Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Get the best products related to our top picks
Flat-top grills, also known as griddles, have surged in popularity for their versatility in outdoor cooking, allowing users to prepare everything from smash burgers and stir-fries to pancakes and fajitas on a single, even-heat surface. Unlike traditional grates that let fat drip away, flat-tops retain juices for flavorful results, making them ideal for tailgating, camping, backyard barbecues, or even as a replacement part for existing grills. Choosing the right one matters because it directly impacts cooking performance, portability, durability, and long-term value. A poorly selected griddle might heat unevenly, rust quickly, or lack the size needed for family meals, leading to frustration and wasted money. Conversely, the best options deliver consistent temperatures, easy cleanup, and robust construction that withstands frequent use.
This guide compares budget-friendly options against premium models to highlight trade-offs. Budget picks, often under $150, prioritize portability and basic functionality for casual users or small groups, like the Griddle Replacement Top for Blackstone Tailgater Combo or the Small Portable Grill 14 Inch Tabletop. These are affordable entry points but may sacrifice power and size. Premium grills, such as the 5-Burner Propane Gas Griddle Grill Combo, exceed $400 and offer larger cooking areas, higher BTUs for faster heating, and combo features like dual grates for serious grillers who want restaurant-quality results at home. Mid-range choices, around $120-$140, like the Tabletop Gas Griddle 18” and the Weber 6787 Full-Size Griddle Inserts, strike a balance with solid build quality and versatility without breaking the bank.
Readers will learn key features to evaluate, such as BTU output, material durability, and portability; budget breakdowns to match spending to needs; performance-price analysis to find sweet spots; and pitfalls to avoid. We'll review five specific products: the Blackstone Griddle Replacement Top ($89.99), Tabletop Gas Griddle 18” ($136.49), Small Portable Grill 14 Inch ($123.36), 5-Burner Propane Gas Griddle Grill Combo ($499.99), and Weber 6787 Full-Size Griddle Inserts ($125.99). By the end, you'll have the insights to select a flat-top grill that fits your lifestyle, whether you're a weekend camper or a dedicated backyard chef. (Word count: 278)
Selecting a flat-top grill involves assessing your cooking needs, space constraints, and usage frequency. Start by determining if you need a standalone unit, a replacement insert for an existing grill, or a combo model. Portability is crucial for tailgating or camping, while stationary options suit permanent outdoor kitchens. Focus on heat distribution for even cooking—look for multiple burners and thick cooking surfaces like cast iron or stainless steel. Fuel type matters too: propane is convenient for portability, but ensure compatibility with your setup. Finally, consider maintenance; non-stick coatings or removable parts simplify cleanup after greasy meals.
Cooking Surface Material and Size: The core of any flat-top is its surface. Cast iron retains heat excellently for searing but requires seasoning to prevent rust. Stainless steel is rust-resistant and easier to clean but may not hold heat as well. Porcelain-enameled options, like those on the 5-Burner Combo, combine durability with non-stick properties. Surface area ranges from 150-200 square inches on compact models (e.g., 14-inch portables) for 2-4 people to over 600 square inches on larger grills for crowds. Compare based on group size—smaller for solo or couples, bigger for families.
BTU Output and Burner Configuration: BTUs measure heat power; aim for 10,000-15,000 per burner for quick preheating (5-10 minutes). The Tabletop 18” offers 30,000 total BTUs across three burners for versatile zoning (hot and cool areas). Dual or multi-burner setups, like the 5-Burner's five burners, allow precise temperature control. Single-burner replacements, such as the Blackstone Top, suit basic needs but limit zoning.
Portability and Build Quality: For on-the-go use, check weight (under 20 lbs for easy carrying) and features like foldable legs or carrying handles, as in the Small Portable 14 Inch. Sturdy stainless steel frames resist warping, while powder-coated steel on budget models like the Blackstone Replacement may chip over time. Includes like covers protect against weather.
Heat Distribution and Temperature Range: Even heating prevents hot spots; thicker plates (1/4-inch or more) excel here. Models with wind guards, useful for outdoor use, maintain performance. Temperature gauges or adjustable knobs help hit 200°F for eggs up to 500°F+ for steaks. The Weber Inserts integrate seamlessly with existing grills for consistent heat from Genesis or Spirit series.
Ease of Cleaning and Accessories: Removable drip trays catch grease, reducing flare-ups. Pre-seasoned surfaces or scrapers (often included) speed cleanup. Combo models like the 5-Burner add grates for versatility. Check for warranties—1-5 years on premium vs. limited on budget.
Fuel Efficiency and Safety Features: Propane models should have auto-ignition and overheat shutoffs. Efficiency means less canister swapping; higher BTUs burn more fuel, so balance with usage. Ensure CSA/UL certification for safety.
Compatibility and Versatility: Inserts like the Weber 6787 fit specific grills (Spirit II 300 series), expanding functionality without full replacement. Standalone units offer broader use but check hose lengths for propane tanks.
Flat-top grills span $90-$500, divided into tiers. Entry-level ($80-$130) includes replacements and small portables like the Blackstone Griddle Top ($89.99) or Small Portable 14 Inch ($123.36). These provide basic 20,000 BTUs, compact sizes (14-17 inches), and steel construction for occasional use by beginners or campers. Expect shorter warranties and lighter builds that may dent.
