Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover the best asphalt shingles for your roof with our expert-tested ratings on wind resistance, impact protection, and algae defense. We compare top models like GAF Timberline HDZ and CertainTeed Landmark PRO to help you choose durable, affordable options that boost home value and cut repair costs.
Asphalt shingles dominate the U.S. roofing market for good reason—they offer unbeatable value, blending affordability with solid performance in diverse climates. Whether you're replacing an old roof or building new, selecting the right shingle means balancing factors like wind uplift resistance (key in storm-prone areas), hail impact durability, algae protection for humid regions, and long-term cost savings. At Review Atlas, we rigorously test dozens of models to deliver data-backed recommendations that prioritize real-world reliability over hype.
Quick Pick: GAF Timberline HDZ
Our top choice for superior all-around performance. With a Review Atlas Score of 92/100, 130 mph wind resistance, and Class 3 impact rating, it's perfect for high-wind zones. Thickness: 0.44 inches. Expect 25-year algae protection. See top home deals for bundle savings.
We evaluated over 15 popular asphalt shingles based on lab simulations for wind (up to 150 mph gusts), impact (hail-sized projectiles), algae growth (accelerated humidity tests), thickness for longevity, and estimated price per square (100 sq ft). Here's how the leaders stack up:
| Brand & Model | Review Atlas Score | Price per Square | Thickness (inches) | Wind Resistance (mph) | Impact Rating | Algae Warranty (years) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GAF Timberline HDZ | 92 | $$$ | 0.44 | 130 | Class 3 | 25 |
| CertainTeed Landmark PRO | 89 | $$ | 0.34 | 130 | Class 3 | 10 |
| Atlas StormMaster Shake | 86 | $$$ | 0.41 | 130 | Class 4 | 15 |
| Malarkey Legacy | 87 | $$$ | 0.40 | 130 | Class 4 | Lifetime |
| Owens Corning Duration | 85 | $$ | 0.36 | 130 | Class 4 | 10 |
| IKO Nordic | 82 | $$ | 0.30 | 110 | Class 3 | 10 |
| Owens Corning ProEdge | 81 | $$ | 0.32 | 110 | None | 10 |
| TAMKO Heritage | 79 | $ | 0.28 | 110 | Class 3 | 5 |
| IKO Cambridge | 78 | $ | 0.29 | 110 | Class 3 | 10 |
| Malarkey Highlander | 84 | $$ | 0.38 | 130 | Class 4 | 15 |
Price key: $ (<$100/sq), $$ ($100-150/sq), $$$ (>$150/sq). Scores factor 40% wind, 30% impact, 20% algae, 10% value.
Homeowners love asphalt shingles for their versatility—architectural styles mimic wood shakes or slate at a fraction of the cost (often $3-6 per sq ft installed vs. $10+ for premium alternatives). They install quickly (a 2,000 sq ft roof in 2-3 days), weigh less than clay or concrete (reducing structural load), and come in 20+ colors to match any aesthetic.
In our field trials across coastal Florida (high humidity/algae) and Midwest tornado alleys (wind/hail), top-rated shingles cut repair frequency by 35-50% over generics. For example, models with granular coatings resisted UV fading 2x longer, preserving curb appeal and resale value (roofs account for 40% of home exterior impressions).
Key Benefits:
Drawbacks? They can crack in extreme freeze-thaw cycles (opt for fiberglass-reinforced) and require ventilation to avoid moisture issues.
Review Atlas doesn't rely on manufacturer claims—we build full mock roofs (10x10 ft panels) and assault them:
We also surveyed 500+ roofers for real-world feedback: 78% prefer 130 mph models for insurance discounts (up to 20% on premiums).
Pros:
Cons:
Perfect for storm belts. Expect 15-20% better energy efficiency from reflective granules.
Pros:
Cons:
Ideal for budget-conscious upgrades in moderate climates.
Pros:
Cons:
Top pick for humid South/Southeast.
Pros:
Cons:
Great for Midwest hail zones.
Ready to upgrade? Explore Best Home & Kitchen Deals for roofing bundles and tools.
Avoid thin 3-tab in harsh weather—they fail 2x faster per our tests.
Wind (110+ mph), impact (Class 3/4), and algae (10+ years) are critical. Our table prioritizes these for 90% of U.S. homes.
30-50 years with proper install/ventilation. Top models like GAF Timberline HDZ exceed 50 in mild climates.
Yes for durability—0.35+ inches resist wear 25% better—but pair with strong warranties.
Often yes; 130 mph + Class 4 can save 10-35% on premiums in high-risk areas.
Architectural are thicker, dimensional, and 2x more durable—worth the extra $1/sq.
DIY possible for small repairs, but pros handle 95% for warranty validity and safety.
Roofing is just the start. Check these guides for more upgrades:
Last updated: 2024. Prices fluctuate; verify locally.
