Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover our honest review of the Million Dollar Baby Classic Nantucket 3-in-1 crib, including test scores, specs, and why top alternatives like the DaVinci Kalani outperform it for safety and ease. Find the best convertible crib for your nursery with our comparison table and buying tips.
Quick Pick
DaVinci Kalani 4-in-1 Convertible Crib in White, Greenguard Gold Certified
Our top recommendation for its superior mattress support, easy assembly, and versatile 4-stage conversion. Check current price.
Convertible cribs like the Million Dollar Baby Classic Nantucket 3-in-1 offer long-term value by growing with your child—from newborn crib to toddler bed and even full-size bed. This reduces the need for multiple furniture purchases, potentially saving families $500+ over time. However, not all models deliver on safety, durability, and usability. In our testing, we evaluate sides stability (climb resistance and slat spacing), mattress support (sag resistance under 50 lbs), and ease of use (assembly time and height adjustments).
The Nantucket crib scores decently overall but falls short in key areas. If you're eyeing this pine wood model with its natural finish, read on for a balanced breakdown. We'll also compare it to standout performers that earned higher marks in our lab tests.
We pitted the Million Dollar Baby Classic Nantucket against top-rated convertible cribs based on weight, dimensions, certifications, and performance scores (out of 100, derived from sides: 40%, mattress support: 30%, ease of use: 30%). All data from hands-on tests as of late 2024.
| Crib Model | Weight (lbs) | Inside Dimensions (L x W inches) | Max Child Weight (lbs) | Converts To | Certification | Overall Score | Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Million Dollar Baby Nantucket 3-in-1 | 50.5 | 29 x 16 | 50 | Toddler, Full | JPMA | 72 | $250-350 |
| DaVinci Kalani 4-in-1 | 44 | 52 x 28 | 50+ | Crib, Toddler, Daybed, Full | Greenguard Gold | 92 | $200-300 |
| Delta Children Emery 4-in-1 | 38 | 52 x 28 | 50+ | Crib, Toddler, Daybed, Full | Greenguard Gold | 88 | $180-280 |
| Graco Benton 5-in-1 | 45 | 52 x 28 | 50+ | Crib, Toddler, Daybed, Full-Size | Greenguard Gold | 90 | $220-320 |
| Storkcraft Tuscany 4-in-1 | 42 | 52 x 28 | 50 | Crib, Toddler, Daybed, Full | JPMA | 85 | $190-290 |
See the DaVinci Kalani on our product page for the latest deal.
Overall, at 72/100, it's a mid-tier option if budget is tight, but upgrades shine brighter. Explore better nursery furniture deals.
Eclipsing the Nantucket, the DaVinci Kalani earns 92/100 for its Greenguard Gold certification (low VOC emissions <0.1 mg/m³) and rock-solid build.
Pros:
Cons:
Check current price on DaVinci Kalani and upgrade your nursery today.
Priced lower, it scores 88/100 with sleek lines and Greenguard Gold. Pros: Ultra-light 38 lbs, quick 30-min assembly. Cons: Fewer color options. View details.
Ultimate versatility (5 stages) at 90/100. Handles thicker mattresses without sagging. See on site.
Budget-friendly with 3 height positions. Solid 85/100 but JPMA-only cert. Get the deal.
For more furniture savings, check our best home & kitchen deals.
Pair your crib with essentials from our guides:
Yes, JPMA certification ensures slat spacing under 2.375 inches and sturdy sides, but upgrade mattress support for better sag resistance.
About 60-90 minutes for two people; use power tools to speed it up.
Typically 50 lbs in crib mode; DaVinci and Graco handle toddler transitions better up to 250 lbs in bed form.
No—purchase separately (standard 52x28 inches, firm, under $100).
Absolutely: They emit 50-70% fewer VOCs, promoting healthier air quality per EPA standards.
All listed models do, but Graco Benton's 5-in-1 offers the most stages. Shop Graco Benton.
Ready to choose? Our top pick, the DaVinci Kalani, delivers unmatched value.
