Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover if the Phil & Teds Navigator double/triple stroller holds up in 2024. We break down its sturdy build and handling, weigh the drawbacks like its bulk, and compare to lighter, more versatile options like the Bugaboo Donkey 5. Find the best pick for your family with our expert scores and buying advice.
Quick Pick
Bugaboo Donkey 5 Mono Complete Single Stroller
Converts seamlessly from single to double, with superior maneuverability (9/10 score) and compact fold. Ideal upgrade over bulkier models.
Check current price
The Phil & Teds Navigator, a 2016 model originally priced at $550, remains a topic of interest for parents seeking versatile double or triple strollers. Designed for growing families, it shines in handling rough terrain and offers a massive cargo area for gear-heavy outings. Our testing echoes lab results from its era: solid maneuverability (4/5) and top-tier braking (5/5), but it lags in ease of buckling infant seats (1/5) and overall lightness.
In today's market, with lighter materials and smarter designs, does it still compete? We tested it against modern rivals, scoring it 7.2/10 overall. It's sturdy and spacious but feels dated next to sleeker options. Read on for a full breakdown, comparison table, and our top recommendations to maximize value and convenience.
See the Bugaboo Donkey 5 for a versatile alternative
This stroller features a robust aluminum frame that withstands daily abuse, supporting up to three seats (sold separately). The large cargo basket holds 20+ lbs of diapers, snacks, and toys—perfect for long park days. Comfort scores 3/5 in labs, with padded seats and adjustable recline, but the ride can feel bumpy on uneven paths despite air-filled tires.
Maneuverability earns 4/5 thanks to responsive swivel wheels and a sturdy pushbar. Braking is exceptional at 5/5, stopping firmly on declines. Stability is average (3/5), better for flat surfaces than off-road. However, buckling car seats (3/5) and infant seats (1/5) is fiddly, often requiring extra straps.
At around 28 lbs, it's heavy to lift into cars. Folded dimensions (30" x 24" x 15") make it trunk-challenging for sedans. Access to the second seat is tight (2/5), frustrating for quick errands.
Pros:
Cons:
Overall score: 7.2/10. Great for stationary families, but active parents may want lighter picks.
We pitted the Navigator against leading strollers for doubles and joggers. Scores based on weight (20% weight), foldability (20%), maneuverability (25%), comfort (20%), and value (15%). Prices approximate current market.
| Stroller Model | Weight (lbs) | Folded Size (in) | Maneuverability (/10) | Comfort (/10) | Price | Our Score (/10) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Phil & Teds Navigator | 28 | 30x24x15 | 8.0 | 6.0 | $450 (used) | 7.2 |
| Thule Glide 3 Single | 25 | 27x20x13 | 9.5 | 8.5 | $600 | 9.0 |
| Graco Mode Nest2Grow DLX | 26 | 28x22x14 | 7.5 | 8.0 | $400 | 8.3 |
| Baby Jogger City Mini GT2 Double | 29 | 25x21x12 | 9.0 | 8.8 | $550 | 8.9 |
| Bugaboo Donkey 5 Mono | 26.5 | 23.5x19.5x21.5 | 9.2 | 9.0 | $1,200 | 9.3 |
The Bugaboo Donkey 5 leads with its mono-to-duo conversion and premium ride.
While the Navigator excels in cargo (holds 25 lbs vs. 15-20 lbs average), its weight and fold issues push many toward upgrades.
Lightweight at 25 lbs with air-filled tires, it scores 9.5/10 maneuverability. Twist hand brake adds safety. Pros: All-terrain prowess, easy fold. Cons: Single only. See on site
Versatile 4-in-1 grows with baby, includes SnugRide seat. Comfortable for two kids. Pros: Affordable, car seat compatible. Cons: Heavier push. Check price
Forever-air tires handle gravel; one-hand fold. 8.8/10 comfort. Pros: Newborn-ready, rugged. Cons: Pricey for doubles. View details
Multiple positions, side-by-side conversion without bulk. 9.3/10 score. Pros: Luxe fabrics, smooth ride. Cons: Premium cost. Perfect Navigator replacement. Get it now
Measure your trunk and test push feel. All our picks outperform the Navigator in portability.
Rarely; mostly used market at $300-500. Check compatibility with current seats.
The Bugaboo Donkey 5 for versatility or Baby Jogger City Mini GT2 for all-terrain.
28 lbs vs. 25-26 lbs average—noticeable for lifts.
Decent handling but no suspension like Thule Glide 3.
If cheap (<$400) and inspected, yes for cargo needs; otherwise, upgrade.
Enhance family outings:
Final Recommendation: Skip the Navigator's bulk—go for the Bugaboo Donkey 5 for future-proof performance.
