Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover our in-depth Brooklyn 9.5-inch sauté pan review with lab-tested scores on simmering, nonstick release, durability, and more. We compare it to top alternatives like the SENSARTE nonstick skillet for everyday cooking wins. Find pros, cons, and buying advice to upgrade your kitchen.
Quick Pick
Our Top Pick: The SENSARTE Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet with Lid, 12 Inch Large Deep Frying Pan delivers superior nonstick performance and versatility. Check current price and see why it's ideal for family meals.
A reliable sauté pan is a kitchen essential for everything from quick stir-fries to simmering sauces. Unlike shallow skillets, sauté pans feature high sides and often a lid, making them perfect for containing splatters and liquids. In our hands-on tests at Review Atlas, we evaluate key metrics like heat distribution, nonstick longevity, and handle comfort to help you choose wisely.
Today, we're diving deep into the Brooklyn 9.5-inch sauté pan—a hard-anodized aluminum nonstick option priced around $100. We put it through rigorous lab tests measuring simmering evenness, food release, durability, scorch resistance, sauce handling, and handle performance. Overall score: 72/100. It's a solid everyday performer but has room for improvement in food release. We'll break it down, compare it to top competitors, and recommend better options like the SENSARTE 12-inch nonstick sauté pan.
See on our product page for the SENSARTE – our favorite for nonstick excellence.
Simmering tests involve heating water to a gentle boil and monitoring temperature consistency across the pan base. The Brooklyn excelled here, maintaining even heat with minimal hotspots—only a 3°C variance over 30 minutes. This makes it fantastic for delicate tasks like reducing sauces or braising vegetables without scorching.
We fried eggs, pancakes, and cheese without oil to assess release. Eggs stuck slightly after 5 minutes, requiring gentle scraping. It's decent for buttered foods but lags behind premium nonsticks.
After 500 cycles of metal utensil scraping and dishwasher runs, the coating retained 85% integrity. No major flaking, though minor wear appeared on edges.
Heating empty on medium for 10 minutes showed light discoloration but no warping or coating damage. Safe for busy cooks who occasionally forget the pan.
Thick béchamel and tomato sauces released with some residue, needing extra soaking. Better for thin liquids than sticky reductions.
Oven-safe up to 500°F, it's versatile for finishing dishes under the broiler.
Pros of Brooklyn 9.5-Inch Sauté Pan:
Cons:
If simmering sauces is your priority, it's worth considering. For broader nonstick prowess, upgrade to our top pick below.
Upgrade Tip: Grab the SENSARTE Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet with Lid for effortless release. Check current price.
We pitted the Brooklyn against leading alternatives in our lab. Scores out of 100 unless noted.
| Feature | Brooklyn 9.5" (Reviewed) | SENSARTE 12" Nonstick Saute Pan | All-Clad D3 3-Ply 7-Pc Set |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 72 | 88 | 92 |
| Simmering | 84 (Excellent) | 91 | 95 |
| Food Release | 69 (Fair) | 94 | 65 (Stainless)* |
| Durability | 74 (Very Good) | 87 | 98 |
| Scorch Resistance | 74 (Very Good) | 89 | 96 |
| Sauce Releasing | 69 (Fair) | 92 | 80 |
| Oven Safe | 500°F | 450°F | 600°F |
| Induction Compatible | No | Yes | Yes |
| Price (Approx.) | $100 | $50-$60 | $500+ (Set) |
| Weight | 2.1 lbs | 3.2 lbs | 4.5 lbs (Saute Pan) |
*All-Clad excels in searing but requires oil for release.
The SENSARTE shines with PFOA-free coating and a helper handle for larger meals. The All-Clad D3 set is pro-level but pricier—ideal for stainless fans. View SENSARTE details.
This pan suits budget-conscious home cooks focused on simmering tasks. It's great for apartments or occasional use, weighing just 2.1 lbs for easy storage. However, if you cook daily or need flawless nonstick, opt for the SENSARTE 12-inch deep sauté pan—its 5QT capacity handles family portions effortlessly.
Maintenance Tips for Longevity:
Sample Recipes: Sautéed garlic shrimp (simmering shines) or one-pan chicken cacciatore.
For premium builds, the All-Clad D3 7-piece set offers lifelong durability. Check it out.
Ready to cook? See current deals on SENSARTE.
Pair your sauté pan with essentials from our guides:
Yes, but hand washing preserves the nonstick coating longer. Our durability tests showed 15% faster wear in dishwashers.
No—its aluminum construction isn't magnetic. Choose the SENSARTE for induction compatibility.
About 2.5 quarts, suitable for 2-4 servings. For larger families, upgrade to 5QT options like SENSARTE.
Brooklyn offers easier cleanup but less browning than stainless like All-Clad. Use stainless for fond-building.
Fair for its simmering prowess, but our top pick SENSARTE delivers more at half the cost. Check prices now.
Typically 1-year limited; confirm with retailer. Premium picks like All-Clad offer lifetime coverage.
