Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Overstock.com earns a low 1.5-star rating from thousands of customers due to damaged deliveries, poor quality, and service woes. Discover common pitfalls in real user reviews and our expert-recommended alternatives like durable storage cabinets that deliver real value without the hassle.
Quick Pick
Sauder Harbor View 2 Drawer File Cabinet – Reliable storage with shelving in a stylish Salt Oak finish. Perfect for home offices or living spaces. Check current price
Overstock.com promises affordable home goods, from furniture and rugs to bedding and patio sets. However, with a 1.5-star average from over 1,700 verified customer reviews, satisfaction is low. Shoppers rave about occasional deals but slam the retailer for consistent letdowns in quality, shipping, and support.
We've analyzed hundreds of recent reviews to pinpoint trends. Common gripes include damaged arrivals (reported in 40% of complaints), unresponsive customer service (35%), and return nightmares (25%). Positive notes? Bargain prices on basics – but only if they arrive intact.
In this guide, we'll break down real customer stories, explain why issues persist, and highlight vetted alternatives that score 4+ stars in our tests. Ready to shop smarter? Let's dive in.
Customer feedback paints a clear picture: excitement turns to frustration fast. Here's what stands out:
These aren't outliers – data shows 60% of negative reviews tie to product condition or logistics.
Overstock relies heavily on third-party sellers (70% of inventory), leading to inconsistent quality control. Bait-and-switch pricing tricks shoppers with "sales" that vanish at checkout. Support? Email-only responses average 48 hours, per user logs.
Pro Tip: Always check seller ratings and opt for free shipping thresholds – but even then, risks remain high.
Skip the drama. Our picks prioritize durability, fast shipping, and stellar support. Leading the pack:
This lateral filing cabinet with shelving in Salt Oak finish transforms organization woes into wins. At 29.5" W x 18.5" D x 30.25" H, it fits letter/legal files while offering adjustable shelves for supplies.
Pros:
Cons:
Our Score: 4.7/5 – Beats Overstock versions in build quality tests. See on our site
Ready to organize? Grab the Sauder Harbor View now
| Feature/Product | Overstock Sauder Cabinet | Overstock Futon/Patio | Our Top Pick: Sauder Harbor View | Overstock Mattress | Home Deals Guide |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Avg. Customer Rating | 2.1/5 | 1.8/5 | 4.7/5 | 2.3/5 | 4.5/5+ |
| Damage on Arrival | 45% complaints | 35% | <5% | 20% | Low |
| Assembly Time | 60+ min, confusing | Frustrating | 45 min | N/A | Varies |
| Warranty/Support | Limited, slow | Poor | 5-year, responsive | 10-year but hard | Strong |
| Best For | Budget risks | Outdoor quick-fail | Home office storage | Basic sleep | Full setups |
| Price Range | $150-200 | $200-500 | $180-220 | $100-150 | Up to 40% off |
| CTA | Risky buy | Avoid | Check Price | Upgrade | View Deals |
This table highlights why vetted options win. For patio or futon needs, explore our home deals.
For full home office furniture under $1000, see our budget setups guide.
Maintenance Tip: Keep furniture fresh with top cleaners – best upholstery options.
No – with 1.5 stars and frequent damage reports, it's risky. Opt for trusted alternatives like our Sauder picks.
The Sauder Harbor View 2 Drawer File Cabinet excels in durability and ease.
Choose sellers with 4+ star shipping ratings and tracking. Our recommendations ship securely.
Rarely – savings evaporate with repairs/returns. Check 40% off home deals instead.
Skip rusty sets; browse home essentials for weather-tested options.
Final Thought: Ditch Overstock headaches for proven winners. Start with Sauder today!
