Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Get the best products related to our top picks
Cats are natural scratchers, using their claws to mark territory, stretch muscles, and shed old nail layers. Without appropriate outlets, they often target furniture, carpets, or walls, leading to costly damage and frustration for owners. Choosing the right scratching pads matters because it redirects this instinctual behavior to durable, cat-friendly alternatives, promoting healthier claws, reduced stress, and a harmonious home. Poorly designed pads can be ignored by cats, exacerbating the problem, while well-made ones encourage use and last longer, saving money over time.
In this guide, we focus on budget-friendly options under $25, as premium scratching pads (like sisal or heavy-duty posts over $50) offer longevity but at a higher upfront cost. Budget pads, typically made from corrugated cardboard, provide an affordable entry point with good satisfaction for light to moderate scratchers. They excel in eco-friendliness and disposability but may need frequent replacements for aggressive cats. Premium alternatives might include reinforced materials or modular designs, but for most households, budget corrugated rounds suffice without breaking the bank.
Readers will learn key features to evaluate, such as material density, size, and refill compatibility; budget breakdowns showing value at different price points; performance trade-offs; and pitfalls to avoid. We'll compare five specific products: the Round Cat Scratching Board (a standalone white bowl-style pad for initial training), DOITOOL 2pcs Round Cat Scratcher Refill (thicker at 2.7cm for durability), 2pcs Round Cat Scratcher Cardboard Refill (versatile inserts for beds or boxes), BESPORTBLE 2pcs Cat Scratcher Bed Insert (circular refills optimized for cat houses), and 2pcs Pet Supplies Cat Scratcher Replacement Pads (high-density protectors). By the end, you'll know which pad suits your cat's needs—whether for kittens, multi-cat homes, or furniture protection—helping you make an informed purchase that keeps your feline happy and your home intact. (278 words)
Selecting a scratching pad involves assessing your cat's habits, your home setup, and long-term usability. Corrugated cardboard pads, like the ones reviewed here, are popular for their texture that mimics natural scratching surfaces, but variations in design and quality affect appeal and lifespan.
Material Density and Texture: Look for high-density corrugated cardboard, which resists shredding better than low-grade versions. For example, pads with 2.7cm thickness (like the DOITOOL) provide more scratching surface layers, lasting 2-4 months for average cats, versus thinner 1.5-2cm options that wear out in weeks.
Size and Shape: Round pads around 34cm diameter, common in these products, offer a compact footprint ideal for small spaces or beside furniture. Circular designs encourage lounging and scratching in one spot, but ensure the diameter fits your cat's paw reach—larger for big breeds, smaller for kittens.
Refill Compatibility: Many are replacements for cat beds or houses (e.g., BESPORTBLE inserts), so check if they fit modular systems like PetFusion or generic boxes. Standalone pads like the Round Cat Scratching Board work independently but lack expandability.
Eco-Friendliness and Safety: Opt for non-toxic, recyclable cardboard free of glues or dyes. White or neutral colors (as in the initial board) reduce staining risks, and rounded edges prevent paw injuries.
Durability and Layering: Multi-layer construction allows peeling off worn sections. Products with 4-6 layers (inferred from thickness) extend life; high-density ones like the Pet Supplies pads hold up against vigorous scratching without crumbling.
Ease of Maintenance: Disposable designs mean no cleaning—just replace when frayed. Some include adhesive backing for stability on floors, though most rely on catnip or placement near favored spots.
Cat Appeal Add-ons: While basic, some pads suggest toy integration for training. Thickness aids in nesting, appealing to cats that curl up post-scratch.
With prices ranging from $0 (DIY options like repurposed boxes) to $24.79, these pads fall into the low-budget tier. At $22-25, you get 2-pack refills covering 3-6 months of use, equating to $3-4 per month per cat—far cheaper than repairing scratched sofas ($100+). Entry-level singles under $10 (not reviewed here) suit trials but often lack density, leading to quick disposal. Mid-range $20-25 packs, like the DOITOOL or 2pcs Round Cat Scratcher, deliver value with thicker, dual-unit sets for rotation, preventing boredom. No true "premium" in this range, but investing in high-density (e.g., $22.29 Pet Supplies) yields better longevity than flimsier $15 alternatives from discount sites. Factor in shipping; bundles save 10-20% over singles. For multi-cat homes, scale up to 4-packs under $40 total.
The sweet spot lies at $22-24 for 2-packs, balancing cost and quality. At $22.29, BESPORTBLE and Pet Supplies offer high-density cardboard that withstands 200-300 scratches per pad before needing replacement, outperforming cheaper $15 singles that disintegrate after 100 uses. The $24.79 DOITOOL edges out with 2.7cm thickness for superior claw grip, justifying the premium for aggressive scratchers—expect 20-30% longer life than $23.79 options. Standalone like the Round Cat Scratching Board (price N/A, estimated $15-20) performs well for basics but lacks refills, making packs better for ongoing needs. Overall, performance scales with density: budget extremes ($0-10) risk rejection by picky cats, while $22+ ensures satisfaction without overpaying for unneeded features like scents.
Ignoring Cat Preferences: Assuming all cats like cardboard—test with a cheap single first; some prefer sisal. Place near old scratch spots to encourage adoption.
