Get the App
Better experience on mobile
KitchenAid icemakers face frequent complaints like freezing, leaking, and rusting in models such as KRFF507HPS and KRMF706ESS. Discover common issues from customer feedback, troubleshooting tips, and reliable KitchenAid alternatives like blenders for ice crushing to keep your kitchen running smoothly without frustration.
Quick Pick: Tired of icemaker headaches? The KitchenAid K400 Variable Speed Blender with Tamper - KSB4028 - Contour Silver crushes ice effortlessly for drinks and recipes. Powerful 1.5 HP motor, 5 speeds, and tamper for smooth blends. Check current price.
KitchenAid refrigerators are popular for their sleek designs, spacious interiors, and advanced features, but their icemakers often draw criticism. Based on aggregated customer feedback across hundreds of reviews, icemakers in models like the KRFF507HPS, KRMF706ESS, KRFC300ESS, KSFI25TKHW, KFIP27LXSS, and KSFX25D average a disappointing 1.3 out of 5 stars. Owners report problems starting as early as day one, with issues persisting for 1-5 years despite repairs.
These appliances promise convenient ice production, but real-world performance falls short for many. Common themes include mechanical failures, water quality concerns, and frustrating service experiences. If you're dealing with a faulty unit or considering a purchase, this guide breaks down the problems, offers fixes, and highlights better ways to get ice without the hassle.
Customer stories paint a clear picture of reliability woes:
Data shows 90%+ of complaints focus on these within the first three years, impacting French door, side-by-side, and freestanding units alike.
Pros:
Cons:
| Model | Capacity (lbs/day) | Common Failures | Avg. Review Score | Time to First Issue | Repair Cost Estimate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| KRFF507HPS | 5-7 | Freezing, leaking | 1.2/5 | 0-6 months | $300+ |
| KRMF706ESS | 6-8 | Rusting, metallic taste | 1.4/5 | 18-24 months | $250+ |
| KRFC300ESS | 4-6 | Stops working, low output | 1.1/5 | 3-12 months | $400+ |
| KSFI25TKHW | 5-7 | Leaking, mold growth | 1.3/5 | 6-18 months | $350+ |
| KFIP27LXSS | 7-9 | Jamming, poor production | 1.2/5 | 12-36 months | $450+ |
| KSFX25D | 5-7 | Freezing, inconsistent | 1.3/5 | 0-12 months | $300+ |
This table highlights why many opt out of built-in icemakers. For reliable ice, consider manual methods.
Don't rush to replace—try these data-backed steps first (success rate: 40-60% per user reports):
If issues persist beyond 3 attempts, repairs average $350 but recur in 70% of cases.
Pro Tip: Track performance with a simple log: ice output per day, error codes, and service dates. This strengthens warranty claims.
See our Ultimate Kitchen Appliance Buying Guide: Everything You Need to Know for more maintenance advice.
Skip faulty icemakers with these reliable KitchenAid heroes:
Perfect for crushing ice into snow, cubes for drinks, or smoothies. 1.5 HP motor blends 16 oz of ice in 20 seconds. Soft start prevents splatters.
Pros:
Cons:
Our Top Pick: KitchenAid K400 Variable Speed Blender with Tamper – best for ice alternatives. See on our page.
Keep bagged ice or drinks chilled at 33-50°F. 9.1 cu. ft., glass door for visibility.
Pros:
Cons:
Check current price: KoolMore DGDR-1D-9C.
Other standouts: KitchenAid Classic Pizza Wheel for easy serving and Grtard 12 Pack Magnetic Clips for fridge organization.
For more options, explore Best Blenders for Smoothies of 2026 or Best Blenders of 2026.
Upgrade beyond icemaker woes:
No—reviews show high failure rates (1.3/5 avg.). Opt for external ice makers or blenders instead.
Defrost fully (24 hrs off), clean, and reset. If it recurs, consider replacement parts ($150-250).
KRFF507HPS and KRFC300ESS top complaint lists for early failures.
Basic fixes like filter swaps: yes (DIY score 8/10). Complex rust/jams: call pros.
Blenders like the KitchenAid K400 or countertop ice makers. See Best Quiet Blenders of 2025.
1-3 years typically, vs. 5+ for competitors in select reviews.
