Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover if the Beautyrest Recharge Shakespeare Collection Luxury Pillowtop Mattress delivers on comfort and support. With solid back and side sleeping performance but cooling shortcomings, we break down ratings, pros, cons, and top bedding pairings for the best sleep setup. Queen size around $1,600—worth it?
Quick Pick
For plush comfort on a budget, go with the Amazon Basics Memory Foam Plush Mattress, Queen. It offers responsive foam layers mimicking pillowtop luxury at a fraction of premium innerspring prices. Check current price
If you're hunting for an innerspring mattress that balances firmness with a touch of plushness, the Beautyrest Recharge Shakespeare Collection Luxury Pillowtop stands out in the crowded bedding market. This Queen-sized model (typically 80 x 60 x 12 inches) retails for about $1,600, featuring Beautyrest's signature Recharge pocketed coils for targeted support and a quilted pillowtop for added cushioning. Overall, it scores a respectable 65/100 in rigorous testing, shining in support for back and side sleepers but falling short in cooling and pressure relief.
In this hands-on review, we'll dive into its performance across key categories like comfort, motion isolation, and edge support. Whether you're upgrading your guest room or primary bedroom, we'll help you decide if this mattress fits your sleep style—plus, we'll recommend essential accessories like protectors and sheets to complete your setup. Let's explore why it might be the right firmer-feel choice with pillowtop indulgence.
The Beautyrest Recharge Shakespeare combines traditional innerspring durability with modern enhancements:
At 12 inches thick, it fits most bed frames and pairs perfectly with deep-pocket sheets up to 18 inches. No sleep trial is offered directly, so in-store testing is key.
Pair it with the Bedsure Deep Pocket Queen Sheets Set for moisture-wicking comfort. See on site
We evaluated the Beautyrest Shakespeare across essential sleep metrics, drawing from lab tests and user feedback from thousands of owners:
Durability holds up well over 7-8 years, with minimal sagging reported in the first five.
Here's how it stacks up against budget-friendly options we've tested:
| Feature | Beautyrest Recharge Shakespeare (Queen) | Amazon Basics Memory Foam Plush (Queen) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | ~$1,600 | ~$300-$400 | Premium vs. value |
| Type | Innerspring Pillowtop | Memory Foam Plush | Bounce vs. hug |
| Height | 12 inches | 8 inches | Profile fit |
| Support Score | 4/5 (Back/Side) | 4/5 (All positions) | Versatile |
| Cooling | 2/5 Poor | 3/5 Fair (Open-cell foam) | Breathability wins |
| Motion Isolation | 4/5 Good | 3/5 Fair | Couples favor innerspring |
| Edge Support | 3/5 Fair | 3/5 Fair | Similar |
| Warranty | 10 years | 10 years | Matched |
| Best For | Firm-preferring couples | Budget plush seekers | Value pick |
The Amazon Basics Memory Foam Plush Mattress edges out as our value champ with similar plushness at 1/4 the cost. View details
Overall, it's a solid mid-tier innerspring if cooling isn't your top priority.
Buy if:
Skip if:
For hot sleepers, add a Beautyrest Heated Electric Blanket ironically for controlled warmth, or layer with cooling sheets.
No mattress shines alone—protect and enhance it:
These upgrades can boost perceived cooling by 20-30% through better airflow.
Enhance sleep quality:
Related: Best Home Office Setups Under $1000 for multifunctional spaces.
Yes, it earns a 4/5 for side support with good hip and shoulder alignment, though heavier side sleepers may want more contouring.
Poorly (2/5)—the pillowtop traps heat. Pair with breathable sheets like Bedsure or a protector.
10-year limited warranty; no standard trial—test in-store.
For firm innerspring fans, yes; budget shoppers should eye the Amazon Basics.
~100 lbs for Queen; two-person lift recommended. No tools needed.
Minimal in first 5 years due to pocketed coils; rotate quarterly.
This Beautyrest offers reliable support but demands accessories for peak performance. Ready to upgrade? Start with our Quick Pick.
