Get the App
Better experience on mobile
We tested the Hotpoint HHM5SMWW 5 cu ft chest freezer and found major flaws in temperature control and efficiency. Discover its full pros/cons, detailed scores, and why top picks like the Danby DCF072A2WDB1 outperform it for reliable freezing.
Quick Pick:
For the best balance of capacity, reliability, and value, go with the Danby DCF072A2WDB1 Chest Freezer, 7.2 Cubic Feet. It delivers superior temperature stability and lower energy costs compared to budget models like the Hotpoint. Check current price.
Chest freezers are essential for bulk shoppers, hunters, or anyone needing extra frozen storage in garages, basements, or kitchens. The Hotpoint HHM5SMWW, a 5.0 cubic foot manual defrost model, appeals to budget buyers at around $219 MSRP. But does its low price justify performance shortcomings? In our hands-on testing inspired by rigorous lab standards, it earned an overall score of 58/100—mediocre at best.
We evaluated temperature control, uniformity, stability, freezing speed, and energy use. While it has basic features like a power-on light and one storage basket, it lags in critical areas. If you're eyeing this for long-term use, consider our top alternatives below. See the Danby on our product page for a proven upgrade.
We compared the Hotpoint HHM5SMWW against three strong contenders: the compact Midea MERC04C4BAWW, spacious Danby DCF072A2WDB1, and matching-size Arctic King ARC050S0ARAB. Here's how they stack up based on key metrics (scores out of 100, energy costs estimated at $0.13/kWh national average).
| Feature | Hotpoint HHM5SMWW | Midea MERC04C4BAWW (3.5 cu ft) | Danby DCF072A2WDB1 (7.2 cu ft) | Arctic King ARC050S0ARAB (5.0 cu ft) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 58 | 82 | 91 | 85 |
| Capacity | 5.0 cu ft | 3.5 cu ft | 7.2 cu ft | 5.0 cu ft |
| Defrost Type | Manual | Manual | Manual | Manual |
| Thermostat Control | Poor (2.3°F off) | Good (0.5°F off) | Excellent (0.2°F off) | Good (0.8°F off) |
| Temp Uniformity | Fair (15.2°F var) | Good (8°F var) | Excellent (4°F var) | Good (10°F var) |
| Temp Stability (post-door open) | Poor (42.9°F rise) | Good (20°F rise) | Excellent (12°F rise) | Good (25°F rise) |
| Freezing Capacity (5 lbs pack) | Poor (108 min) | Good (65 min) | Excellent (52 min) | Good (72 min) |
| Annual Energy Cost | $51 | $42 | $58 (larger size) | $48 |
| Dimensions (HWD in.) | 33.5 x 28.8 x 20.1 | 33.5 x 28.7 x 20.5 | 33.1 x 39.9 x 22.2 | 33.5 x 28.7 x 20.5 |
| Weight (lbs) | 50 | 55 | 79 | 52 |
| MSRP | $219 | $249 | $349 | $279 |
| Warranty | 1 year | 1 year | 1 year | 1 year |
View the top-rated Danby DCF072A2WDB1—ideal for families needing more space.
The Hotpoint features a bottom-hinge lid that stays open, handy for loading. An interior light (switch-activated) and exterior power indicator add convenience. One lift-out basket organizes smaller items, but no high-temp or temperature alarms mean you risk unnoticed thawing.
Dimensions fit tight spaces (33.5" H x 28.8" W x 20.1" D, 50 lbs), and it's not Energy Star certified.
Pros:
Cons:
Verdict: Skip it unless price is your only factor. Upgrade to the Arctic King ARC050S0ARAB for similar size, better performance.
This 7.2 cu ft beast shines for large households. Excellent thermostat holds within 0.2°F, uniformity at 4°F variance, and quick 12°F recovery. Freezes 5 lbs in 52 minutes; $58/year energy for its size is efficient (0.45 kWh/day).
Pros:
Cons:
Check current price on Danby DCF072A2WDB1—top for 2025 reliability.
Matching Hotpoint's size in black finish, it improves with 0.8°F thermostat accuracy, 10°F uniformity, and 25°F recovery. Freezes faster (72 min), $48/year energy.
Pros:
Cons:
At 3.5 cu ft, perfect for apartments. Strong 82/100 score: 0.5°F control, 8°F uniformity, $42/year energy.
Pros:
Cons:
Read our Ultimate Kitchen Appliance Buying Guide for more tips.
No—its poor temperature performance (2.3°F off setpoint, 42.9°F recovery) risks food spoilage. Opt for the Arctic King instead.
Fair at $51/year, but Danby ($58 for double size) and Midea ($42) are better per cu ft.
The Danby DCF072A2WDB1 handles fluctuations best.
No, lacking this safety net—unlike premium models.
Yes for bulk savings, but pick high-scorers to cut energy bills amid rising costs.
Pair your freezer with essentials:
