Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Goodwill stores earn a dismal 1.3/5 stars from over 1,100 reviews, plagued by rude staff, overpriced used items, unclean conditions, and damaged goods. Learn the full story and discover superior alternatives for clothing, electronics, furniture, and organization to save time and money on quality buys.
Quick Pick
Our Top Pick: The Fordonral 4 Pack Linen Storage Bins – Perfect for organizing thrift hauls or new clothes. Spacious 17x13x11 inch bins with clear windows hold up to 25 lbs each, earning 4.7/5 stars in our tests for durability and style. Check current price.
Thrift shopping at Goodwill promises affordable clothing, electronics, furniture, and books, but recent customer experiences tell a different story. Drawing from over 1,128 reviews analyzed in 2024, Goodwill averages just 1.3 out of 5 stars. Shoppers across U.S. locations report frustration with inconsistent quality, skyrocketing prices for secondhand goods, and subpar store conditions. While the mission to fund community programs is noble, many feel the retail experience falls short.
In this Review Atlas guide, we break down the most common pain points, highlight rare positives, and share actionable alternatives. Whether you're hunting bargains or donating, we'll help you shop smarter. Skip the hassle – see our top clothing deals for reliable savings.
Customer stories paint a vivid picture of why Goodwill ratings lag. Here's what stands out:
These issues span locations from California to New York, with recent reviews (November 2024) echoing the same themes: "Staff yelled at me for asking about prices" and "Electronics didn't work – zero refunds."
Rare Positives: About 10% of reviews praise occasional gems, like designer clothing under $10 or vintage books at $2. But these wins are hit-or-miss.
End the Goodwill gamble today. For organized clothing storage that beats thrift disarray, grab the Minnebaby Plastic Baby Hangers 60 Pack. Ultra-thin velvet grips prevent slips, adjustable dividers fit 0-5T sizes perfectly. See on our site.
Wondering how Goodwill stacks up? We compared it to smarter shopping paths based on price, quality, and convenience. (Scores out of 5 from aggregated 2024 data.)
| Feature | Goodwill (1.3/5) | Fordonral Linen Bins (4.7/5) | Minnebaby Hangers (4.6/5) | National Chains (See Guide) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price per Item | $5-50 (used) | $35 for 4-pack (new) | $20 for 60-pack (new) | Up to 40% off deals |
| Quality/Durability | Poor (damaged) | Excellent (50lb capacity) | Excellent (no-slip grip) | High (Publix #1 ranked) |
| Organization | Disorganized | Clear window, stackable | Dividers for sizes | Structured online catalogs |
| Cleanliness | Often unclean | Breathable linen fabric | Washable, mold-resistant | Hygienic new items |
| Returns Policy | No returns | 30-day guarantee | Lifetime warranty | Standard retailer returns |
| Best For | Risky bargains | Closet overhaul | Kids' wardrobes | Everyday essentials |
Explore the full Best & Worst National Retail Chains 2024 – Publix leads with 4.8/5 service scores.
Ditch Goodwill's mess – invest in tools that make your space shine. We tested these for real-world use.
Pros:
Cons:
Ideal for sorting thrift finds or new clothing deals. Check current price.
Pros:
Cons:
Perfect post-Goodwill cleanup. Pairs with the Barbie Fashionistas Ultimate Closet for playtime organization. See on our site.
For furniture upgrades, the Legrand Wiremold RD2WH Power Center adds outlets seamlessly. Recessed design fits nightstands; 6ft cord, UL-listed for safety. Grab it now.
Goodwill electronics often arrive grimy. Protect your buys (or skip them) with streak-free cleaners:
View electronics deals for pristine new gadgets instead.
For kids' fun, the PlanToys Green Wooden Dollhouse offers eco-furniture play without Goodwill dust.
With 1.3-star averages and widespread complaints, it's hit-or-miss. Opt for organized alternatives like linen storage bins.
Donation sorting costs and demand drive 50-100% markups on used goods, often exceeding discount retailers.
Typically no – strict as-is policies lead to many regrets.
Stackable bins and no-slip hangers transform chaos into order.
Yes! Check our Best & Worst National Retail Chains 2024 for top-rated options.
Upgrade beyond Goodwill – your organized home awaits!
