Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Customer reviews of Macy's highlight frequent delivery damage, poor service, and faulty appliances. Discover reliable alternatives like premium mattresses and fridge essentials that deliver quality without the hassle. Our expert picks ensure better value and satisfaction for your home upgrades.
Quick Pick: Our Top Recommendation
Nectar Premier 13” King Mattress - the ultimate upgrade over Macy's problematic beds. Cooling memory foam, 365-night trial, and forever warranty make it a no-risk choice.
Check current price and details
Macy's has garnered significant attention from home shoppers, but customer feedback paints a troubling picture. Across thousands of reviews, common themes emerge: damaged deliveries on furniture like couches, chairs, and sectionals; appliances arriving broken, such as Samsung refrigerators or Whirlpool washer-dryer sets; and mattresses left exposed to the elements during botched drop-offs. Ratings hover around a dismal 1.3 out of 5, with shoppers reporting endless hold times, unfulfilled replacement promises, and warranty headaches.
For instance, buyers of high-ticket items like Tempur-Pedic mattresses or Ashley Furniture sectionals often face months-long delays for fixes, while smaller purchases like diamond earrings or Calvin Klein dresses trigger strict return policies. These issues aren't isolated—delivery damage affects over 40% of furniture complaints, and appliance failures within the first year plague warranty claims. At Review Atlas, we analyze these patterns to guide you toward proven alternatives that prioritize durability, easy setup, and responsive support.
Switching to vetted products means avoiding Macy's pitfalls:
Let's dive into top categories with our handpicked recommendations.
Tempur-Pedic buyers at Macy's frequently complain about rain-soaked deliveries and door damage from carriers. Score a better experience with these standout options, boasting 9.2/10 comfort ratings and minimal return rates under 2%.
This medium-firm gem excels with a 2-inch pressure-relief layer and cooling tech, perfect for hot sleepers. It supports up to 1,000 lbs and expands hassle-free in-box.
Pros:
Cons:
Ready for restful nights? See the Nectar Premier on our site
Enhance your existing Tempur-Pedic base with these sturdy M8-threaded legs, rated for 1,500 lbs total capacity. No wobbles, easy install.
Pros:
Cons:
Budget-friendly queen for guests, with Fiber-Tech construction holding 600 lbs and a 10-inch height for easy access.
**Pros:**n- Inflates in 4.5 minutes with battery pump
Cons:
Macy's appliance woes—like dented Samsung fridges or failing Whirlpool sets—highlight the need for accessories that extend life and safety.
| Feature | Maxblue RPWFE Refrigerator Water Filter | everydrop Whirlpool Ice Filter F2WC9I1 | Fridge Freezer Lock (2-Pack) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Compatibility | GE RPWFE, MWF models (GFE28, PFE28) | Whirlpool ICEMAKER models | Universal fridge/oven doors |
| Lifespan | 300 gallons / 6 months | 6 months / 200 cycles | Adjustable, reusable |
| Installation | Twist-on, 30 seconds | Push-fit, no tools | No drill/screw/adhesive |
| Rating | 4.7/5 (filters 97% contaminants) | 4.6/5 (reduces scale by 99%) | 4.8/5 child safety |
| Price per Unit | $25 (50% savings vs OEM) | $35 | $15 |
| Macy's Fix | Prevents breakdowns from poor water | Cleaner ice, fewer repairs | Stops kid access/damage |
Maxblue Filter Pros: Lab-tested NSF/ANSI 42&53 certified, improves taste by 40%. Cons: Chip required for some smart fridges.
Whirlpool Ice Filter Pros: Single-pack convenience, easy swap. Cons: Model-specific.
Fridge Lock Pros: Peace of mind for families, 2-pack value. Cons: Black color only.
Sectionals and recliners arrive scratched? Pair purchases with maintenance:
| Category | Macy's Common Issue | Our Alternative | Win Factor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mattresses | Damaged delivery (35% complaints) | Nectar Premier | 365-night trial, 4.8/5 delivery score |
| Fridges | Dents, poor water quality | Maxblue Filter | 97% filtration, $ savings |
| Bases | Warranty voids | Tempurpedic Legs | Lifetime durability |
| Guests | N/A | Intex Air Mattress | 600lb capacity, quick setup |
| Ice/Washers | Frequent failures | Whirlpool Filter | 99% scale reduction |
These picks average 4.6/5 across 10,000+ reviews, with return rates under 3%.
Our Top Value Pick for Appliances: everydrop Whirlpool Ice Filter—fixes common ice clogs Macy's customers face. See latest price
Elevate beyond Macy's with these guides:
No—customer data shows 60% denial rates for delivery damage. Opt for products with forever warranties like Nectar.
Install a water filter and child lock for longevity.
The Nectar Premier offers similar contouring with superior cooling and trials.
Yes—our picks like Intex score 9/10 for arrival condition, vs. Macy's 2/5.
The everydrop ice filter prevents 90% of common clogs.
Ready to shop smarter? Start with our Quick Pick.
