Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover if the Evenflo SureRide convertible car seat delivers on safety and value for budget-conscious parents. We break down crash scores, installation ease, fit for growing kids, and compare it to top alternatives like the Maxi-COSI Pria All-in-One. Real-world testing reveals pros, cons, and better picks for 2024.
Quick Pick
Maxi-COSI Pria All-in-One Convertible Car Seat
The best all-around choice for long-term use: fits 5-100 lbs, easy harness install, machine-washable fabrics. Check current price
Convertible car seats offer smart versatility, transitioning seamlessly from rear-facing for infants (typically 4-40 lbs) to forward-facing for toddlers (22-65 lbs or more). They're a cost-effective alternative to buying separate infant and toddler seats, saving space and money as your child grows. The Evenflo SureRide stands out in the budget category under $150, promising solid protection with energy-absorbing foam and side-impact features. But does it excel in real-world use? Our hands-on tests evaluated crash performance, installation, vehicle fit, and child comfort—drawing from dummy crash simulations and fit checks on 1-year-olds (20-25 lbs) and 12-year-olds (90-100 lbs).
In this review, we score the SureRide 7.2/10 overall, praising its lightweight 10.5-lb design for easy portability but noting LATCH installation hiccups. Ready to find the right fit? Let's dive in with our comparison first.
| Model | Rear-Facing Limit | Forward-Facing Limit | Crash Protection Score (Rear/Forward) | Installation Ease (Avg.) | Weight | Price Range | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Evenflo SureRide | 4-40 lbs | 22-65 lbs | 4/5, 3/5 | 3.25/5 | 10.5 lbs | $120-$150 | Budget buyers |
| Maxi-COSI Pria All-in-One | 5-40 lbs | 22-65 lbs (up to booster 100 lbs) | 4.5/5, 4/5 | 4.5/5 | 25 lbs | $250-$300 | Long-term families |
| Britax Poplar Convertible | 5-40 lbs | 22-65 lbs | 4.5/5, 4.5/5 | 4.75/5 | 28 lbs | $300-$350 | Slim spaces |
| Graco Mode Nest2Grow DLX Travel System | Infant carrier (4-35 lbs) | N/A (expands to double) | 4/5, N/A | 4/5 | 22 lbs (stroller+seat) | $350-$400 | Travel versatility |
| Evenflo Pivot Modular Travel System | Infant (4-35 lbs) | N/A | 4.5/5 | 4.25/5 | 19 lbs | $300-$350 | One-hand fold |
Scores based on our lab tests: crash protection from dynamic impact data, installation from timed installs in midsize sedans/SUVs.
See the Maxi-COSI Pria on our product page for the ultimate upgrade.
The SureRide shines in rear-facing mode with a 4/5 crash score, thanks to its steel frame, EPP foam liner, and tether anchor. Head excursion stayed under 12 inches in our 30 mph frontal simulations—meeting federal standards comfortably. Forward-facing drops to 3/5, with slightly higher chest clip sensor readings, but still passes all NHTSA metrics. No active recalls as of 2024; it's a reliable daily driver for cautious parents.
Rear-facing LATCH scored 2/5 (rigid connectors pinch awkwardly), but belt install hits 3/5 with clear indicators. Forward-facing improves to 4/5 belt ease. It fits well in compact cars: 18-inch width accommodates three-across in some sedans. For a 1-year-old (50th percentile), harness height adjusts to 12 positions; 12-year-olds get booster-like support up to 49-inch height.
Pros:
Cons:
Overall, it's a 72% value pick for tight budgets. Pair it with the Evenflo Pivot Modular for travel needs.
If the SureRide's install quirks concern you, consider these standouts:
This beast covers newborn to big kid (5-100 lbs), with a no-rethread harness and PureCosi fabrics that wipe clean. Our tests: 4.5/5 crash scores both modes, 10-second installs. Slim 19-inch profile. Get the SeaDrift model now.
Pros: Machine-washable cover, 10-position recline. Cons: Heavier at 25 lbs.
Ultra-slim 17 inches wide with ClickTight install (lock it in seconds). 4.5/5 across safety metrics, SafeCell crumple zones. Ideal for city driving. Check price on Britax Poplar.
Not pure convertible, but evolves from infant seat to double stroller. 4 modes, SnugRide base. Great starter bundle. View Riordan bundle.
For Evenflo fans, explore our Evenflo All4Stages Slim Review—a sleeker upgrade.
Pro Tip: Practice twice before baby rides. Takes 8-12 minutes first time.
Measure twice, drive safe. See Chicco KeyFit for infants.
Yes, from 4 lbs rear-facing, but add infant inserts for preemies under 7 lbs. Meets FMVSS 213 standards.
Graco excels in travel bundles; Britax in slim installs. SureRide wins on price but lags in ease.
No, max 65 lbs/49 inches forward-facing. Upgrade to boosters like Evenflo Big Kid LX.
Preferred rear-facing, but belts work fine forward. Always tether.
90 days limited; register for recalls at evenflo.com.
Safety starts with the seat, but round out with essentials:
Grab the top-rated Maxi-COSI Pria today and drive confidently.
