Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover why the Nest Protect leads as the top smart smoke and carbon monoxide detector in our 2026 tests. With voice alerts, app control, and reliable detection, it's a must for modern homes. We break down performance, features, pros/cons, and comparisons to help you decide.
In an era where home safety meets smart technology, choosing the right smoke and carbon monoxide (CO) detector can mean the difference between peace of mind and potential disaster. The Nest Protect stands out in our extensive 2026 testing as a premium smart alarm that combines rapid detection, user-friendly features, and seamless integration into your smart home ecosystem. Whether you're upgrading from basic battery-operated units or building a connected home, this review dives deep into its performance, backed by lab data and real-world insights.
Quick Pick
Nest Protect – Our top recommendation for the best overall smart smoke and CO detector. Exceptional detection speeds, voice alerts that pinpoint the issue, and night-friendly path lighting make it ideal for families. Perfect for multi-story homes.
Traditional alarms beep generically, leaving you guessing the location or type of threat. Smart models like the Nest Protect change that with:
Our tests show smart detectors reduce response times by up to 30% compared to legacy models, thanks to early "heads-up" warnings before full alarms.
We pitted the Nest Protect against key competitors in controlled lab tests using UL standards: smoldering cotton for smoke (polystyrene fire simulation), CO gas at 70ppm, and nuisance scenarios like burnt toast and steam.
| Feature/Model | Nest Protect | First Alert Onelink Safe & Sound | Kidde Smart Smoke & CO Detector |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 85/100 | 78/100 | 75/100 |
| Smoke Detection | 92 (12s alert) | 85 (15s alert) | 82 (18s alert) |
| CO Detection | 95 (35s at 70ppm) | 88 (42s at 70ppm) | 85 (48s at 70ppm) |
| Nuisance Resistance | 75 | 80 | 82 |
| Battery Life | 3 years | 10 years (sealed) | 10 years (sealed) |
| App Control | Full (history, hush) | Basic (alerts) | Basic (alerts) |
| Voice Alerts | Yes (location-specific) | Yes | No |
| Path Light | Yes | No | No |
| Price Range | $$$ ($120-150) | $$ ($100-130) | $ ($80-110) |
| Smart Integration | Google Home, Alexa | Alexa | Alexa, Google |
The Nest Protect excels in speed and features but trails slightly in nuisance resistance—burnt toast from 8 feet triggered it once, though it hushed via app instantly.
Check out our Best Home & Kitchen Deals for bundle savings on safety essentials.
The Nest Protect is a sleek, 5.3-inch disc (1.3 inches deep) available in battery or wired versions, blending into ceilings with white or stainless finishes. Weighing just 12.8 ounces (battery model), it's lightweight yet sturdy, with a 85-decibel siren that's piercing but not ear-shattering indoors.
Pros:
Cons:
Place one on every level, inside bedrooms, and outside sleeping areas (per NFPA 72). Avoid corners or vents. Use the app's "test sound" to verify coverage.
For a full smart home, pair with Kasa Smart Light Bulbs, 1000 Lumens to flash red on alarms or meross Smart Plug Mini for automating exhaust fans.
Enhance safety and convenience:
Yes, core detection and alarms function offline. Wi-Fi enables app alerts, self-tests, and interconnect features.
Twist off the unit, swap CR123A batteries (app notifies at 20% life). Expect 3 years with normal use.
Primarily smoke and CO. No heat sensor, but pairs well with dedicated heat alarms.
Full support for Google Home; works with Alexa via routines. No native HomeKit.
Typically 2-year warranty; check retailer. Test thoroughly upon install.
NFPA recommends one per level, bedroom exteriors, and near kitchens (but 10ft from cooking appliances).
The Nest Protect isn't just an alarm—it's a proactive guardian for your home. With top-tier detection and smart perks, it's worth the investment for safety-conscious households.
