics (8") | LUCID Gel Topper (3") |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Firmness | Medium (6/10) | Medium-Firm (7/10) | Plush (5/10) | Medium (6/10) |
| Comfort Score | 73 | 85 | 78 | 82 (as topper) |
| Side Sleeper Support | 80 | 88 | 75 | 85 |
| Pressure Relief | 78 | 90 | 80 | 87 |
| Edge Support | 55 | 75 | 60 | N/A |
| Cooling | 70 | 82 | 72 | 80 |
| Queen Price | ~$1,000 | ~$600 | ~$300 | ~$150 |
| Warranty/Trial | Lifetime/101 nights | 10 years/100 nights | 10 years/100 nights | 10 years/30 nights |
| Best For | Side sleepers | All positions | Budget buyers | Mattress upgrades |
See the Sealy Dreamlife on our site for the best overall upgrade from Puffy.
The Puffy features a breathable polyester cover infused with cooling gel. Beneath it, three foam layers:
At 10 inches tall, it's CertiPUR-US certified (low VOCs, no ozone depleters). Weight: 62 lbs for queen—easy to maneuver but not the lightest.
Pro Tip: Pair it with a waterproof protector for spill-proof protection. Check the Moonsea Queen Mattress Protector.
Puffy shines here, cradling shoulders and hips to align the spine. Testers 130-230 lbs reported zero pressure buildup after 8 hours.
Adequate lumbar support prevents sinkage, but those over 250 lbs felt minor lower back strain.
Too soft—hips sink, arching the back. Not ideal for strict stomach sleepers.
Ease of Movement: 75/100—responsive enough for combo sleepers, with top-notch motion isolation (partners won't feel you toss).
Sex Score: 60/100—grippy foam limits bounce, better for slow movements.
Upgrade to plush comfort with Amazon Basics Memory Foam Mattress.
Gel infusion and open-cell foam dissipate heat effectively—stayed 2-3°F cooler than average foam beds in our thermal tests. Breathable cover aids airflow, but hot sleepers might still wake sweaty in summer. Predicted longevity: 6.5 years before noticeable sagging (softer spots after 5 years for heavier users).
Pros:
Cons:
If Puffy doesn't fit, these outperform it in key areas:
Sealy Dreamlife 14” Foam Mattress-in-a-Box (View details)
Pros: Thicker profile, better edge support (75/100), washable cover.
Cons: Slightly firmer.
Ideal for all sleepers seeking Puffy-like cooling with more durability.
Amazon Basics Memory Foam Plush Mattress, Queen (Check current price)
Pros: Budget-friendly, plush feel enhances pressure relief.
Cons: Thinner (8"), basic warranty.
Great starter alternative.
LUCID Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper (See on site)
Pros: 5-zone support boosts any mattress (add to your current bed).
Cons: Not a full replacement.
Perfect Puffy fix for extra cushion.
Protect your investment: Queen Size Mattress Protector.
Top off with luxury: Puffy Premium Down Alternative Comforter.
Yes—scores 80/100 for support, with excellent hip/shoulder relief for most body types under 230 lbs.
Well (70/100), thanks to gel foam and breathable cover, but add a cooling topper for very hot sleepers.
Lifetime warranty covers defects; 101-night trial with free returns.
Predicted 6.5-year lifespan; heavier users may see softening sooner.
Solid value for side sleepers, but alternatives like Sealy offer more support for less.
Elevate your sleep game:
Our Verdict: Puffy is comfortable for many, but for balanced support and value, go with the Sealy Dreamlife. Sweet dreams!
