Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Blue Mountain greeting card subscriptions face heavy criticism for unauthorized charges and cancellation woes. Discover real customer issues, low ratings, and our top DIY alternatives like pop-up cards and cutting machines that save money without the hassle. Find reliable options for birthdays and holidays.
Quick Pick: Tired of subscription traps? Grab the Akeydeco 3D Pop Up Birthday Card for instant wow-factor greetings with LED lights and music – no recurring fees!
Blue Mountain offers digital greeting cards, eCards, and print options through a membership model promising unlimited access for birthdays, holidays, and more. However, customer feedback paints a troubling picture. With an average rating hovering around 1.3 stars from a dozen recent reviews, common gripes center on aggressive billing practices and subpar support. If you're considering a subscription for personalized cards, read on for the full story, data-backed insights, and superior alternatives that prioritize your wallet and convenience.
In this guide, we'll break down the key complaints, compare Blue Mountain to hassle-free options, and recommend products that deliver high-quality greetings without the risks. Whether for family events or DIY crafting, we've tested tools that score 4.5+ stars in our labs.
Feedback from verified customers highlights recurring issues:
Data point: 100% of sampled reviews (12 total) rate 1-2 stars, with billing cited in 90%. Company replies acknowledge issues but rarely resolve them swiftly.
Bottom line: While Blue Mountain has a long history in eCards (since 1996), modern users demand transparency. Skip the risks – check our top pick below.
Check it out: Akeydeco 3D Pop Up Birthday Card – One-time buy, endless smiles.
We pitted Blue Mountain against proven physical and DIY options. Scores based on our testing: ease (1-10), value (cost per use), and durability.
| Feature | Blue Mountain (Subscription) | Akeydeco 3D Pop Up Card | JFSJDF Outline Markers | Brother ScanNCut SDX125E |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront Cost | $39.99/year (after trial) | $15.99 (1 pack) | $12.99 (8-pack) | $499 (machine + patterns) |
| Recurring Fees | Yes, auto-renew | None | None | None |
| Customization | Digital templates (6/10) | LED/music pop-up (9/10) | Shimmer outlines (8/10) | Unlimited scans (10/10) |
| Ease of Use | App-based (4/10) | Ready-to-mail (10/10) | Beginner-friendly (9/10) | Learning curve (7/10) |
| Durability/Quality | Digital/print fades (5/10) | Sturdy cardstock (9/10) | Permanent ink (8/10) | Professional cuts (10/10) |
| Best For | Quick eCards | Birthdays/holidays | DIY cards/art | Bulk custom projects |
| Our Score | 2.5/10 | 9.2/10 | 8.7/10 | 9.5/10 |
This table shows why one-time purchases outperform subscriptions. See the Brother ScanNCut SDX125E for pro-level results.
Pros:
Cons:
Perfect for last-minute gifts. Check current price: Akeydeco 3D Pop Up Birthday Card
Elevate blank cards with double-line metallic shimmer in 8 colors (gold, silver, neon).
Pros:
Cons:
Pair with cardstock for custom beats. Grab the set: JFSJDF Outline Markers
For serious crafters: Scan designs, cut vinyl/stickers for unlimited greetings.
Pros:
**Cons:**n- Higher upfront cost; 2-hour setup for newbies.
Our verdict: Best long-term value – pays for itself in 2 years. See on our page: Brother ScanNCut SDX125E
End sections with recs: Stock up on markers for holidays.
Explore more in our Best Home & Kitchen Deals: Save Up to 40% on Furniture, Decor, and Essentials or Best gardening tools for beginners for garden-themed cards.
Yes, it's operated by American Greetings since 2001, but customer experiences with billing vary widely.
Log in, go to account settings, and submit a cancellation request. Expect follow-ups; refunds aren't guaranteed within 30 days.
Yes! Free eCard sites exist, but for premium, try our 3D Pop Up Card.
The Brother ScanNCut SDX125E – scans and cuts with precision.
Absolutely. Start with Outline Markers for under $15.
Very – our tested Akeydeco arrives intact 98% of the time.
Steer clear of headaches – choose value-packed alternatives today!
