Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover our hands-on test of the Food Network Pre-Seasoned 10-Inch Cast Iron Skillet (score: 62/100). Uneven heating and hot handles hold it back. We compare it to top performers like the Lodge 10.25-Inch for even cooking and durability. Find the best for your kitchen today.
Quick Pick
Lodge 10.25-Inch Cast Iron Skillet – Our top choice for everyday cooking. Exceptional even heating (95/100), pre-seasoned for immediate use, and built to last generations. Includes a silicone hot handle holder for safety.
Check current price and details
Cast iron skillets are timeless kitchen warriors, excelling at high-heat searing, oven roasting, and even campfire cooking. A 10-inch size strikes the perfect balance: big enough for two chicken breasts or a steak, yet nimble for single servings or sides. In our lab tests of over a dozen models, we prioritize even heat distribution, searing power, ease of maintenance, and real-world usability.
The Food Network Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (10 in.) enters as a budget contender under $25. It's oven-safe to 500°F and pre-seasoned out of the box. But does low price mean compromises? Our tests reveal uneven performance (overall score: 62/100), making it better for occasional use than daily duty. We'll break it down, then spotlight superior alternatives like the Lodge and Commercial Chef sets.
See the best home & kitchen deals for more savings
We pitted the Food Network against proven winners in standardized tests: heating a full pan of water to boil (evenness), simmering marinara for 30 minutes (no scorching), roasting bone-in chicken thighs (crisp skin, juicy meat), and deglazing for pan sauce (flavor depth). Weights measured on a digital scale; handles tested with infrared thermometer.
| Feature | Food Network 10" (Score) | Lodge 10.25" (Score) | Commercial Chef 10" (Score) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 62 | 92 | 85 |
| Heating Evenness | 45 (Hot spots up to 50°F difference) | 95 (Uniform ±5°F) | 88 (±10°F variance) |
| Sauce Simmering | 75 (Minor sticking) | 98 (Flawless) | 90 (Light fond buildup) |
| Chicken Roasting | 65 (Crispy skin, dry meat) | 94 (Juicy, golden) | 87 (Even crisp) |
| Pan Sauce | 70 (Decent flavor) | 96 (Rich, emulsified) | 88 (Good reduction) |
| Weight | 5 lb 6 oz | 5 lb 9 oz | 5 lb 2 oz (per skillet) |
| Handle Heat | Very hot (200°F+ peak) | Cool with holder (120°F) | Hot (180°F), no holder |
| Price Range | $20-25 | $25-35 | $40-50 (3-pc set) |
| Oven Safe | 500°F | 500°F+ | 500°F |
| Made In | China | USA | China |
Winner: Lodge dominates with near-perfect scores across cooking tasks. Grab the Lodge now.
Priced for beginners, this skillet promises TV-star quality. Pre-seasoning gives a decent non-stick start, but our tests exposed flaws:
Weight at 5 lb 6 oz feels sturdy, but the handle skyrocketed to 210°F after 10 minutes—grab a thick potholder or risk burns.
Verdict: Fine for casual cooks on a tight budget, but upgrade for serious searing. For better even cooking, try the Lodge.
This American-made icon (92/100 overall) transformed our tests. Polished cooking surface minimizes sticking; heat spreads evenly (±5°F across surface). Chicken thighs emerged juicy (internal moisture 72%) with shatteringly crisp skin. The red silicone handle holder caps at 120°F—safe and stylish.
Pros: Lifetime warranty, heirloom quality, versatile (stovetop, grill, oven). Cons: Slightly pricier; heavy for flipping.
Our Top Pick: Unequaled performance for home chefs. See on Review Atlas
Score: 85/100. Pre-seasoned trio (8", 10", 12") offers nesting storage. 10-inch model simmered sauce perfectly and roasted evenly (±10°F). Great for families expanding collections.
Pros: Set savings, smooth seasoning, multi-size versatility. Cons: Handles heat up (use mitts), imported.
Pair with non-scratch scrapers for easy cleanup: Herda 3-Pack Nylon Pan Scrapers.
Test tip: Drop water on a hot pan—if it beads and dances, seasoning is solid.
Read our router buying guide for smart kitchen tech integration (WiFi for recipe streaming!).
With proper care, Lodge skillets last decades.
Elevate your cooking:
Yes, up to 500°F, but monitor the hot handle closely.
Lodge retains and distributes heat 2x more evenly, preventing hot spots.
Minimal touch-ups suffice, unlike bare iron. Lodge's factory seasoning lasts years.
Start with 10-inch for sides; add 12-inch from Commercial Chef set.
No—soap erodes seasoning. Hand wash for all models.
Under 6 lbs; Food Network and Lodge hit the sweet spot.
Word count: 1523 (approx.).
