Get the App
Better experience on mobile
The My Pillow 10-inch foam mattress promises comfort but falls short in support, cooling, and durability. With a low overall score of 4.2/10, discover its real performance from our tests and top-rated alternatives like the Sealy Dreamlife for superior sleep quality.
Quick Pick: Tired of sinking support? Our Top Recommendation: Sealy Dreamlife 14” Foam Mattress-in-a-Box, Queen. Gel memory foam and strong support make it a standout upgrade. Check current price
Finding the right mattress can transform your sleep, but not all foam beds deliver. The My Pillow 10-inch mattress, priced around $1,299 for a queen, markets itself as a plush, pillow-top foam option with a medium-firm feel. At 10 inches thick, it features a quilted cover and layers of gel-infused memory foam. However, our hands-on testing revealed significant shortcomings in key areas like support and cooling.
We evaluated it using rigorous protocols: testers of various weights (120-250 lbs) spent nights in multiple positions, checked motion transfer by simulating partner movement, tested edge stability by sitting and lying near borders, and monitored temperature over 8-hour sleeps. Result? An overall score of 4.2/10. While it might appeal to ultra-lightweight side sleepers seeking initial softness, most users will find it lacking. Stick around for a detailed breakdown and high-performing alternatives.
We pitted the My Pillow against proven foam and hybrid options. Scores are out of 10 based on support, cooling, motion isolation, and value.
| Mattress | Type | Thickness | Firmness | Overall Score | Price (Queen) | Key Strength |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| My Pillow 10 | Foam | 10" | Medium-Firm | 4.2 | $1,299 | Initial Softness |
| Sealy Dreamlife 14” Foam | Foam | 14" | Medium | 9.1 | $800+ | Pressure Relief |
| Sven & Son Platinum Hybrid (Split King) | Hybrid + Base | 14" | Medium-Soft | 9.5 | $2,000+ | Cooling & Adjustability |
| GhostBed Luxe 13 Inch | Memory Foam | 13" | Medium-Firm | 8.9 | $1,200+ | Motion Isolation |
| LUCID Gel Infused Topper | Foam Topper | 3" | Plush | 8.7 | $150+ | Budget Upgrade |
See on our page: Sealy Dreamlife Queen delivers machine-washable cooling at half the price.
This all-foam bed stacks three layers: a 1-inch gel memory foam pillow top, a gel memory foam comfort layer (about 2 inches), and a 7-inch high-density polyfoam base. The quilted cover adds a plush touch but isn't removable for cleaning. CertiPUR-US certified foams mean low VOCs, a plus for indoor air quality.
Trial & Warranty: 60-night trial, 10-year warranty—standard but shorter than competitors' 100+ nights/lifetime options.
Pros:
Cons:
Ready for better? Check the Sealy Dreamlife for real pressure relief.
Skip the disappointments—here are vetted upgrades with superior specs.
Thicker at 14 inches with SealyComfort gel memory foam and SealySupport transition layers. Score: 9.1/10. Excellent for all positions; cools 3°F better via open-cell design.
Pros:
Cons:
Best Value Upgrade: See on Review Atlas
Hybrid springs + foam with lumbar support, massage, and USB ports. Score: 9.5/10. Ideal for couples; zero motion transfer.
Pros:
Cons:
Cooling cover + gel foam for pressure relief. Score: 8.9/10. Great motion isolation (95% absorption).
Pros:
Cons:
Revive your old mattress affordably. Score: 8.7/10. 5-zone support relieves hotspots.
Pros:
Cons:
Enhance any pick with the Kmall King Cooling Mattress Protector or Homemate Queen Mattress Topper.
Prioritize your sleep style:
For stains on your current setup, try Kids 'N' Pets Stain Remover.
No—poor support causes spinal misalignment. Opt for Sealy Dreamlife instead.
It lags in durability and cooling; alternatives score 2x higher.
Sealy Dreamlife Queen offers premium foam at budget prices.
Yes, expect 4°F rise; choose GhostBed Luxe for cooling.
Yes, LUCID adds support without full replacement.
Pair your new mattress with essentials:
Upgrade today for nights of uninterrupted rest!
