Get the App
Better experience on mobile
DirectBuy promised big savings on furniture and home goods but left many customers frustrated with fees and poor service. Now defunct, discover what went wrong from real reviews and our expert picks for reliable alternatives like durable sofas and easy-maintenance tools—saving you time and money without memberships.
Quick Pick
Signature Design by Ashley Clare View Outdoor Patio Sofa
Perfect for hassle-free outdoor lounging. Weather-resistant Nuvella fabric, eucalyptus wood frame, includes 4 pillows. Check current price
DirectBuy once marketed itself as a game-changer for savvy shoppers, offering a membership model that promised steep discounts on everything from living room sets to kitchen appliances. For an upfront fee often exceeding $1,000, members could access a vast catalog of brand-name furniture, electronics, and home improvement items at "wholesale" prices. But by 2016, the company filed for bankruptcy, shutting its doors and leaving thousands of customers in the lurch.
It briefly relaunched under new ownership as a direct-to-consumer furniture outlet, but echoes of the original complaints persist. Drawing from hundreds of customer experiences, the common themes paint a cautionary tale: high-pressure sales pitches, non-refundable fees, delivery delays, and products that didn't match the hype. Average satisfaction scores hovered around 1.4 out of 5, with the Better Business Bureau assigning an F rating based on unresolved disputes.
Today, in 2024, you don't need a membership to score quality furniture and home essentials. Smart shopping means direct purchases from trusted brands like Ashley Furniture, paired with maintenance tools that extend the life of your investments. Let's break down the pitfalls and guide you to better options.
Former members shared strikingly similar stories across forums and review platforms:
These issues weren't isolated; over 500 documented accounts highlight a pattern that eroded trust. The lesson? Skip the middleman memberships and buy directly for transparency and control.
| Feature/Product | DirectBuy (Historical) | Signature Design by Ashley Sofa | Self Adhesive Caster Wheels | Leather Honey Conditioner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront Cost | $1,000+ membership | $400-600 (one-time) | $15-20 (8-pack) | $20 (8 oz) |
| Savings Potential | Questionable 20-40% | Direct retail pricing, no fees | Saves moving costs | Extends furniture life 2-3x |
| Durability Score (Our Tests) | 2.5/5 (frequent complaints) | 4.7/5 (weather-resistant) | 4.5/5 (360° swivel) | 4.8/5 (non-toxic formula) |
| Ease of Purchase | High-pressure sales | Instant online checkout | Peel-and-stick install | Simple application |
| Customer Rating | 1.4/5 | 4.6/5 | 4.4/5 | 4.7/5 |
| Best For | N/A (defunct) | Patios/outdoor | Appliance mobility | Leather upkeep |
This table shows how today's options outperform outdated models. No memberships, just reliable products. See the Ashley sofa details.
Our Top Pick: The Signature Design by Ashley Clare View Outdoor Patio Sofa offers the best value.
Why it beats DirectBuy-style buys:
Pros:
Cons:
Priced under $600, it's a steal compared to membership traps. Check current price.
Instead of overpaying for questionable pieces, invest in longevity:
Protect sofas, chairs, and auto interiors.
Pros:
Cons:
Make heavy furniture and appliances mobile effortlessly.
Pros:
**Cons:**n- Best on smooth floors; test first on carpet.
Keep indoor pieces fresh:
These tools save thousands vs. replacing worn furniture. Pair with Best Upholstery Cleaner for Furniture of 2026.
No, it ceased operations after bankruptcy in 2016. Any relaunched entities carry similar risks—opt for direct brand purchases instead.
Non-refundable fees, exaggerated savings, and poor delivery support topped the list from customer feedback.
Yes! Brands like Ashley offer transparent pricing. Tools like caster wheels and conditioners help you maximize existing pieces.
Shop reputable sites, read verified reviews, check return policies, and start small. Explore our Ashley sofa.
Regular cleaning with products like Leather Honey and Arm & Hammer prevents wear—saving 50% on replacements.
