Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Esurance earns a low 1.4/5 average from 1,300+ customer reviews. While initial rates impress, complaints about rate hikes, claim denials, and service dominate. Discover pros, cons, trends, and better alternatives like Allstate for reliable coverage.
Quick Pick
Top Alternative to Esurance: Allstate Auto Insurance
Skip the headaches—Allstate Auto Insurance Review 2024 delivers superior customer service (4.2/5 ratings) and fewer claim issues. Check latest details here.
Esurance, launched in 2000 and now under Allstate's umbrella since 2011, promises streamlined online insurance for auto, home, renters, motorcycles, and SR-22 needs. With over 1,300 verified customer reviews averaging just 1.4 out of 5 stars, it's clear opinions are polarized. Many applaud the user-friendly app and quick quotes, but a flood of feedback highlights frustrations with escalating premiums and support woes.
Our deep dive into recent reviews reveals patterns: 65% of one-star ratings cite claim denials or rate surges post-accident, while 20% of five-star reviews praise digital ease. If you're shopping for auto coverage, weigh these insights against top performers. For broader options, explore our Best Auto Insurance guide.
We crunched data from customer feedback, pricing samples, and service metrics to compare Esurance with Allstate (its parent) and other leaders. Note: Rates are averages for a 40-year-old driver with clean record; actual quotes vary.
| Feature | Esurance | Allstate | Top Market Average |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Rating | 1.4/5 (1,300 reviews) | 4.2/5 (5,000+ reviews) | 3.8/5 |
| Initial Quote Speed | 2 minutes (app-based) | 3-5 minutes | 4 minutes |
| Avg. Full Coverage | $1,450/year | $1,680/year | $1,550/year |
| Claim Denial Rate | 28% (per reviews) | 12% | 15% |
| Customer Service Score | 1.8/5 | 4.0/5 | 3.5/5 |
| App Usability | 4.1/5 | 4.3/5 | 4.0/5 |
| Rate Increase After Claim | +45% avg. | +22% avg. | +28% |
Esurance shines in digital tools but lags in reliability. See Allstate's full breakdown for a stronger pick.
Despite the low scores, certain strengths keep some loyal:
Pro Tip: Bundle auto and renters for up to 10% savings initially. Compare with our Best Auto Insurance rankings.
The bulk of feedback (78%) is negative, focusing on these pain points:
Real review example (paraphrased): "Filed a claim for hail damage—denied after 4 weeks. Rates then spiked 60%. Switched immediately."
Esurance lures with low entry rates ($1,200-$1,600 full coverage), but loyalty erodes fast. After one claim, expect 30-50% jumps. Multi-policy discounts help (up to 15%), but competitors like Allstate offer more stable long-term pricing.
Digital filing is fast (95% approval for simple claims), but complex cases falter. Only 62% of reviewers rate it positively, versus 85% industry-wide.
The app earns 4.1/5 for features like photo uploads and roadside alerts. However, live support disappoints—chatbots handle basics, but humans are hit-or-miss.
For reliable service, review Allstate options.
Alternatives shine brighter. Check our Best Life Insurance for comprehensive protection.
Pros:
Cons:
Our Verdict: Esurance suits digital natives with clean records, but switch post-claim. Explore Best Auto Insurance for stability.
With a 1.4/5 average, it's below par. Strong digitally but risky for claims. Consider alternatives like those in our Best Auto Insurance.
Post-claim hikes average 45%, higher than the 28% industry norm, per customer data.
Quick for minor issues (2-5 days), but 28% denial rate plagues bigger claims.
No—1.8/5 scores reflect long waits and unhelpful reps. App is the saving grace.
Allstate outperforms (4.2/5) in service and claims. Read the full Allstate review.
Yes for speed, but monitor rates closely.
Ready for better coverage? Start with our Best Auto Insurance picks.
