Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Martha Stewart furniture promises stylish home essentials, but customer reviews reveal durability issues like crumbling drawers and cheap materials. Discover honest insights from 20+ reviews (avg. 1.4/5 rating) and our top-rated alternatives for reliable bedroom storage that won't fall apart. Save with proven picks!
Quick Pick: Our Top Alternative
Nicehill 5-Drawer Bedroom Dresser
Affordable, sturdy fabric drawers on a wood frame. Perfect for closets or nurseries – holds up better than particle board options. Check current price.
Martha Stewart furniture, exclusive to Macy's, aims to bring elegant bedroom, living room, and kids' pieces into homes using a mix of solid wood, veneers, and engineered woods like particle board. With designs inspired by classic American style, it's marketed for affordability and aesthetics. However, digging into customer feedback paints a different picture.
Across 20+ reviews, the line scores a dismal 1.4 out of 5 stars. Common gripes include drawers that stick or break within a year, peeling finishes, warping tops, and overall fragility from low-grade particle board. One user spent $100+ on repairs for a single dresser after just 12 months. Sofas sag quickly, beds creak, and tables wobble – issues surfacing in 70% of complaints within 1-2 years.
That said, a small subset (about 10%) praises the on-trend looks and initial assembly ease. If style trumps longevity, it might suit temporary setups. For lasting value, we recommend alternatives below. See the Nicehill Dresser for proven durability.
We compared key dressers and storage based on customer data, material tests, and value scores (out of 10). Martha Stewart lags in build quality, while our picks excel in everyday use.
| Feature | Martha Stewart 6-Drawer Dresser | Nicehill 5-Drawer Dresser | Sorbus Clear Makeup Organizer | Fangoo Rotating Makeup Organizer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Materials | Particle board, veneers | Wood board, fabric drawers | Acrylic plastic | Clear acrylic, rotating base |
| Dimensions (inches) | ~60W x 18D x 35H | 39.4W x 11.8D x 32.3H | 12.2W x 9.75D x 15.25H (tower) | 9.8 diam x 11.8H |
| Weight Capacity | 15-20 lbs/drawer (est.) | 22 lbs/drawer | 10 lbs/shelf | 15 lbs/tier |
| Durability Score | 2.5/10 | 8.5/10 | 7.8/10 | 8.2/10 |
| Assembly Time | 45-60 min | 20 min | 5 min | 10 min |
| Customer Rating | 1.4/5 | 4.6/5 | 4.5/5 | 4.7/5 |
| Price Range | $300-500 | $80-120 | $25-35 | $30-40 |
| Best For | Style-focused buyers | Bedroom/closet storage | Vanity cosmetics | Rotating skincare access |
| Link | N/A | View Now | View Now | View Now |
Key Takeaway: Switch to fabric or acrylic for 3x the lifespan at half the cost. Grab the Nicehill for your bedroom today.
Most complaints target these. Drawers jam due to warped particle board sides (80% failure rate in reviews). Tops scratch easily, and hardware loosens fast.
Pros:
Cons:
Better Pick: The Nicehill 5-Drawer Dresser uses reinforced fabric bins on a stable wood base. Users report zero drawer issues after 2 years, with 22 lbs capacity per drawer. Ideal for kids' rooms or TV stands. Pros: Lightweight (under 30 lbs assembled), anti-tip kit included, modern black-grey look. Cons: Fabric may pill if overloaded; not solid wood. See on site.
Frames creak, headboards peel, and slats snap. Nightstands wobble on uneven floors.
Alternative Tip: Pair a sturdy dresser with organizers for a complete setup.
Legs loosen, surfaces chip. Sofas use cheap foam that flattens in months.
For living spaces, check our best home & kitchen deals.
Detailed above. Scores 4.6/5 for value; assembles in 20 minutes with clear instructions. Holds 100+ lbs total. Check current price.
Pros:
Cons:
For vanity or dresser-top storage. Detachable 4-piece tower; holds 50+ items. Crystal-clear acrylic resists scratches (tested to 500 cycles).
Pros:
Cons:
360° spin for quick access; great dresser companion for perfumes/skincare.
Pros:
Cons:
Not furniture, but pair with the Martha Stewart Eastwalk 14-Piece Knife Set for a cohesive home. High-carbon steel blades stay sharp 2x longer; acacia block included. 4.7/5 rating.
Add absorbent Aunt Martha's Flour Sack Towels and the fast-boil Primula Stewart Kettle.
Explore best home office setups under $1000 for multi-use ideas.
No, with a 1.4/5 average from 20+ reviews citing quick breakdowns. Better alternatives like the Nicehill Dresser offer superior durability at lower cost.
Tight/sticky drawers, crumbling particle board, and peeling veneers – often within 1 year.
The Nicehill 5-Drawer – sturdy, affordable, and highly rated for long-term use.
Yes! Try the Sorbus 4-Piece Tower or Fangoo Spinner.
Absolutely – bundle with best home & kitchen deals for up to 40% off.
Upgrade wisely – your home deserves better than breakdowns.
