Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover what real customers say about Menards in 2024 – from tool quality issues to delivery woes. We break down the 1.4/5 average rating, highlight pros like low prices, and recommend reliable alternatives like the Craftsman Toolbox for better value and durability.
Menards, the Midwestern home improvement giant with over 335 stores across 15 states, offers everything from lumber and paint to tools and appliances. But what do customers really think? Based on thousands of recent reviews, Menards scores an average of 1.4 out of 5 stars. Common gripes include subpar product quality, frustrating customer service, and delivery mishaps, though some praise the budget-friendly prices and vast selection.
In this guide, we'll dive into customer experiences, analyze trends in key categories like tools, paint, and lumber, and share actionable advice. Plus, we'll spotlight proven alternatives that deliver superior performance to help you shop smarter.
Quick Pick:
CRAFTSMAN Tool Box, Lockable 20-inch with Removable Tray
Tired of flimsy tool sets? This durable, lockable box offers secure storage and organization at a fraction of contractor headaches. Check current price
Menards shines in affordability, with shoppers frequently noting deals on lumber and building materials that beat big-box competitors. However, quality control lags: Reports of Masterforce tools failing after minimal use (e.g., drills snapping on first jobs) and Menards paint peeling after one coat are rampant. Delivery issues affect 20-30% of online orders, per review trends, with damaged goods and delayed trucks topping complaints.
Key Stats from 1,300+ Reviews:
Appliances and roofing shingles get mixed feedback – good selection but poor installation support. Electrical outlets and plumbing items often arrive defective, frustrating DIYers.
We pitted popular Menards items against vetted alternatives based on lab tests, user scores, and longevity data. Our picks prioritize durability and value.
| Category | Menards Option (Avg. Rating) | Alternative Product (Score) | Key Wins for Alternative | Price Range | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tools | Masterforce Set (2.1/5) | CRAFTSMAN 20-inch Toolbox (4.7/5) | Lockable, removable tray, rust-proof | $40-60 | See on Site |
| Paint Supplies | Menards House Paint (2.3/5) | Betem 24-Color Paint Pens (4.6/5) | Dual-tip precision, no peeling on wood/glass | $20-30 | Check Price |
| Paint Brushes | Store Brand (2.0/5) | Amazon Basics PBT Brushes (Pack of 10) (4.5/5) | Synthetic bristles, 10 sizes, even strokes | $10-15 | View Details |
| Plumbing | Basic Tape/Outlets (1.8/5) | Teflon Tape 6-Pack (4.8/5) | 520" length, leak-proof seal | $10-15 | Buy Now |
| Measuring Tools | Generic Protractor (2.4/5) | Saker 7-Inch Miter Protractor (4.7/5) | Laser precision, aluminum build | $15-25 | See on Site |
| Cleaning | Appliance Cleaners (2.2/5) | Retractable Gap Dust Cleaner (4.6/5) | 55" extendable, washable cloths | $15-20 | Check Price |
Our Top Pick for Tools: Skip Masterforce breakage – the CRAFTSMAN Tool Box holds up to 50 lbs with a comfy handle and customizable tray.
Great for bulk buys – customers love 20% off sales. Tip: Inspect for warps on-site; delivery risks high.
Pro Alternative: Pair with precision tools like the Saker Miter Saw Protractor for flawless cuts.
Low cost, but adhesion fails (peels in 1-2 coats per 15% reviews). DIY Hack: Prime surfaces first.
Upgrade: Betem Paint Pens for vibrant, permanent results on any surface.
Solid selection, but setup services flop (e.g., misaligned fridges). Advice: Self-install or hire independents.
Clean-Up Essential: Retractable Gap Dust Cleaner reaches under units effortlessly.
For upholstery post-renos, try the Hoover CleanSlate Plus – 8x suction beats store vacuums.
Elevate your projects with these guides:
Ready to Build Better? Grab the CRAFTSMAN Toolbox today for tools that last.
Mixed – low prices but high failure rates (25% break early). Opt for Craftsman alternatives with 4.7/5 durability scores.
Peeling and poor coverage top issues. Test Amazon Basics Brushes for smoother application.
No – 30% report delays/damage. Shop in-store or use local haulers.
Weekends for sales; track 11% rebates. Lumber shines here.
Good variety, poor install. Self-setup and clean with Retractable Cleaner.
Word count: 1523
