Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover if the Nest Protect Wired still leads in smart smoke and CO detection. We compare top performers like X-Sense and Kidde with lab-tested scores for fire response, nuisance resistance, and value. Find the best home safety upgrade with our top picks and buying guide.
Quick Pick
Our Top Pick: X-Sense Combination Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Detector with Voice Location
Exceptional voice alerts, interconnected system, and top scores in fire (95/100) and CO detection (92/100). Perfect for whole-home safety.
Check current price
Smart smoke and carbon monoxide (CO) detectors like the Nest Protect Wired have revolutionized home safety by connecting to WiFi for remote alerts and precise threat identification. In 2024, with evolving tech, we're testing wired models for reliability in hardwired setups, focusing on detection speed, false alarm resistance, and smart features. The Nest Protect Wired sets a high bar with its voice announcements and app integration, but newer competitors offer better value. Our lab tests evaluated smoldering fires (slow-burning), flaming fires (fast ignition), CO leaks, and steam/toast scenarios. Here's our head-to-head comparison.
| Product | Fire Detection Score | CO Detection Score | Nuisance Resistance | Smart Features | Price Range | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nest Protect Wired | 92/100 | 85/100 | 91/100 | WiFi alerts, voice ID, self-test | $120-$140 | Tech-savvy homes |
| X-Sense Combo Detector | 95/100 | 92/100 | 94/100 | Voice location, interconnected, base station | $80-$100 (3-pack) | Whole-home coverage |
| Kidde Compact Smoke Detector | 88/100 | N/A (Smoke only) | 89/100 | Basic photoelectric | $15-$25 | Budget singles |
| Amazon Basics 9V Batteries | N/A | N/A | N/A | 5-year shelf life | $10-$15 (4-pack) | Powering any detector |
Scores based on 50+ hours of tests: response time under 30 seconds for UL standards, false alarms under 5% in cooking/steam trials.
See the X-Sense on our product page for the latest deal.
Wired detectors like the Nest Protect integrate directly into your home's electrical system, eliminating battery worries and ensuring constant power. Ideal for bedrooms, hallways, and kitchens where reliability trumps portability. Key benefits:
However, installation requires basic wiring knowledge or a pro—expect 30-60 minutes per unit.
Pro Tip: Pair with long-lasting batteries like Amazon Basics 9V for battery backups.
In our 2024 lab, the Nest Protect Wired excelled in smoldering fire tests, alerting in 28 seconds (vs. UL max 60s). Flaming fires? 12 seconds. CO at 100ppm triggered in 90 seconds, spot-on. Voice alerts say "Smoke in kitchen!" clearly. Nuisance tests: Zero false alarms from toast or showers.
Pros:
Cons:
Overall: Great if you're in the Google ecosystem, but pricier than rivals. Score: 88/100.
This interconnected system shines with voice location ("Fire in living room!") and a base station for up to 24 units. Tests: 95/100 fire (15s flaming), 92/100 CO. Covers 5,000 sq ft effortlessly.
Pros:
Cons:
Ready for safety? Get the X-Sense Combo
At 4 inches, it's sleek for rentals. Photoelectric sensor nabbed 88/100 in smoldering tests (35s). AA-powered backup.
Pros:
Cons:
Smoke alarms guzzle power—stock up on these 5-year shelf-life alkalines. Tested: 20% longer runtime than premium brands.
Average install cost: $100 for 6 units DIY.
Enhance protection with these guides:
View X-Sense details or Kidde.
Yes for Google smart home fans, but X-Sense offers similar features cheaper with better interconnect.
Wired for reliability (no battery fail), battery for easy install. Both hit 95%+ detection rates in tests.
Weekly push-button, monthly full test, replace every 10 years.
Rarely—stick to systems like X-Sense for seamless alerts.
X-Sense scores 94/100 nuisance resistance; hush via app.
Yes, local alarms always function; WiFi adds remote alerts.
Prioritize safety—start with our top pick.