Mid-range ($120-$150) like the Tabletop 18” ($136.49) and Weber Inserts ($125.99) upgrade to 30,000 BTUs, stainless elements, and better heat retention for frequent tailgaters or small families. You get included covers, legs, and easier cleanup, justifying the slight premium over budget.
High-end ($400+) is exemplified by the 5-Burner Combo ($499.99), delivering 60,000+ BTUs, 618 sq in area, dual surfaces (griddle and grate), and cast iron for pros or large gatherings. These include robust cabinets, longer warranties (up to 10 years on burners), and app connectivity in some cases, but they're less portable. Allocate budget for accessories like scrapers ($10-20) or extra propane.
The sweet spot lies in mid-range models ($120-$150), where performance rivals premiums without excess cost. For instance, the Tabletop 18” matches the 5-Burner's zoning at a fraction of the price, heating to 500°F evenly for smash burgers in under 10 minutes—ideal for most users. Budget options like the Blackstone Top perform adequately for inserts (even heat on 17-inch surfaces) but falter in wind or with large loads due to lower BTUs. Premiums excel in durability and capacity, justifying $500 for daily use, but overkill for weekends. Prioritize BTUs per dollar: the Small Portable's 20,000 BTUs at $123 yields better value than the Weber's insert-specific design. Test via user reports—mid-tier often scores 4.5+ stars for reliability.
Ignoring Compatibility: Buying inserts like the Weber 6787 without verifying grill model (e.g., Spirit E-310) leads to fit issues and returns. Always cross-check dimensions.
Underestimating Size Needs: Opting for 14-inch models for groups over 4 causes overcrowding and longer cook times. Measure your typical meal volume.
Overlooking Fuel Type Mismatch: Assuming all use standard propane tanks; some require adapters, hiking costs $20-50 extra.
Neglecting Maintenance Requirements: Choosing non-seasoned steel without planning upkeep results in rust after rain. Budget time for oiling cast iron weekly.
Prioritizing Price Over BTUs: A $90 low-BTU grill heats slowly (15+ minutes), frustrating users. Aim for at least 10,000 BTUs for efficiency.
Our top pick is the Tabletop Gas Griddle 18” ($136.49), best for versatile outdoor enthusiasts needing portability and power for 4-6 people—its 30,000 BTUs and three burners outperform budget rivals without premium bulk.
Runner-up: Small Portable Grill 14 Inch ($123.36), ideal for solo campers or couples on RV trips, offering compact 20,000 BTUs and a cover at a steal, though limited for larger groups.
Third: 5-Burner Propane Gas Griddle Grill Combo ($499.99), perfect for backyard hosts wanting pro-level 618 sq in and dual cooking, but only if space and budget allow—beats inserts for standalone use. (Word count: 742)
Flat-top grills, or griddles, feature a solid, even cooking surface (often steel or cast iron) that retains juices and fats for steaming and searing in one go, perfect for foods like eggs, stir-fries, or quesadillas. Traditional BBQ grills use open grates that allow drippings to fall onto flames, imparting smoky flavor but risking flare-ups and drier results. Flat-tops heat faster and more uniformly (e.g., the Tabletop 18” reaches 500°F in 7 minutes vs. 15 for some grate grills) but lack that char unless you use ridged inserts like the Weber 6787. For versatility, combos like the 5-Burner offer both. Choose flat-tops if you prioritize ease and multi-food cooking; stick to grates for pure smoking.
Regular maintenance extends life, especially for cast iron or steel surfaces. After each use, while hot, scrape off residue with a metal scraper (included on many models like the Small Portable). For cast iron (
Compare key specs and features of all our recommendations side-by-side
| Product | Recommendation | Rating | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
 Griddle Replacement Top for Blackstone Tailgater Combo 1555 1827 and Rec 1504 Gas Grills, Powder Coated Steel Flat Top Grill Part for Blackstone RP 90408 Rank #1 | 🏆 Top Pick | N/A | |
 Tabletop Gas Griddle with Legs, Cover - 18” Portable Propane Grill, 3 Burner Flat Top Griddle, 30,000 BTUs Output Stainless Steel for Outdoor Cooking, Camping or Tailgating Rank #2 | N/A | ||
 Small Portable Grill, 14 Inch Tabletop Gas Grill, 2 Burner Flat Top BBQ Propane Griddle with Legs, Cover - 20,000 BTUs Output for Outdoor Patio Backyard Camping, Tailgating, and RV Trips Rank #3 | — | N/A | |
 5-Burner Propane Gas Griddle Grill Combo with Porcelain-Enameled Cast Iron Grate & Cast Iron Pan, Dual BBQ Grill With Flat Top Griddle for Outdoor Kitchen & Backyard Barbecue,618 SQIN Cook Area Rank #4 | — | N/A | |
 6787 Full-Size Griddle Inserts & 7658 Cast Iron Grill Griddle for Weber Spirit 300 & Spirit II 300 Series Grills, Flat Top Griddle for Weber Spirit I & II E-310 E-320 S-310 S-320 Rank #5 | 💰 Budget Pick | N/A |
