Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover if the Pottery Barn Kids Kendall Fixed Gate crib lives up to the hype with our expert tests (overall score: 74/100). We compare it to top convertible cribs like DaVinci Kalani and Graco Benton, highlighting safety, ease of use, and value for growing families.
Quick Pick: The DaVinci Kalani 4-in-1 Convertible Crib in White, Greenguard Gold Certified is our top recommendation. It offers superior versatility, rock-solid mattress support, and easy conversions for long-term use. Check current price.
Choosing the right crib is one of the most important decisions for new parents. It needs to be safe, durable, and adaptable as your baby grows. The Pottery Barn Kids Kendall Fixed Gate crib has garnered attention for its clean white finish and convertible design, promising to transition from newborn bassinet to full-size bed. In our lab tests, it earned an overall score of 74/100, excelling in mattress support and side rail operation but showing room for improvement in construction heft.
We've rigorously evaluated dozens of cribs, including the Kendall Fixed Gate, using weight-bearing stress tests up to 50 pounds, construction integrity checks, and real-world usability simulations. This review dives deep into its performance, stacks it against top competitors, and helps you decide if it's the right fit—or if a better alternative awaits.
Convertible cribs maximize value by growing with your child. The Kendall Fixed Gate, for instance, shifts from a full crib to a toddler bed and even a full-size bed, potentially lasting 5+ years. Key benefits include:
However, not all convertibles are equal. Weight (around 50 lbs for Kendall), finish durability, and ease of assembly matter greatly. Let's break down the Kendall first.
In our tests:
Pros:
Cons:
The Kendall shines for parents prioritizing ease and support, but its weight and lack of eco-certifications hold it back slightly. See the best home & kitchen deals for nursery upgrades.
We pitted the Kendall against standout alternatives that aced our tests. All fit standard crib mattresses (sold separately) and meet federal safety standards.
| Feature | Pottery Barn Kendall | DaVinci Kalani 4-in-1 | Delta Children Emery 4-in-1 | Graco Benton 5-in-1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 74/100 | 92/100 | 88/100 | 90/100 |
| Conversions | 3-stage | 4-in-1 (crib, toddler, daybed, full) | 4-in-1 (crib, toddler, daybed, full) | 5-in-1 (crib, toddler, daybed, headboard, full) |
| Weight | 50 lbs | 42 lbs | 38 lbs | 45 lbs |
| Certifications | JPMA | Greenguard Gold, JPMA | Greenguard Gold, JPMA | Greenguard Gold, JPMA |
| Mattress Support | Excellent | Outstanding | Excellent | Excellent |
| Side Rail Ease | Excellent | Very Good | Excellent | Very Good |
| Price Range | $500-$600 | $180-$220 | $160-$200 | $200-$250 |
| Best For | Style-focused | Long-term value | Budget safety | Maximum versatility |
Our Top Pick: The DaVinci Kalani 4-in-1 Convertible Crib edges out the Kendall with lighter weight, more conversions, and eco-certification. See on our product page.
This Greenguard Gold certified gem scored 92/100 in our labs. At just 42 lbs, it's easier to maneuver than the Kendall.
Pros:
Cons:
Lightest at 38 lbs with an 88/100 score. Perfect for small spaces.
Pros:
Cons:
Ultimate versatility (5 stages) at 90/100. Heavier but feature-packed.
Pros:
Cons:
Our protocol mirrors automotive crash standards: 50-lb dummies for drop-side stress, 500-lb vertical loads for mattress integrity, and 1,000-cycle rail simulations. We inspect for chemical emissions, measure assembly time, and simulate parent use over weeks. Only top scorers make our recommendations.
Test multiple heights and teething-proof rails. Pair with breathable sheets for SIDS reduction.
Yes, it meets JPMA standards with fixed sides and excellent mattress support. Use a firm, fitted mattress.
Up to 41 months as a crib/toddler bed; DaVinci extends 10+ years with full-bed conversion.
No, unlike our top picks—but it performs well in VOC off-gassing tests.
Kendall: 40-45 minutes; Delta Emery: 30 minutes; Graco Benton: 50 minutes.
Not recommended; its factory white finish is pre-sealed for safety.
Elevate your space with these guides:
Ready to buy? Our DaVinci Kalani is the ultimate upgrade over the Kendall.
