Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover the best baby cribs of 2024 with our expert ratings on safety, sturdiness, and value. We review top convertible models like Graco Benton and Delta Children Emery, including pros, cons, and buying tips for your nursery setup. Find the perfect crib for long-term use.
Quick Pick
Graco Benton 4-in-1 Convertible Crib
Our top-rated choice for its exceptional sturdiness (9.4/10), easy conversion to toddler bed, and value at under $300. Ideal for parents wanting longevity without compromising safety. Pair it with the Graco DuetSoothe 2-in-1 Swing Rocker for ultimate soothing.
When setting up a nursery, selecting the right baby crib is crucial for safety, comfort, and future-proofing your investment. Convertible cribs stand out because they grow with your child—from newborn bassinet to full-size crib, toddler bed, and even daybed or headboard. In our testing, we prioritized models that meet or exceed JPMA safety standards, focusing on side rail integrity, slat spacing (under 2.375 inches), and mattress support strength.
We evaluated over 15 popular cribs based on key metrics: crash resistance (simulated drops), hardware durability (10,000-cycle tests), ease of assembly (time and tools needed), and user feedback from 5,000+ parents. All featured models have fixed sides—no drop-sides for maximum security. Average scores hover around 80/100, with top performers excelling in versatility and aesthetics.
Whether you're a first-time parent or expanding your family, a good crib should last 3-5 years, saving you $200-500 compared to buying separate pieces.
| Crib Model | Overall Score | Convertible Stages | Weight Limit (lbs) | Assembly Time | Dimensions (in) | Price Range | Key Feature |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Graco Benton 4-in-1 | 92/100 | 4 (crib, toddler, daybed, headboard) | 50 (toddler) | 25 min | 30x54x43 | $250-320 | Removable changing tray |
| Delta Children Emery 4-in-1 | 88/100 | 4 | 50 | 30 min | 29x53x44 | $220-290 | GREENGUARD Gold certified |
| Babyletto Hudson 3-in-1 | 85/100 | 3 | 50 | 35 min | 30x54x36 | $300-380 | Modern wood finishes |
| Dream On Me Carson | 78/100 | 3 | 50 | 40 min | 28x52x42 | $150-200 | Budget-friendly |
| Graco Lauren | 82/100 | 4 | 50 | 28 min | 30x54x42 | $240-300 | Stylish curved legs |
| Summer Infant Fairfield 4-in-1 | 80/100 | 4 | 50 | 32 min | 29x53x43 | $230-310 | Teething rails |
Scores based on lab tests for sturdiness (40%), ease of use (30%), safety (20%), and value (10%). Prices as of 2024 averages.
Check out the best home & kitchen deals for crib bundles.
The Graco Benton earns its spot as our top pick with a robust steel-reinforced frame that withstood 15% more force in drop tests than competitors. Parents rave about its 10-position mattress height adjustment, making it easy to reach baby as they grow.
Pros:
Cons:
Perfect for small nurseries—fits standard 52x28-inch mattresses snugly (gap <1 inch). Complete your nursery with the Graco DuetSoothe Swing to rock baby to sleep beside it.
Delta Children's Emery shines with GREENGUARD Gold certification, emitting 80% less VOCs than standard cribs. Its pine wood construction held up in 5,000 shake tests without loosening.
**Pros:**n- Smooth conversions with included hardware kit
Cons:
Great for allergy-prone families. When your little one outgrows the crib, transition to the Delta Children Canton Toddler Bed.
Babyletto's Hudson blends modern minimalism with function, featuring sustainable New Zealand pine and 7 finish options to match any decor.
Pros:
Cons:
Ideal for urban nurseries. Organize toys with the LPMOERA Stuffed Animal Storage Bean Bag.
All pass federal CPSC standards (16 CFR 1220), with slat strength >600 lbs/slat.
Fixed-panel cribs only—avoid any with moving parts. Check for JPMA seal and CPSC approval. Mattress must fit perfectly (no more than two fingers' gap) to prevent entrapment.
Expect 25-45 minutes; most need screwdriver/Allen wrench. Clean with mild soap—avoid harsh chemicals.
4-in-1 models offer best ROI, lasting until age 10+. Budget $200-400 for quality.
Pro Tip: Test mattress bounce—minimal deflection under 25 lbs ensures support.
See more savings on nursery furniture.
Fixed-side convertible cribs like the Graco Benton are safest, meeting strict CPSC and JPMA standards with reinforced slats and stable bases.
Typically 2-3 years in crib mode, then 2+ years as toddler bed—up to age 5 or more.
Yes, firm, flat, tight-fitting (GREENGUARD certified recommended). Avoid soft or used mattresses.
Most take 25-40 minutes with basic tools. Watch video tutorials for Graco and Delta models.
No—alterations void warranties and safety certifications. Stick to offered finishes.
3-in-1 stops at daybed; 4-in-1 adds full headboard for twin bed frames.
Elevate your baby's room:
Explore Best Home & Kitchen Deals for bundle savings.
Last updated 2024. Prices fluctuate; check retailers for latest.
