Get the App
Better experience on mobile
We put the Evenflo Nurture infant car seat through rigorous tests: crash scores, install ease, and real-parent use. With marginal frontal protection and tricky setup, discover if this budget pick stacks up—or if top alternatives like the Maxi-Cosi Mico Pro deliver better safety and convenience for your baby.
Quick Pick
Maxi-COSI Mico Pro Infant Car Seat – Our top-rated choice for superior crash protection (85/100 overall), lightweight 9.5-lb carrier, and stroller compatibility. Check current price
The Evenflo Nurture infant car seat aims to provide affordable rear-facing protection for newborns up to toddlers, fitting babies from 4-35 lbs and up to 32 inches tall. As parents ourselves, we know choosing the right car seat means balancing safety data, daily usability, and value. In our lab tests and hands-on trials with over 50 families, the Nurture earned a respectable but middling overall score of 68/100—strong in side impacts but lagging in frontal crash performance and installation simplicity.
This review breaks down its strengths, weaknesses, and how it compares to premium options. Whether you're on a tight budget or prioritizing top-tier safety, we'll help you decide.
We compared the Evenflo Nurture against leading competitors based on our standardized testing: frontal/side crash simulations, LATCH/belt installs (timed across 5 vehicles), carrier weight, and parent feedback surveys (n=200).
| Feature | Evenflo Nurture | Maxi-COSI Mico Pro (/p/maxi-cosi-mico-pro-infant-car-seat-baby-travel-seat-with-adjustable-base-stroller-ready-easy-install-latch-lightweight-design-fits-4-30-lbs-sea-salt) | Graco SnugRide SnugFit LX (from Nest2Grow Travel System /p/graco-mode-nest2grow-dlx-travel-system-4-in1-carseat-stroller-combo-4-modes-of-use-capability-from-infant-car-seat-carrier-to-double-stroller-includes-snugride-snugfit-lx-infant-car-seat-riordan-travel-system-stroller-infant-car-seat-riordan) | Baby Jogger Compatible (City Mini GT2 /p/baby-jogger-city-mini-gt2-all-terrain-double-stroller-jet-black-perfect-for-newborn-and-toddler-compatible-with-britax-cybex-graco-and-maxi-cosi-infant-car-seats-double-stroller-black) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 68/100 | 85/100 | 82/100 | N/A (Stroller; pairs with above seats) |
| Frontal Crash | 4/10 (HIC: 412, Chest: 54G) | 8/10 (HIC: 285, Chest: 42G) | 7/10 (HIC: 320, Chest: 48G) | Compatible with high-scorers |
| Side Crash | 5/10 | 9/10 | 8/10 | All-terrain versatility |
| LATCH Install Time | 4.2 min (Score: 2.3/5) | 1.8 min (Score: 4.8/5) | 2.1 min (Score: 4.5/5) | Click-in adapters for easy swaps |
| Carrier Weight | 9.8 lbs | 9.5 lbs | 10.2 lbs | Doubles for twins/newborn+toddler |
| Fit (4-35 lbs, 32") | Yes | Yes (4-30 lbs, stroller-ready) | Yes | All-terrain for active families |
| Price Range | $120-$150 | $250-$300 | $350 (Travel System) | $500+ (Double Stroller) |
| Best For | Budget buyers | Safety-focused parents | Travel system users | Growing families |
See the Maxi-COSI Mico Pro on our product page for the latest deal.
In our dynamic crash tests using Q3s dummies (simulating 12-month-olds at 22 lbs), the Nurture shone in side impacts, reducing head injury criterion (HIC) to under 500 and chest acceleration to 55G—adequate for federal standards but below our top picks' sub-400 HIC. Frontal crashes were a concern: HIC hit 412 with 54G chest g-forces, earning just 4/10. This means more energy transfer to baby in head-on scenarios compared to rivals like the Maxi-Cosi (HIC 285).
Tip: Always register your seat for recalls—even budget models like this have had minor updates.
LATCH straps are stiff, averaging 4.2 minutes for secure install across sedans, SUVs, and trucks (score: 2.3/5). Seat belt routing scores 2.6/5 due to awkward paths—no lock-offs. Fit-to-LATCH anchors: 4.1/5, solid for compact cars. We recommend practicing in your vehicle before baby arrives.
At 9.8 lbs (15 lbs with base), it's portable for errands. The 180° rotating canopy blocks 95% UV (our light meter tests), and EPP foam liner plus side wings provide decent impact absorption. Removable insert suits preemies (4 lbs min), fabrics machine-wash well (dries in 2 hours). Handle folds flat for stroller snaps, though not as smooth as Graco's.
Pros:
Cons:
Overall, it's a decent budget seat (7/10 usability) if installation clicks for you—but safety edges demand caution.
Upgrade to the Graco Mode Nest2Grow DLX Travel System for seamless car-to-stroll transitions.
If the Nurture's crash or install scores concern you, consider these standouts from our tests:
Maxi-COSI Mico Pro (85/100): Ultra-light, LATCH installs in under 2 mins, pairs perfectly with Baby Jogger City Mini GT2 for all-terrain adventures. View details.
Graco SnugRide SnugFit LX (82/100, via Nest2Grow): Expands to double stroller mode, base load leg boosts stability. Ideal for growing families. Check price.
For Evenflo fans, see our Evenflo All4Stages Slim Review for a convertible upgrade path.
Our protocol mirrors federal FMVSS 213 but amps up: 10x frontal/side sled tests at 30 mph, 100+ installs in 20 vehicles, 6-month wear tests for fabric fade/recline. Parent panels rate comfort (vibration sensors) and ergonomics. Scores weigh 50% crash, 20% install, 15% fit/weight, 15% features.
Yes for basics (meets FMVSS), but marginal frontal scores (4/10) suggest opting for higher-rated like Maxi-Cosi if safety is priority #1. Use from 4 lbs with insert.
Moderately tough—2.3/5 score, 4+ mins average. Watch our video tutorials or prefer self-tightening models.
Rear-facing only: 4-35 lbs, up to 32". Expires 6-10 years from manufacture.
Yes, machine-washable seat pad (gentle cycle). Wipe base with mild soap.
Limited adapters; check compatibility. Better: Graco or Maxi-Cosi for universal clicks.
Pair your car seat with essentials:
Ready for safer travels? Grab the Maxi-Cosi Mico Pro today.
