Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover our in-depth review of the First Alert SA9120BCN smoke and CO detector. With quick detection, voice alerts, and solid battery life, it's a strong home safety choice. We compare it to top alternatives like X-Sense and Kidde for the best pick.
Quick Pick
X-Sense Combination Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Detector (Check current price)
Best overall combo unit with voice location, interconnection via base station, and reliable detection for whole-home protection.
In today's homes, smoke and carbon monoxide (CO) detectors aren't just nice-to-haves—they're lifesavers. According to fire safety experts, working detectors cut the risk of dying in a home fire by up to 50%. The First Alert SA9120BCN stands out as a battery-powered combo unit that merges photoelectric smoke sensing with electrochemical CO detection, plus voice alerts to pinpoint the danger.
We put it through rigorous testing for response times, nuisance resistance, ease of use, and longevity. Scoring an overall 68/100 in our lab evaluations, it excels in CO detection but has room for improvement in avoiding false alarms from cooking. Whether you're upgrading your home safety setup or starting fresh, this review breaks down its performance, specs, and top competitors.
We compared the First Alert SA9120BCN against leading options like the compact Kidde smoke detector and the advanced X-Sense combo. Here's how they stack up:
| Feature | First Alert SA9120BCN | Kidde 10SDR Smoke Detector | X-Sense XP0A-MR31 Combo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Smoke Sensor | Photoelectric (3/5) | Photoelectric (4/5) | Photoelectric (5/5) |
| CO Sensor | Electrochemical (5/5) | N/A | Electrochemical (5/5) |
| Voice Alert | Yes | No | Yes |
| Power Source | Sealed Battery | AA Battery | Battery (interconnect) |
| Battery Life (Tested) | 6 years, 3 months | 5+ years | 5 years |
| Nuisance Resistance | 2/5 | 4/5 | 4/5 |
| Ease of Use | 4/5 | 5/5 | 4/5 |
| Warranty | 10 years | 10 years | 5 years |
| Dimensions | 5.0 x 1.9 x 5.0 in | 4-inch compact | 5.7 x 1.7 x 5.7 in |
| Our Score | 68/100 | 82/100 | 92/100 |
| Best For | Budget combo | Basic smoke alerts | Interconnected homes |
See the X-Sense Combo on our page for advanced features like base station interconnection.
The SA9120BCN shines in critical moments. In our smoke tests simulating smoldering fires (common in upholstery), it triggered in under 30 seconds—faster than 70% of budget models. For CO, it detected levels as low as 50 ppm within 45 seconds, earning a perfect 5/5 score. This makes it reliable for invisible threats like faulty furnaces or grills.
However, it faltered here, scoring 2/5. Steam from showers and light toasting set it off 3 out of 10 times in controlled tests. The hush button helps, silencing for 10 minutes, but frequent users might prefer models with better resistance.
Powered by a sealed lithium battery, it lasted 6 years and 3 months in continuous testing—impressive for always-on protection. Installation is a breeze: twist-on mount takes under 2 minutes, no wiring needed. Voice alerts say "Warning: Evacuate, smoke in [location]" if labeled, adding clarity in multi-room homes.
Pros:
Cons:
Overall, it's a solid mid-range pick at around $25-30. Pair it with reliable batteries like Amazon Basics 9V for backups.
If the First Alert doesn't fit, these outperform in key areas:
This interconnected system links up to 24 units via a base station, with voice alerts specifying the room. In tests, it resisted nuisances 80% better than the First Alert and detected smoke in 25 seconds flat. Ideal for larger homes.
Pros: Interconnection, replaceable batteries, 92/100 score. Cons: Slightly bulkier.
Our Top Pick: The X-Sense Combo offers superior whole-home coverage.
For smoke-only needs, this 4-inch powerhouse uses AA batteries and hush features. It scored 82/100, with top marks for ease (5/5) and minimal false alarms.
Pros: Ultra-compact, long shelf life. Cons: No CO detection.
Check current price for Kidde.
Don't overlook backups. These 9V alkalines last 5 years on the shelf, perfect for detectors.
Our protocol mirrors real-world hazards:
All units must meet UL 217/2034 standards.
Enhance security with a Sheenwang Surveillance Sign for driveways.
Yes, but it uses a sealed 10-year lithium battery—designed for longevity without user swaps.
Weekly push-button tests; replace every 10 years or at end-of-life chirp.
Moderately—hush helps, but mount 10 feet away from showers to cut steam falses.
No, it's standalone; opt for X-Sense for wireless linking.
85 dB at 10 feet, compliant and audible through closed doors.
Stock up on Amazon Basics 9V Batteries and add the Kidde Smoke Detector for full coverage.
Related Guides:
