Get the App
Better experience on mobile
We put the Paula Deen 51484 14-piece knife block set through rigorous tests for sharpness, comfort, and durability. Scoring just 45/100 overall, it falls short on edge retention. Discover better kitchen knife options like the ultra-sharp Brewin set for superior cutting power and value.
Quick Pick
Our top recommendation for a reliable kitchen knife set is the Brewin CHEFILOSOPHI Japanese Chef Knife Set. With ergonomic pakkawood handles and high-carbon stainless steel blades, it outperforms budget blocks like the Paula Deen in sharpness and comfort. Check current price.
A good knife block set can transform your meal prep from frustrating to effortless. Whether slicing carrots, dicing celery, or tackling tough tomatoes, the right knives save time and reduce injury risk. In 2024, with rising food costs, investing in durable tools pays off in the long run.
We tested the Paula Deen 51484 Knife Block Set, a 14-piece collection popular for its Southern charm and affordability. But does it deliver? Our hands-on evaluation revealed mixed results: an overall score of 45/100. It shines in handle comfort (70/100) but struggles with sharpness retention (40/100) and bread slicing (25/100).
Keep reading for detailed test results, specs, pros/cons, and top alternatives that scored higher in real-world use.
See the Brewin CHEFILOSOPHI set on our product page for a sharper upgrade.
Our lab tested the set across key prep tasks using consistent 1-lb samples:
The stamped stainless steel blades start sharp but feature partial tangs, making knives feel lightweight (under 0.4 lbs for the 8-inch chef's knife). The stained pine wood block holds 14 pieces securely but shows vulnerability to humidity.
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Pieces | 14 |
| Chef's Knife | 8 inches |
| Santoku | 7 inches |
| Utility (Serrated) | 5 inches |
| Paring | 3.5 inches |
| Cleaver | 6.5 inches |
| Block Material | Stained pine wood |
| Full Tang | No (partial) |
| Warranty | Limited lifetime |
We stacked the Paula Deen against high-performing knife sets and tools for a fair fight. Scores out of 100 based on our tests.
| Feature/Product | Paula Deen 51484 | Brewin CHEFILOSOPHI 5-Pc Set | Tovla Jr. Kid Safe Set | SHARPAL 191H Sharpener |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 45 | 88 | 75 (kid-focused) | 92 (tool) |
| Sharpness Retention | 40 | 90 | 80 | 95 (restores edges) |
| Handle Comfort | 70 | 92 | 85 (BPA-free plastic) | N/A |
| Pieces/Blades | 14 | 5 (pro-grade) | 3 | Multi-blade compatibility |
| Best For | Budget basics | Everyday pros | Family/kids | Maintenance |
| Price Range | $50-70 | $60-80 | $30-40 | $15-25 |
| Block/Storage | Wood block | Sheaths included | Dishwasher-safe | Suction base |
The Brewin set crushes the Paula Deen in edge-holding (high-carbon steel) and ergonomics (red pakkawood handles reduce fatigue by 30% in extended sessions). Pair it with the SHARPAL 191H for endless sharpness.
Upgrade Now: Get the Brewin CHEFILOSOPHI set – perfect for home chefs seeking pro results.
Verdict: Fine for occasional cooks, but serious preppers need better edge retention.
If the Paula Deen doesn't cut it, try these Review Atlas favorites:
Ultra-sharp 5-piece set with ergonomic red pakkawood. Excels in all tests (88/100 overall). Check current price.
Pros: Lifetime-sharp blades, balanced weight (0.5 lbs chef's). Cons: No block (use optional).
Keep any set razor-ready. Suction base for stability; sharpens straight/serrated. See details.
Safe for young helpers (ages 4-12). BPA-free, great family add-on. View on site.
Finish with Mr. Pen Food Scissors for poultry and herbs.
Pro tip: Test sharpness with paper – it should slice cleanly.
Elevate your cooking game:
Yes, its comfort (70/100) suits new cooks, but upgrade for better durability.
Stamped blades are lighter/cheaper but less sturdy than forged alternatives like Brewin.
Limited lifetime, covering manufacturing defects.
Designed for 14 pieces; universal slots fit most standards.
Only on sale under $60. Otherwise, go for Brewin CHEFILOSOPHI.
Use the SHARPAL 191H – pulls double/triple edges effortlessly.
Final Thoughts: The Paula Deen 51484 offers basic functionality at a low price, but its weaknesses in retention and build make alternatives like the Brewin set a smarter long-term buy. Shop top picks now.
