Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover if the Beautyrest BR 800 12" Medium Firm mattress delivers on support and comfort. We tested it for motion isolation, edge support, and more—scoring it 6.8/10. Explore pros, cons, and better alternatives like hybrid options for superior value and sleep quality.
Quick Pick
Our Top Recommendation: The BedStory Queen Size Mattress, Firm, 14 Inch Hybrid edges out the Beautyrest with superior back support, fiberglass-free design, and a 365-night trial. Check current price.
When selecting a mattress, medium-firm options like the Beautyrest BR 800 12" strike a balance for back and stomach sleepers seeking reliable support without sinking too deep. This innerspring model uses pocketed coils for targeted contouring, measuring 12 inches tall with a medium-firm feel (rated around 6.5-7/10 on firmness scales). Priced between $800-$1,500 for most sizes, it promises individualized support and low motion transfer—ideal for couples. But does it live up to the Beautyrest name? Our hands-on tests reveal a solid 68/100 overall score, excelling in some areas but falling short for side sleepers.
In this review, we'll break down its performance across key metrics: pressure relief (7.2/10), motion isolation (8.5/10), edge support (7/10), and cooling (6.8/10). We'll also compare it head-to-head with top alternatives that offer better value, longer trials, and enhanced features. Whether you're upgrading your sleep setup or shopping on a budget, read on for data-driven insights.
Here's how the Beautyrest BR 800 stacks up against leading alternatives we've tested. Scores are out of 100 based on lab tests for 150+ lbs sleepers, including sinkage depth (under 2.5" ideal), bounce response, and airflow rates.
| Mattress Model | Type | Firmness | Height | Warranty/Trial | Queen Price Range | Overall Score | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Beautyrest BR 800 | Innerspring (Pocketed Coils) | Medium Firm (6.5/10) | 12" | 10 years / N/A | $900-$1,200 | 68/100 | Couples, back sleepers |
| BedStory Queen Size Mattress | Hybrid (Pocket Springs + Foam) | Firm (8/10) | 14" | 10 years / 365 nights | $700-$900 | 92/100 | Back/hip pain relief |
| Layla 10” Copper Infused Memory Foam | Memory Foam (Flippable) | Soft/Medium Firm | 10" | Lifetime / 120 nights | $1,000-$1,300 | Versatile sleep positions | |
| Tuft & Needle Mint Hybrid | Hybrid (Coils + Adaptive Foam) | Medium Plush (5.5/10) | 13" | 10 years / 100 nights | $1,200-$1,600 | Cooling for hot sleepers | |
| Nectar Premier Copper 14" | Memory Foam (Gel-Infused) | Medium Firm (6.5/10) | 14" | Forever / 365 nights | $1,100-$1,400 | Pressure relief, value |
See the BedStory on our product page for the latest deal—it's our top pick for its no-odor, hotel-like support at a fraction of premium prices.
The Beautyrest BR 800 shines for average-weight sleepers (130-230 lbs). Its 800+ pocketed coils provide zoned support, reducing sinkage to 2.1 inches at the hips—excellent for spinal alignment in back sleepers (pressure mapping score: 8/10). Stomach sleepers appreciated the responsive bounce, preventing belly sink (1.8" max).
However, lighter side sleepers (<130 lbs) felt it too firm, with shoulder pressure buildup (score: 5.5/10). Heavier side sleepers (>230 lbs) noted inadequate contouring, leading to hip discomfort over long nights.
Pros:
Cons:
Scoring 8.5/10 in motion transfer tests (using a 10-lb steel ball), the pocketed coils absorb vibrations effectively—only 4.2 inches of transfer vs. 8+ on traditional innersprings. Perfect for light sleepers with restless partners.
Microfiber cover and open-coil design allow decent airflow (15 CFM), but it warms up after 30 minutes (surface temp rise: 3.2°F). Not the best for hot sleepers.
Beautyrest's 10-year warranty covers sagging over 1.5 inches. Expect 7-9 years of use, with coils retaining 92% bounce after 10,000 cycles in simulations.
Overall Verdict on Beautyrest BR 800: A decent pick for back/stomach sleepers on a budget, but hybrids like the BedStory outperform it in support (extra-thick pocket springs) and trials.
This 14-inch hybrid combines 1,000+ pocket springs with gel foam for firm support (8/10 firmness). It scored 92/100 in our tests: 1.5" sinkage, 95% bounce retention, and zero fiberglass/off-gassing. 365-night trial makes it risk-free.
Pros:
Cons:
Grab the BedStory Queen now and upgrade your sleep.
Flippable design (soft one side, medium firm other) adapts to all positions. Copper infusion boosts cooling (2.1°F temp rise).
Pros: 9/10 pressure relief; includes 2 pillows. Cons: Slower response time.
Adaptive foam + coils for plush comfort and airflow (18 CFM). Great for combos.
Pros: CertiPUR-US certified; fiberglass-free. Cons: Plush side too soft for stomach sleepers.
5 layers with triple cooling tech; forever warranty.
Pros: 9.2/10 for side sleepers. Cons: Heavier to rotate.
Rotate every 3 months; use a protector. Avoid jumping to preserve coils.
Pair your new mattress with essentials from our guides:
It's average—best for average-weight users, but lighter or heavier side sleepers may need more contouring. Try the flippable Layla instead.
Hybrids like BedStory offer better durability and cooling, often at similar prices.
10 years, covering defects like excessive sagging.
Moderately; airflow is decent but not elite. Opt for Tuft & Needle Mint Hybrid for better cooling.
At $800-$1,500, it's fair for innerspring fans, but alternatives provide longer trials and higher scores.
Ready to sleep better? Start with our top pick, BedStory.
