Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover the best asphalt shingles for your roof in 2024. We break down top-rated options like CertainTeed Landmark and GAF Timberline HDZ based on lab tests for wind, hail, cracking resistance, and more. Compare prices, warranties, and performance to find the perfect fit for your home.
Quick Pick
CertainTeed Landmark
Top-rated for superior wind and hail resistance (up to 130 mph winds), excellent cracking protection, and a 50-year warranty. Ideal for most climates at ~$110 per square. Perfect balance of performance and affordability.
Asphalt shingles remain the go-to choice for homeowners due to their affordability, versatility, and proven longevity. In 2024, with extreme weather on the rise, selecting high-performing shingles is crucial for protecting your investment. These materials undergo rigorous testing for resistance to cracking at low temperatures, tearing under stress, thermal blistering from heat cycles, high winds, and hail impacts.
Our experts evaluated leading brands using simulated real-world conditions: wind gusts up to 150 mph, hailstones from 1-inch to 2-inch diameters, freeze-thaw cycles down to -20°F, and UV exposure equivalent to 10 years. Only shingles scoring Excellent or Very Good (80+ overall) made our list. This guide helps you pick the best for your region's weather, budget, and aesthetic needs.
Look for shingles with layered fiberglass construction and advanced granule coatings for UV and algae resistance. Top performers withstand 110-150 mph winds and Class 4 hail impacts.
Expect 30-110 years prorated against defects, plus non-prorated options for wind (up to 130 mph) and algae (10-25 years).
Prices range $90-$130 per square (100 sq ft). Factor in installation (~$4-8/sq ft) and potential energy savings from reflective granules.
Architectural (dimensional) shingles like those below offer a premium wood-shake look in 10+ colors, boosting curb appeal by 15-20% per home value studies.
Here's a side-by-side look at the highest performers. Scores are out of 100, based on weighted lab results (30% wind/hail, 25% cracking/tearing, 20% blistering, 25% overall build quality). Prices are approximates for standard colors.
| Brand & Model | Overall Score | Wind Resistance (mph) | Hail Rating | Warranty (Years) | Price per Square | Algae Protection |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CertainTeed Landmark | 84 | 130 | Class 4 | 50 Pro-rated | $110 | 15 years |
| GAF Timberline HDZ | 82 | 130 | Class 4 | Lifetime Limited | $115 | 25 years |
| IKO Cambridge | 80 | 110 | Class 3 | 38 Pro-rated | $105 | 10 years |
| Malarkey Legacy | 79 | 120 | Class 4 | 50 Pro-rated | $120 | 20 years |
| Owens Corning Duration | 78 | 130 | Class 3 | Lifetime Limited | $112 | 10 years |
| Atlas StormMaster Slate | 77 | 110 | Class 4 | 40 Pro-rated | $108 | 15 years |
| TAMKO Heritage | 76 | 110 | Class 3 | 40 Pro-rated | $100 | 10 years |
This shingle excels in every category, resisting cracks down to -25°F and tearing forces 25% above average. Its StreakFighter algae protection keeps roofs cleaner longer.
Pros:
Cons:
Perfect for coastal or stormy regions. Check out best home & kitchen deals for roofing bundles.
GAF's heavy-duty design features Dura Grip adhesive for superior sealing, passing 150 mph wind tests in independent labs.
Pros:
**Cons:**n- Premium pricing
Ideal for hurricane zones. Pair with best garden storage options for tool organization during installs.
At $105/square, it delivers 80+ scores across the board with reinforced edges for tear resistance.
Pros:
Cons:
Great for budget-conscious homeowners in moderate climates.
We simulated harsh conditions:
These exceeded industry standards by 20-30%, ensuring 30-50 year lifespans with proper install.
For related projects, see our best gardening tools for beginners to maintain your yard post-roofing.
Upgrading your roof? Explore these guides:
High-quality ones like our top picks last 30-50 years with proper ventilation and maintenance. Factors like climate and installation affect this.
Architectural (like these) are thicker, more durable, and visually appealing vs. flat 3-tab's 20-year life.
Yes, all top-rated options handle pitches over 4:12 and cold cracking down to -25°F.
$8,000-$20,000 for 2,000 sq ft, depending on pitch, location, and shingle choice. Premium shingles add 10-15% but save on repairs.
Absolutely—built-in protectors last 10-25 years. Northern homes may need zinc strips for extra defense.
CertainTeed Landmark or Malarkey Legacy with Class 4 ratings handle 2-inch hail without cracking.
