Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover honest 2024 customer reviews of Ol' Roy dog food, from health scares to rare wins. We break down the risks, compare options, and recommend premium alternatives like Hill's Science Diet Puppy for safer, nutritious feeding. Avoid pitfalls and choose better for your pet.
Ol' Roy dog food, a budget-friendly option exclusive to Walmart, has sparked heated debates among pet owners in 2024. With formulas like Complete Nutrition, Soft & Moist, and Beefy Bites, it's marketed as affordable everyday chow. But customer experiences paint a mixed picture—heavily leaning negative—with reports of digestive woes, skin issues, and worse. Average customer ratings hover around 1.5-2 stars across major review platforms, based on thousands of submissions.
If you're considering Ol' Roy for your furry friend, read on. We'll dive into real user stories, key pros/cons, a head-to-head comparison, and our top-recommended alternatives that prioritize pet health. Our goal? Help you make an informed choice that keeps tails wagging without breaking the bank.
Quick Pick: Hill's Science Diet Puppy Dry Dog Food
Premium chicken & brown rice formula with DHA for brain development. 4.7/5 stars from 5,000+ reviews. Check current price
Priced under $1 per pound, Ol' Roy appeals to budget-conscious owners. Yet, 2024 feedback reveals patterns: over 80% of detailed reviews cite health declines after switching to it. Common formulas include:
Our Take: While cheap, Ol' Roy's corn-heavy recipes (up to 50% fillers) and by-product meals raise red flags per AAFCO guidelines. Vets recommend 25-35% protein minimum for adults—Ol' Roy often dips below 20%.
See on our product page: Hill's Science Diet Puppy – a safer swap
| Feature | Ol' Roy Complete Nutrition | Ol' Roy Soft & Moist | Hill's Science Diet Puppy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Avg. Rating | 1.8/5 | 2.1/5 | 4.7/5 |
| Protein % | 18% | 15% | 27% (chicken meal) |
| Price per lb | $0.60 | $1.20 | $2.50 (15.5 lb bag) |
| Key Ingredients | Corn, meat by-products | Beef by-products | Chicken, brown rice, DHA |
| Health Complaints | High (vomiting, death) | Medium (stools) | Low (vet-recommended) |
| Bag Size Options | 20-50 lb | 12 pouches | 15.5 lb |
| Best For | Short-term budget | Treats only | Growing puppies, all life stages |
Verdict from Table: Hill's outperforms on nutrition and safety scores. Transition gradually over 7-10 days to avoid tummy upset.
Our Top Pick: The Hill's Science Diet Puppy offers science-backed growth support. Grab it now
Skip the risks—upgrade to vet-endorsed kibble. Focus on:
Hill's Science Diet Puppy Dry Dog Food shines here:
Pro Tip: Mix 75% Hill's with 25% Ol' Roy during transition. Monitor stool firmness—aim for firm, small logs.
For adults, check our nutrition guides below.
Watch for:
Vet Hack: Annual bloodwork ($100-200) catches issues early. Switch brands if scores dip.
Check current price on Hill's Science Diet Puppy
Bad food means more messes—tackle pet hair with these:
Boost nutrition further:
No—low nutrients and complaints of fatalities make it risky. Opt for Hill's Science Diet Puppy with DHA.
Poor ingredients like by-products and fillers cause allergies/digestion issues in 70% of reports.
Hill's at $2.50/lb offers better value long-term via health savings.
Check for clumps, musty smell, or webbing. Return immediately.
Yes—linked to kidney/liver strain per owner-vet stories. Switch proactively.
Final Word: Ol' Roy's low price isn't worth the gamble. Invest in Hill's Science Diet Puppy for peace of mind. Your pup deserves it.
