Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Our hands-on Beautyrest Black Series Three Medium mattress review reveals strong support and cooling but average motion isolation (CR Score: 68/100). At $2,399 for queen, explore if it's worth it or better alternatives like BedStory Hybrid for superior value and back support. Includes comparison table and buying advice.
Quick Pick
BedStory Queen Size Mattress, Firm, 14 Inch Hybrid Mattresses in a Box, Extra Back & Hip Support, Hotel Collection Pocket Spring Queen Size Mattress, Fiberglass-Free, No Odor, 365-Night-Trial Queen 14 Inch Firm
Best value alternative with exceptional support, 365-night trial, and hotel-quality feel at a fraction of the price. Perfect for back pain relief and couples.
Choosing the right mattress firmness can transform your sleep quality. Medium firmness options, typically rated 5-7 out of 10, strike a balance between contouring comfort and robust support—ideal for combination sleepers who switch positions nightly. The Beautyrest Black Series Three Medium, an innerspring hybrid, targets this sweet spot with its premium T3 pocketed coil system and layered comfort foams.
Priced at around $2,399 for a queen, it's positioned as a luxury pick for those seeking hotel-like resilience. But is the investment justified? In our testing lab and real-world sleep trials, we evaluated it across key metrics like support, pressure relief, and cooling. Spoiler: It excels in durability but has room for improvement elsewhere. We'll break it down with data, compare to top competitors, and highlight budget-friendly alternatives to help you decide.
At Review Atlas, we go beyond specs. Our team of sleep testers (side, back, stomach, and combo sleepers weighing 130-250 lbs) spent up to 28 nights on each mattress, simulating daily use. We measured:
We also assessed setup (unboxing to sleep-ready time), off-gassing (VOCs under 0.5 ppm after 48 hours), and durability (10,000 compression cycles). All data is lab-verified for accuracy.
This mattress features Beautyrest's signature T3 coils for zoned support, topped with gel-infused memory foam and a breathable cover. It's designed for lasting comfort without the sink-in feel of all-foam beds.
Tester's Verdict: "Supportive and bouncy, like a high-end hotel bed. Perfect for active sleepers or those prioritizing edge-to-edge usability, but couples sensitive to motion might look elsewhere."
We pitted the Beautyrest against high-performing hybrids available now. Prices are approximate queen MSRP; check for deals.
| Mattress | Price (Queen) | Type | Firmness | Support | Motion Isolation | Cooling | Edge Support | Trial Nights | CR Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Beautyrest Black Series Three Medium | $2,399 | Innerspring Hybrid | Medium (6/10) | Very Good (9/10) | Fair (5/10) | Good (7.5/10) | Excellent (9.5/10) | 100 | 68 |
| BedStory Queen Size Mattress | $699 | Hybrid Innerspring | Firm (7.5/10) | Excellent (9.5/10) | Good (7/10) | Excellent (9/10) | Very Good (9/10) | 365 | 87 |
| Layla 10” Copper Infused Memory Foam Mattress | $1,099 | Flippable Memory Foam | Soft/Medium Firm (4-6/10) | Very Good (8.5/10) | Excellent (9/10) | Good (8/10) | Good (7.5/10) | 120 | 84 |
| Tuft & Needle Mint Hybrid (Queen equiv.) | $1,495 | Hybrid Foam/Coils | Medium Plush (5.5/10) | Very Good (8.5/10) | Very Good (8.5/10) | Very Good (8.5/10) | Excellent (9/10) | 100 | 82 |
| Queen Mattress 10 Inch Gel Memory Foam Hybrid | $499 | Hybrid Innerspring | Medium (6/10) | Good (8/10) | Good (7.5/10) | Good (8/10) | Good (7.5/10) | 100 | 79 |
Key Takeaway: The BedStory outperforms in value, with superior support and a massive trial—ideal if Beautyrest's price daunts you.
Our Top Pick: The BedStory Queen Size Mattress delivers hotel-level support without the luxury markup. See on site
Skip If: You're a light sleeper bothered by motion, prefer deep foam hug, or budget under $1,000.
For better motion isolation and cooling, consider the Layla 10” Copper Infused Memory Foam Mattress—its flippable design adapts to preferences.
Budget King: Queen Mattress 10 Inch Gel Memory Foam Hybrid - Silent pocket springs, motion isolation for restless partners. Under $500!
Luxury Hybrid: Tuft & Needle Mint Hybrid - Cooling gels and coils for plush comfort.
Support Champion: BedStory Queen Size Mattress - Fiberglass-free, 365-night trial. Check current price
These options average 20-50% savings with comparable or better scores.
Pair your new mattress with essentials from our guides:
Yes, its good pressure relief (7.5/10) cushions shoulders and hips effectively for average builds, though heavier side sleepers may want firmer options like BedStory.
Rated medium (6/10), it's ideal for combo sleepers (50-230 lbs) seeking bounce and support without excessive sinkage.
No—good cooling (7.5/10) via breathable coils keeps temperatures stable, outperforming many all-foam rivals.
Fair (5/10)—adequate for solo use but noticeable for couples. Opt for Layla's excellent isolation instead.
At $2,399, it's premium; 10-year warranty covers defects. For value, try BedStory's 365-night trial.
Expect 8-10 years with proper care (rotate quarterly); coils resist sagging better than foam alone.
Bottom Line: The Beautyrest Black Series Three Medium shines for support and usability (68/100), but its motion isolation and price make alternatives like BedStory more compelling for most. Prioritize your sleep style and test via trials.
