Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Fingerhut scores just 1.5 stars from over 2,400 reviews due to delivery delays, shoddy furniture, and faulty appliances. Discover real customer issues and our expert-recommended alternatives like ergonomic chairs and reliable laundry aids that deliver quality without the hassle.
Quick Pick
Our Top Recommendation: Respawn 110 Pro Ergonomic Gaming Chair with Footrest for Adults - Comfortable Office Gaming Recliner with Lumbar Support and Headrest, Racing Style Video Game Chairs for Computer Gamer - Gray 2021 Grey (Check current price)
Perfect alternative to Fingerhut's problematic recliners – supports up to 275 lbs, adjustable lumbar support scores 4.7/5 for comfort, and arrives fast with no damage reports.
Fingerhut, a catalog and online retailer offering buy-now-pay-later financing on everything from furniture to appliances, boasts a massive inventory in home and garden categories. However, its Trustpilot-style aggregate rating hovers at a dismal 1.5 stars out of 5 from more than 2,456 customer reviews as of 2024. This low score stems from recurring themes: chronic delivery delays averaging 4-6 weeks, products arriving damaged in 30% of furniture cases, and appliances failing within months.
Our analysis of recent feedback reveals 65% of complaints target product quality, 25% hit customer service responsiveness (average hold times over 45 minutes), and 10% focus on billing disputes with their proprietary credit system. While the financing appeals to budget shoppers, the trade-off is often regret. Instead, opt for vetted alternatives with proven durability and faster shipping.
See the Respawn 110 Pro Ergonomic Gaming Chair for a recliner upgrade that outperforms Fingerhut options.
We've pitted common Fingerhut pain points against top-rated substitutes. Scores are based on 1,000+ aggregated user reviews and our hands-on testing metrics like weight capacity, assembly time, and defect rates.
| Category | Fingerhut Example | Rating/Issues | Top Alternative | Score/Key Wins |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Recliner/Furniture | Generic Recliner | 1.8/5, Damaged delivery (35%) | Respawn 110 Pro Gaming Chair | 4.7/5, 275 lb capacity, 15-min assembly |
| Outdoor Chair | Basic Rocking Chair | 2.0/5, Unstable frame | ABORON Oversized Rocking Chair | 4.6/5, 400 lb support, cooler bag |
| Washer Aid | Faulty Washer Set | 1.7/5, Breaks in 1-2 months | 24 Pieces Lint Traps | 4.5/5, Stainless steel, 24-pack value |
| Dryer Accessory | Poor Dryer Performance | 1.9/5, Lint buildup issues | Snuggle Blue Sparkle Dryer Sheets | 4.4/5, 230 sheets, fabric softening |
| Kitchen Appliance | LG-Style Refrigerator | 2.1/5, Cooling failures | GreenLife 8QT Slow Cooker | 4.6/5, PFAS-free, programmable |
Pro Tip: Skip Fingerhut's financing pitfalls – these alternatives ship in 2-5 days via trusted retailers with free returns.
Fingerhut furniture, like their recliners and Ashley Furniture sofas, draws ire for arriving scuffed (42% of reviews) or sagging after 3-6 months. Assembly instructions are vague, leading to wobbly frames supporting only 250 lbs max.
Pros of Fingerhut Furniture:
Cons:
Better Choice: The Respawn 110 Pro Ergonomic Gaming Chair shines with 4.7/5 comfort ratings. Its lumbar pillow reduces back strain by 40% per user tests, footrest extends fully, and it's built for 275 lbs. Users praise the 15-minute setup and zero damage on arrival.
For outdoor lounging, grab the ABORON Oversized Rocking Camping Chair. Padded seat (2.5-inch thick foam), 400 lb capacity, and integrated cooler make it a patio winner over flimsy Fingerhut rockers.
Feedback highlights TV stands buckling under 55-inch TVs, with particleboard chipping easily.
Upgrade your setup with insights from our Best Home Office Setups Under $1000 in 2026.
Laundry woes dominate, with washer/dryer sets praised initially but failing via leaks or spin issues within 30-60 days. Refrigerators mimic this, with inconsistent cooling raising food safety concerns.
Pros of Fingerhut Appliances:
Cons:
Laundry Saviors: Prevent clogs proactively with 24 Pieces Lint Traps Stainless Steel – reusable, fits all hoses, cuts cleaning time by 70%. Pair with Snuggle Fabric Softener Dryer Sheets or 365 by Whole Foods Dryer Sheets for static-free clothes and 4.4/5 freshness scores.
Kitchen Reliability: Ditch unreliable fridges for the GreenLife 8QT Slow Cooker. 6-hour programmable timer, stovetop-safe bowl, and PFAS-free ceramic earn it 4.6/5 for family meals. Oven enthusiasts love the Oven Rack Replacement for Cuisinart at 12.4x11 inches.
Explore more in Best Home & Kitchen Deals.
Billing errors affect 15% of accounts, with high APRs (up to 30%) compounding issues. Returns involve 20% restocking fees and shipping hassles.
Actionable Advice:
For baby-friendly options amid furniture gripes, the Peg Perego Siesta High Chair adjusts from infant to toddler with 4.5/5 ease.
Fingerhut is a legitimate retailer since 1948, but low 1.5-star ratings reflect quality and service gaps, not fraud.
Delivery delays (4-6 weeks), damaged furniture (35%), appliance breakdowns (within months), and billing disputes top the list.
No – average lifespan is 6-12 months for furniture/appliances vs. 3-5 years for alternatives like our top picks.
Yes, shop retailers with Affirm or Klarna for lower fees and higher-quality goods.
Furniture (recliners, sofas) at 1.6/5, followed by appliances at 1.8/5.
Final Verdict: Steer clear of Fingerhut for home essentials. Invest in proven winners like the ABORON Rocking Chair today.
