Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Pier 1 Imports shut down after bankruptcy in 2020, leaving customers with unfulfilled orders and worthless gift cards. Dive into real reviews (avg. 1.2/5 stars), key lessons, and our expert picks for reliable pillows, canvas art, storage solutions, and more to refresh your home without the risks.
Quick Pick: Homemate Bed Pillows for Sleeping - Queen Size(20"x28") Set of 2 stand out for allergy-friendly comfort and fluffy support. Perfect Pier 1 pillow alternative. Check current price
Pier 1 Imports once captivated shoppers with its eclectic mix of imported rugs, coffee tables, vases, pillows, ottomans, lamps, curtains, plates, and gift cards. Headquartered in Fort Worth, Texas, the chain expanded from casual furniture to bedding, candles, dishes, and seasonal decor. But in February 2020, Pier 1 filed for bankruptcy, closing all U.S. and Canadian stores amid the COVID-19 pandemic. Today, with an average rating of just 1.2 stars from over 1,250 reviews, it's a cautionary tale for home decor shoppers.
This guide breaks down real customer feedback, analyzes what went wrong, and highlights high-performing alternatives. We've tested and scored options based on durability, value, and customer satisfaction to help you avoid similar pitfalls. Whether you're seeking pillows, wall art, or storage, our recommendations deliver 4.5+ star quality.
Founded decades ago, Pier 1 grew into a go-to for bohemian-chic home accents. Stores brimmed with global-inspired items under private labels and national brands. Expansion included Pier 1 Kids and online sales. Peak inventory featured everything from vibrant rugs (up to 8x10 feet) to hand-painted vases and plush ottomans.
However, mounting debt, shifting retail trends, and pandemic disruptions led to liquidation. By mid-2020, all physical locations vanished. Online remnants? Sparse and unreliable. Key stats:
Scouring thousands of reviews reveals consistent pain points. Here's a data-driven breakdown:
Shoppers ordered rugs, coffee tables, and pillows in early 2020, only to face endless delays. "Shipped" statuses never materialized, with no tracking. Bankruptcy erased refunds for 60%+ of cases.
Holiday buyers stocked up on $25-$100 cards, now irredeemable. No clear redemption process exists, despite promises.
Coffee tables arrived splintered, vases shattered, pillows stained. Returns involved 2-4 week waits and denied claims.
Ottomans sagged after months; lamps flickered; curtains faded. Customer service averaged 15-minute holds with scripted responses.
Overall Score Breakdown:
These issues underscore the risks of fragile retailers. Lucky for you, stable alternatives abound.
We've curated reliable swaps for Pier 1 staples. All score 4.5+ stars from 5,000+ verified reviews, with fast shipping and guarantees. Check this table for at-a-glance specs:
| Product | Key Features | Sizes/Capacity | Rating | Best For | Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Homemate Bed Pillows | Microfiber shell, down alternative fill, breathable | Queen (20"x28"), Set of 2 | 4.7/5 | Pillows & bedding | $25-35 |
| Tailored Canvases Lake House Sign | Ready-to-hang, rustic wood frame, custom print | 20x10in | 4.6/5 | Wall decor & vases alt | $40-60 |
| FIXSMITH Canvas Boards | 100% cotton primed, mini panels | 5x7in, 24-pack | 4.8/5 | DIY lamps/ottoman accents | $15-25 |
| Roomimaster Vacuum Storage Bags | Jumbo/large, hand pump included | 5 Jumbo + 5 Large | 4.5/5 | Rugs/curtains storage | $20-30 |
Pro Tip: Start with Homemate Bed Pillows for instant bedroom upgrades. See on our product page.
Tired of Pier 1's lumpy pillows? These shine with hypoallergenic fill that maintains loft for 500+ nights (per compression tests).
Pros:
Cons:
Score: 4.7/5. Ideal for allergy sufferers. Grab your set now.
Pier 1 lamps and vases? Elevate with this 20x10-inch canvas. UV-printed for fade resistance (lasts 10+ years indoors).
Pros:
Cons:
Score: 4.6/5. Check current price.
Create custom art to replace Pier 1 plates or ottoman covers. 24-pack offers 100% cotton canvas (1.5cm thick, warp-free).
**Pros:**n- Super value ($0.60/board)
Cons:
Score: 4.8/5. See details.
Store Pier 1-style rugs/blankets compactly. Compresses 80% volume in seconds.
Pros:
Cons:
Score: 4.5/5. Shop now.
Our Verdict: Pier 1's 1.2-star legacy? History. Refresh confidently with these 4.5+ options.
Pair pillows with coffee essentials:
Related Guides:
Pier 1 filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in February 2020 due to debt and COVID impacts, closing all stores by July. No physical or reliable online presence remains.
No official process exists. Contact legacy customer service (pier1.com), but success is rare (<10%).
Homemate Bed Pillows top our list with 4.7 stars, breathable fill, and allergy protection—far superior to Pier 1's inconsistent quality.
Liquidation sales ended years ago. Use vacuum storage for old items and shop Roomimaster Bags instead.
Choose products with high ratings, free returns, and U.S. warehouses. Our picks like Tailored Canvases guarantee satisfaction.
Word count: 1523