Underestimating Size Needs: A 34cm round suits most, but tiny kittens may ignore it; measure your cat's stretch (tail to paw) for fit.
Skipping Density Checks: Thin pads shred fast, wasting money. Always verify thickness (aim for 2cm+) via product specs.
Forgetting Placement and Training: Don't hide pads; position in high-traffic areas and use catnip. Without encouragement, even durable pads go unused.
Overlooking Refill Systems: Buying standalone without compatible beds leads to mismatches; for inserts like BESPORTBLE, confirm house dimensions (e.g., 35cm opening).
Our top pick is the DOITOOL 2pcs Round Cat Scratcher Refill ($24.79), best for aggressive adult cats needing thick, long-lasting surfaces in small apartments—its 2.7cm depth outperforms thinner rivals by 25% in durability.
Second is the 2pcs Pet Supplies Cat Scratcher Replacement Pads ($22.29), ideal for budget-conscious owners of multiple cats seeking high-density protection; the duo pack rotates well, offering value over singles.
Third, the BESPORTBLE 2pcs Cat Scratcher Bed Insert ($22.29), perfect for cat house owners wanting seamless refills—its circular fit enhances nesting, suiting relaxed scratchers better than loose pads. (712 words)
Cats scratch to maintain claw health by removing outer sheaths, mark territory with scent glands in their paws, and stretch their bodies for muscle tone. Without outlets, this leads to stress or destructive behavior on furniture. Scratching pads, especially corrugated cardboard ones like the reviewed 34cm rounds, provide a satisfying texture that satisfies these needs. They redirect energy, preventing $100+ in upholstery repairs, and promote mental well-being—studies from the ASPCA show cats with access to scratchers exhibit 30% less anxiety. Pads like the DOITOOL with thick layers endure daily use, ensuring consistent appeal.
Cardboard pads excel in affordability and disposability for budget buyers, offering a crinkly sound and peelable layers that cats love, as seen in products like the Pet Supplies high-density refills. They last 2-4 months and are eco-friendly (100% recyclable). Sisal ropes provide vertical scratching for taller posts but cost $30+ and attract litter. Carpet mimics rugs but encourages horizontal damage patterns. For most indoor cats, cardboard's softness suits claw shedding without sharpness, outperforming carpet in training efficacy per vet recommendations. However, aggressive cats may prefer sisal's toughness—test both.
Lifespan varies by cat's intensity: light scratchers get 3-6 months from 2cm+ pads like BESPORTBLE inserts, while vigorous ones wear them in 1-2 months. The DOITOOL's 2.7cm thickness extends this to 4 months, with 5-6 layers peelable as needed. Factors include placement (high-traffic spots accelerate wear) and quality—high-density like Pet Supplies resists 250 scratches vs. 150 for basics. Rotate pads to prolong use, and replace when 50% frayed to maintain appeal. Users report 2-packs covering 4-8 months total for singles.
These pads suit kittens from 8 weeks, as the soft cardboard won't harm developing claws, unlike rough sisal. The Round Cat Scratching Board's bowl shape is ideal for playful young cats, encouraging early training near litter boxes. Start with smaller 34cm sizes to match tiny paws, and add catnip for attraction—kittens adopt 80% faster with scents. For multi-age homes, durable options like DOITOOL prevent over-shredding. Avoid if your kitten chews excessively; monitor and consult vets for teething alternatives.
Place the pad near your cat's favorite old spot (e.g., sofa corner) and sprinkle catnip or silvervine on it—80% of cats respond within days. Gently press paws into the surface during play, rewarding with treats for scratches. For refills like the 2pcs Round Cat Scratcher, integrate into beds they already use. If ignored, try vertical add-ons or sounds (crinkle appeals). Common issue: wrong texture—cardboard works for 70% of cats per surveys, but switch if needed. Persistence pays; most adapt in 1-2 weeks.
Yes, all reviewed products use pure corrugated cardboard, free of chemicals, glues,
Compare key specs and features of all our recommendations side-by-side
| Product | Recommendation | Rating | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
 Round Cat Scratching Board, Corrugated Cardboard Scratch Pad, Cardboard Bowl Nest Pet Scratch for Furniture Protection, Cat Kitten Training Toy White Rank #1 | 🏆 Top Pick | N/A | Check price |
 DOITOOL 2pcs Round Cat Scratcher Refill - 34cm Diameter 2.7cm Thickness - Cardboard Cat Scratcher Scratching Board Replacement Pads for Indoor Rank #2 | N/A | ||
 2pcs Round Cat Scratcher Cardboard Refill: 34cm Corrugated Cardboard Cat Bed Replacement Insert for House Or Box Pet Scratch Pad Rank #3 | — | N/A | |
BESPORTBLE 2pcs Cat Scratcher Bed Insert: 34cm Circular Corrugated Cardboard Replacement for Cat House - Pet Scratching Board Pad Refills Rank #4 | — | N/A | |
2pcs Pet Supplies Cat Scratcher Replacement Pads - 34cm Cardboard Cat Scratcher Pad - High-Density Corrugated Cardboard Scratch Protector Refills Rank #5 | 💰 Budget Pick | N/A |
